TAMPA, Fla. — Too old, a lot of us said when the Penguins hired Jim Rutherford as general manager in June 2014.
Too much of a retread.
Sure, Rutherford’s name was on the Stanley Cup because of the Carolina Hurricanes’ magical run in 2006. But what had he done lately? The Hurricanes failed to make the playoffs in his final five seasons as their general manager.
This is the best the Penguins could do as a replacement for Ray Shero?
“We felt like we hit the lottery,” president/CEO David Morehouse said Thursday.
Easy to say now, right?
Read More
The Penguins are two wins from the Cup final and can take another step in that direction tonight in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference final against the Tampa Bay Lightning. Rutherford’s contributions to the success have been widely noted. He is a finalist for the NHL’s general manager of the year award.
But Morehouse said he, not to mention owners Ron Burkle and Mario Lemieux, believed in Rutherford last season when the Penguins were bounced out of the playoffs by the New York Rangers in five first-round games. The organization blamed that on injuries to Kris Letang and Olli Maatta. Morehouse insisted there was no talk of Rutherford’s job being in jeopardy even in December when Rutherford fired Mike Johnston as coach and replaced him with Mike Sullivan, the organization’s Wilkes-Barre/Scranton coach. Rutherford had hired Johnston to replace fired Dan Bylsma a few weeks after he took over the team.
“He’s not afraid to make mistakes and not afraid to correct them when he does,” Morehouse said. “He was willing to make a change with someone he picked because he didn’t think he was the guy who could take us where we needed to go. I’m not sure a lot of guys would have done that.”
Hiring Johnston has been one of Rutherford’s few Penguins mistakes.
“He diagnosed our problem from day one and did everything he said he was going to do to fix it,” Morehouse said. “He told us, ‘Teams are concentrating on taking away your two superstars and you can’t score goals. You need more balance. You need to bring more young players into the lineup. You need more speed.’ ”
The kids from Wilkes-Barre/Scranton — Matt Murray, Tom Kuhnhackl, Conor Sheary, Bryan Rust — have played big roles. “Jim reminded us that young guys have an impact on the rest of the team when they come up,” Morehouse said. “Every day at practice is the best day of their life. Their enthusiasm carries over to the veterans.”
Rutherford added balance by signing Matt Cullen and Eric Fehr as free agents and trading for Nick Bonino. He added speed by trading for Trevor Daley, Carl Hagelin and Justin Schultz. In his most significant move, he traded for Phil Kessel, who, along with Hagelin and Bonino, is a part of what has become the best line in hockey. Kessel has emerged as the Penguins’ top candidate for the Conn Smythe Trophy as postseason MVP.
“For some reason, lots of people don’t like Phil Kessel,” Rutherford said of initial criticism of that trade. “He was only the best player Toronto had for eight years — year in and year out — and he got the blame for everything, which was very unfair. He’s a very talented player. We all know he can score. He’s a playmaker, also. He can pass the puck as good as just about anybody in this league. I’m really happy for him because he stuck with it and it’s paid off.”
The same can be said of Rutherford.
“The moves he’s made, they’ve been unbelievable. Every single one of them,” Morehouse said. “What he’s done is extraordinary. Even when he hired Mike Sullivan for Wilkes-Barre, I remember him saying, ‘He’s an NHL coach. He’s not an American Hockey League coach.’ ”
You probably will agree that hiring has turned out pretty well for the Penguins.
“I don’t take any personal satisfaction right now,” Rutherford said. “This is a team thing. We have a good group of players. We have a good coaching staff. We have great ownership. I don’t take any satisfaction because we haven’t gotten to where we want to go at this point.”
Rutherford is 67. Morehouse said the organization hopes he stays around for a while. “He’s perfect for Pittsburgh.” Rutherford, for his part, said he isn’t looking past Game 4 tonight.
“I’ve made it two years. At this point, we’ll just leave it at that.”
I asked Rutherford if he thought he might follow Johnston out the door if the Sullivan hiring didn’t work out.
“I’m not worried about myself. I’ve been around a long time,” he said. “If you want me to leave today, I’ll leave.”
That’s not what I want at all. I hope Rutherford becomes a much older man on the job as long as he keeps making moves that work. I’m prepared to pay him my highest compliment and put him next to this town’s other terrific general managers, the Steelers’ Kevin Colbert and the Pirates’ Neal Huntington.
“We really do have an embarrassment of riches,” Morehouse said. “Think about a city our size that doesn’t have hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue. Then, think about the success that we’re having.”
I do every day.
It never fails to amaze me.
We’re pretty lucky here, you know?
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.