WASHINGTON — The Penguins said all the right things late Saturday night about how they wasted a great opportunity to eliminate the Washington Capitals in Game 5 of their Stanley Cup playoff series. But the truth? The Penguins can’t be too upset about their 3-1 loss at Verizon Center. In fairness, they had this defeat coming. They were fortunate to have a 3-1 series lead after the Capitals won the first game in overtime and the next three games were so tight, all going the Penguins’ way by one goal. It would have been greedy to ask for or expect four consecutive wins against a Capitals team that had a 120-point regular season. The Capitals didn’t even lose three games in a row until early April, long after they had clinched the Presidents’ Trophy. They aren’t going to go out quietly.
“That’s a really good team,” defenseman Ben Lovejoy said.
The Penguins didn’t deserve to win — blame dumb penalties and one bad turnover — but they still have control of the series with that 3-2 edge. They wouldn’t trade places with the Capitals with Game 6 Tuesday night at Consol Energy Center.
“For long stretches of the game, I thought we were the better team,” Penguins coach Mike Sullivan said. “I liked our game. I liked our team. I thought we played fast. But we knew this wasn’t going to be easy. We’ll get ready for the next game. All we’ve got to do is win one game.”
Maybe you’re worried, anyway.
You remember the 2011 playoffs when the Penguins blew a 3-1 series lead against the Tampa Bay Lightning and lost in seven games. You also remember the 2014 playoffs when they led the New York Rangers, 3-1, and lost the final three games.
Read More
Are you thinking it could happen again?
I’m not.
This Penguins team is better and deeper than those other teams. It has been playing terrific hockey, parts of Saturday night aside. It hasn’t lost two games in a row since Jan. 12 and Jan. 15 when it was beaten on the road by Carolina and Tampa Bay. I’m not seeing three consecutive losses now, not even against a club as powerful as the Capitals.
“This team has done a remarkable job of making sure we respond the right way,” Sullivan said.
Of course, they sang a different song in the Capitals room. They sounded energized and confident after getting this win. They said they can’t wait for Game 6.
“The series can change so quickly,” coach Barry Trotz said.
We’ll see.
What we know for sure is the Capitals capitalized on Penguins penalties Saturday night, getting power-play goals by Alex Ovechkin and T.J. Oshie. A slashing call on defenseman Ian Cole early in the second period was especially punishing for the Penguins because it was a retaliation penalty on Capitals pest Tom Wilson. Sullivan clearly wasn’t happy and was even more upset when Oshie made the Penguins pay, scoring on the rebound of an Ovechkin shot for a 2-1 lead.
The goals by Ovechkin and Oshie marked the first time in the series that the Penguins penalty-kill cracked. The Capitals came in 1 for 12 on the power play. Cole had been a big part of the Penguins’ success, leading their defensemen in short-handed time, but you can’t defend when you are in the box.
“They are really good on their power play,” Lovejoy said. “They have a shooting mentality that can make you uncomfortable. We’ve got to be a little more disciplined. We dug ourselves a hole with the penalties. But we feel those mistakes are correctable.”
Another Penguins blunder — a turnover in his end by defenseman Brian Dumoulin — led to a goal by Justin Williams that made it, 3-1. Williams intercepted Dumoulin’s clearing attempt and fired a wrist shot that somehow dribbled through rookie goaltender Matt Murray’s legs.
“He’s been so good for us,” Lovejoy said of Dumoulin. “He’ll come out and be great again.”
Murray thought he should have made the save on Williams’ shot.
“I think he got pretty lucky on that one.”
The two-goal lead was more than enough for Washington netminder Braden Holtby. Holtby, who tied the NHL single-season wins record with 48, showed why he’s going to win the Vezina Trophy. He was especially good late in the second period when he made consecutive terrific saves to rob Patric Hornqvist and Justin Schultz in close. They were his best saves of the series.
Holtby was the difference.
Murray couldn’t quite match him.
But, no, in case you’re wondering, it’s not time for the Penguins to go back to Marc-Andre Fleury in net. Murray wasn’t bad enough to force that change. This was just his second loss in eight starts in this postseason.
“I think he’s been great every game he’s ever played in this uniform,” Lovejoy said. “He has been a stud back there for us. We didn’t give him enough support tonight. We gave them too many opportunities and they stung us.”
Murray deserves another start in Game 6.
I expect him to win it.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette and Twitter @RonCookPG. Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays, 10 a.m.-2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.