You know what I thought after watching Brooks Orpik knock Olli Maatta into next week Saturday night with a vicious cheap shot?

Two things …

I couldn’t believe Orpik — one of the great teammates in any sport — letting down his Washington Capitals guys. He will miss the next three games of the Penguins-Capitals playoff series after being suspended for his elbow-to-the-head hit on Maatta early in Game 2. His absence will be a severe blow to the Capitals defense. They are a much lesser team without him.

I also thought about how hypocritical so many of us are. We are outraged that Orpik did that to Maatta, who could miss significant time with an apparent head injury, and wanted the NHL to come down on him even harder. Yet we loved Orpik when he delivered those dangerous hits when he played for the Penguins. It was perfectly fine that he delivered borderline-to-dirty hits to Erik Cole, Derek Stepan and Jonathan Toews — among others — and had been suspended twice. It was good, hard hockey, right? Of course, we loved Ulf Samuelsson and Darius Kasparaitis, too. It didn’t matter to us that they were dirty players. They played for the home team.

Advertise with us

Orpik should be ashamed of himself for that hit on Maatta.

We should be ashamed of ourselves for our sanctimoniousness.

I’m not sure who should be more embarrassed.

ORPIK’S HIT TO PENGUINS DEFENSEMAN MAATTA:

Orpik, who played in more games than any Penguins defenseman, was considered such a good teammate that the Penguins voted him their Players’ Player award — their highest honor — four years in a row. Paul Martin summed up the belief in the team’s room when he wrote in The Players’ Tribune, “Brooksy taught everybody what it meant to be a consummate professional.”

Advertise with us

Even near the end, when it became clear Orpik would have to leave as a free agent for a rich contract after the 2013-14 season, he was praised for helping his younger teammates, Maatta among them. “I know Olli plays like he’s 27, but he’s watching us,” Orpik said, including Martin and Kris Letang as veteran mentors. Orpik never shortchanged any of the kids.

But Orpik made a lot of enemies of opposing players, coaches and fans while he was here. He was especially infuriating because he played a physical game but refused to fight when challenged to answer for his hits. I’m convinced that’s why Boston enforcer Shawn Thornton pummeled Orpik with extra zeal during a game in 2013, hitting him repeatedly when he was down. Orpik left the ice that night on a stretcher and missed eight games with a concussion. Thornton was suspended for 15 games.

Orpik’s boarding hit on Cole of Carolina in 2006 resulted in a three-game suspension. He had a questionable hit on Chicago’s Toews late in the 2013-14 season. His knee-to-knee hit on the New York Rangers’ Stepan in 2012 left Stepan’s coach, John Tortorella, livid. Tortorella called the play “a cheap, dirty hit” and went off on the Penguins, describing them as “one of the most arrogant teams in the league” and calling Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin, “two whining stars.” Orpik received a 5-minute kneeing penalty and game misconduct but didn’t receive supplemental discipline from the NHL office. Tortorella was fined $20,000 for his comments.

Mike Sullivan was a loyal, devoted Tortorella assistant coach at the time.

The guess here is Sullivan has come around to liking Crosby and Malkin, but his feelings toward Orpik only have worsened.

Advertise with us

Sullivan declined to discuss Orpik’s possible suspension after Penguins practice Sunday but said a night earlier: “I thought it was a late hit. I thought it was a target to his head. I think it’s the type of hit that everyone in hockey is trying to remove from the game.” Sullivan did say Sunday that he was “not optimistic” Maatta will play tonight.

The Penguins shared Sullivan’s belief about Orpik’s hit. They kept using the word “late” to describe it.

“Olli didn’t need to get hit there,” Phil Kessel said.

It was a bad hit, even by Orpik’s standards, much worse than Tom Wilson’s knee-on-knee hit on Penguins winger Conor Sheary in Game 1. Wilson was fined $2,403.67 by the NHL.

The league office called Orpik’s hit “unacceptably high and excessively late” when announcing his suspension Sunday night.

Advertise with us

None of the Penguins who played with Orpik should have been shocked by the hit. It was clear Letang wasn’t surprised Saturday night when he took a punch in the face from Orpik after a battle in front of the net late in the second period.

“Playoff hockey. He doesn’t want anyone near his goalie,” Letang said Sunday, fairly shrugging. “Sometimes in the playoffs, you’re on that edge. You either cross it or you stay right on the other side. These things happen.”

Often, Orpik stays on the right side of the line. Remember the 2008 Stanley Cup final against Detroit? He had four hits in a 15-second span in Game 3 and became a Pittsburgh sports hero. All were clean.

But fairly frequently, Orpik steps over that line. He didn’t just do it Saturday night. He did it here many times.

Remember that before you criticize the NHL for not coming down harder on Orpik.

Advertise with us

Don’t be a hypocrite.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter @RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.