NEW YORK — Just about everything went right for the Penguins Tuesday night when they beat the New York Rangers in Game 3 of their Stanley Cup playoff series. Kid goaltender Matt Murray was strong in his first NHL postseason appearance and gives the team legitimate hope going forward without concussed Marc-Andre Fleury. The defense — especially the penalty-kill — was terrific. Sidney Crosby kept rolling with his second goal in the three games, a power-play goal that was his first in, almost unbelievably, 28 playoff games. Phil Kessel showed again why the Penguins traded for him in the offseason by getting the primary assist on Crosby’s goal, Kessel’s fourth point of the series. The team even got a big break from the game officials, who missed an obvious high-stick penalty on Kris Letang in the third period, and then from the NHL office, which chose not to suspend Letang after reviewing his stick work. They got very lucky there.

But there was one major Penguins problem.

Evgeni Malkin.

The Penguins might be able to win the Rangers series without getting much from Malkin, but they won’t win the Stanley Cup.

Advertise with us

I thought Malkin would play much better in Game 3 than he did in Game 2 Saturday, his first game since leaving the lineup March 11 with an arm injury. I predicted as much in Sunday’s column. Yes, I’d like to have that one back. Malkin was much worse. He was so bad that it makes you wonder if he’s healthy. For purposes here, I’m going to assume he is. He’s playing, right? He did go 3-3 in six faceoffs in Game 3 after not taking any in Game 2. He also had three shots on net after not getting any on in Game 2.

But Malkin played lazy defense on the Rangers’ goal by Chris Kreider that was disallowed because of an offside call. He pinched too far up ice on Rick Nash’s short-handed goal. He took a bad tripping penalty in the offensive zone at the end of a long shift.

Malkin played so poorly that he was benched for the final 5½ minutes of the game. He played just 3 minutes in the third period. His 13:30 of ice time was his fewest in a playoff game since his rookie year in 2007.

I can’t blame Mike Sullivan for any of that.

That doesn’t mean it was easy for Sullivan. Figuring out the best way to use Malkin has become his biggest challenge. Malkin is one of the world’s great players. Like Crosby, Letang and other players of that ilk, he has a big ego. It couldn’t have been easy for him to watch the other players decide Game 3 down the stretch.

Advertise with us

“No, no, no!” Malkin insisted Wednesday after the Penguins practice at Madison Square Garden. “It’s OK for me. We win game. I’m glad. It doesn’t matter who plays the last 4 or 2 minutes of game.”

It sounded nice. But I’m not buying it.

None of this can be easy for Malkin. That the Penguins went 13-2 down the stretch of the regular season and won Game 1 against the Rangers without him. That he has done little to contribute in his two playoff games other than secondary assists on two power-play goals. That he has been dropped to what amounts to the team’s third line. That he played so little in the third period of an important postseason match.

Sullivan didn’t help Malkin by the way he used him in the Game 2 loss to the Rangers. He started Malkin as the center on a line with Conor Sheary and Bryan Rust before moving him to left wing on Crosby’s line. Sullivan made it clear he didn’t want to break up the Carl Hagelin-Nick Bonino-Kessel line because it had been playing so well. That’s fine. But he was willing to break up the Chris Kunitz-Crosby-Patric Hornqvist line after Crosby and Hornqvist combined for seven points in Game 1? It didn’t make sense because Malkin and Crosby haven’t played especially well together in the past.

Sullivan started Malkin at center with Sheary and Eric Fehr in Game 3 but eventually bumped Sheary to the Crosby line and dropped Kunitz to the Malkin line. Nothing wrong with that. Malkin and Kunitz have a nice history together. Kunitz was one of Malkin’s linemates when Malkin scored 50 goals in 2011-12.

Advertise with us

“I like him. I know him a long time,” Malkin said. “We played together a long time. He’s a good player, a smart player. We understand each other. I’m glad to play with him.”

Kunitz, at 36, still has game left. Other than Hornqvist, he’s probably the Penguins’ most physical player. Maybe he will get Malkin going. Someone has to do it if the Penguins are going to seriously compete for the Cup.

Sullivan said Wednesday he has talked to Malkin about not trying to do too much.

“He can be such a dynamic player with the puck. He’s a difference-maker, but it’s important that he plays the game the right way within the team concept that we’ve established. Everybody needs to buy into that collective effort. I think Geno understands that, and he’s getting more comfortable with it with every shift that he plays.”

Progress is nice, but results will be better.

Advertise with us

“Oh, yeah, of course,” Malkin said when asked if he thinks his goals are coming. “Just shoot a couple of times and score one time, the confidence will come. I feel better every day. Work hard every practice.

“Yeah, it’s coming.”

Tonight in Game 4 won’t be too soon for the Penguins.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.