The Pirates are 5-5, the definition of mediocre. They played a thoroughly mediocre game Thursday against the Detroit Tigers at PNC Park and got what they deserved, a 7-4 loss. They failed to hit a home run again and failed too often to get a big hit. When they did get a clutch hit, they ran themselves out of a possible big inning with a major, inexcusable coaching blunder. It’s been going that way for nearly a week. This was the Pirates’ fifth loss in six games after their 4-0 start. It’s been only 10 games, but the team is trending downward.
There was some good news, though.
After a rough spring and — for lack of a better description — a mediocre first start against the Cincinnati Reds, Gerrit Cole took a step toward becoming the elite pitcher he was last season. He clearly was pleased that he made it through six strong innings against a tough lineup and could have gone another. He was even more pleased that he lived to tell about it.
Leading off the sixth, Tigers starter Jordan Zimmerman hit a line shot through the middle that got a piece of Cole’s head and sent his ball cap flying. He went down as if he had been shot, probably more frightened at the thought of what might have been than actually hurt. An inch or two lower? The results could have been horrifying. Cole was checked out by trainer Ben Potenziano, stayed in the game and finished the inning.
“Luckily, I was able to get out of the way for the most part,” Cole said. “It didn’t get me that good.”
This wasn’t a first for Cole. Pitching for Class AA Altoona in June, 2012, he took a line drive off his face and somehow finished that inning, as well. He was able to make his next start.
“I got clocked,” Cole said of that 2012 incident, adding he remembered the horrible feeling of the ball coming at his head. He then grinned and quickly said, “Well, no,” he didn’t remember it.
You would have put it out of your mind, too.
It was easy for Cole to laugh off Zimmerman’s at-bat. He knew he was lucky. Even his 0-2 record couldn’t ruin his mood.
“I was much sharper today,” Cole said. “The stuff was much more defined. It’s a good feeling when you can walk away knowing that you’ve improved from the last start.”
Cole gave up three runs, five hits and three walks in 4⅔ innings in the loss to the Reds Saturday. This time, he allowed two runs, four hits and a walk in his six innings. He breezed through three perfect innings before Ian Kinsler led off the fourth with a bloop single to left-center. Two outs later, with Justin Upton now on first base, Cole made a pickoff attempt before a 3-2 pitch to J.D. Martinez only to see the ball roll down the right-field line. First baseman John Jaso had been instructed by the Pirates dugout to play behind Upton because Upton was going to be running on the pitch, anyway. No one was there to catch Cole’s throw.
“It was just a lack of communication on our part,” Cole said.
“At the end of the day, that’s my responsibility,” manager Clint Hurdle said.
Upton made it to third base on the error that was charged to Cole. Upton and Martinez, who eventually walked, both scored when Nick Castellanos hit a double over Andrew McCutchen’s head in center field. The Pirates have been playing their outfielders shallower this season, based on the advice of their metrics crunchers. This time, it bit them in the behind.
That didn’t take away from Cole’s outing, Hurdle said.
“I thought he pitched extremely well today. He just needs to keep going.”
Cole deserved better than the loss.
The Pirates hitters let Cole down, leaving the bases loaded in the first and fifth innings and stranding two runners in the third. Just one big hit – a home run, perhaps? – would have made it a different game. But the team isn’t built to win with power after losing Pedro Alvarez and Neil Walker in the off-season. They have hit just three home runs in the 10 games.
“I don’t look at what we don’t have,” Hurdle said. “I look at the opportunities that we were able to create and we’ve been creating. We’re doing a lot of good things. We’re not getting the hit that can create separation.”
The bullpen let Cole down late. Rob Scahill gave up two runs in the seventh inning and, almost unbelievably, Tony Watson gave up three in the eighth, two coming on a home run by Castellanos, who had himself quite a day. It’s always shocking when Watson gives up anything.
“I guess it just reminds you that these guys are human beings,” Hurdle said.
Third-base coach Rick Sofield is among that group, but there is no defending his decision to send Jaso home on McCutchen’s double in the eighth. The Pirates trailed, 7-3, at the time and had one out. Jaso was thrown out at the plate.
Hurdle acknowledged a better awareness of the situation was needed. “Today’s a call you don’t ever want to go that way. It wasn’t what we wanted to have happen.”
Not much has gone right for the Pirates during this mini-slide. But the sight of Cole walking out of the clubhouse made one thing clear. A lousy day at the ballpark could have been so much worse.
rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.