This goes back to April 2003, to the day when Pitt promoted Jamie Dixon to replace Ben Howland as its men’s basketball head coach. The news was not well-received after a season when Pitt won 28 games and the Big East Conference regular-season and tournament championships and made it to the Round of 16 in the NCAA tournament.

“There are very few ways to screw up a top-10 men’s basketball program. Pitt found one yesterday,” some fool wrote in the Post-Gazette. “There are dozens and dozens of qualified, proven head coaches between Pitt’s first choice as Ben Howland’s replacement — Skip Prosser, the ACC coach of the year — and the man it weakly settled for — Jamie Dixon, who has no head coaching experience. Why couldn’t Pitt find one?

“This is insanity.”

I was that fool.

Advertise with us

I learned my lesson.

I am going to give Kevin Stallings a chance.

Based on Twitter reaction, I am in the minority. I guess I understand that. I’m just not quite sure what coach Pitt fans expected to get after the Millers — Sean and Archie — made it clear neither was the least bit interested in coming back to coach his hometown team.The Millers did so for the best of reasons. Now that Pitt is in the ACC, the position isn’t nearly as good as it was when Pitt played in the Big East. Pitt is a middle-of-the-pack ACC program — nothing more — because it’s so much harder for it to recruit players from the Northeast to play in the ACC.

But the masses have spoken. They clearly think Pitt could have done better than Stallings. His hiring is being trashed just about everywhere. Stallings is a tired coach, the critics say. He is 55. His star isn’t rising the way the Miller boys’ stars are rising. Stallings certainly isn’t considered a hot coaching commodity the way James Franklin was when he left Vanderbilt for Penn State after the 2013 football season. Stallings was so stale after 17 seasons at Vanderbilt that Vanderbilt reportedly was considering firing him.

It’s all true.

Advertise with us

But I learned from the Dixon hiring the danger of rushing to judgment. Dixon won a school-record 31 games in his first season at Pitt and took his team to another Round of 16 in the NCAA tournament. He led Pitt to the NCAAs in his first eight seasons, 11 of 13 overall. He had an incredible run at Pitt even though he, too, grew stale at the end. He knew it. That’s why he took the job at TCU last week.

I also am willing to give Pitt athletic director Scott Barnes a chance with the Stallings hiring. Barnes has a basketball background. He knows people in the game. I’m going to trust he sees something in Stallings that most people don’t, at least until proven otherwise. There’s no way Stallings was Barnes’ first choice, but that’s OK. Prosser — not Dixon — was Pitt’s first choice in 2003. Go back even longer, to 1969. Chuck Noll wasn’t the Steelers’ first choice. Joe Paterno turned down the job. That turned out pretty well for the Steelers.

I’m not suggesting Stallings will have the same success that Noll or even Dixon did. I believed from the minute Dixon left that, although it was time for him to move on, his departure probably won’t end happily for him or for Pitt. Dixon won’t be as successful at TCU — a lower-level program in the powerful Big 12 Conference — as he was at Pitt. Stallings has a chance to win next season because Pitt returns every key player but point guard James Robinson from a team that was one of the final teams selected to the NCAA tournament this season. But, over the long haul, he won’t be as successful as Dixon.

Of course, I’ve been wrong before. Just ask Dixon. He will tell you.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.