Pirates general manager Neal Huntington finished second to Toronto’s Alex Anthopoulos for baseball’s 2015 Executive of the Year award. If Huntington can successfully solve the conundrum with Pedro Alvarez, Neil Walker and Mark Melancon in the next few months, he will be the early favorite for 2016.

The three players are eligible for big raises next year through salary arbitration, then can become free agents after the season. Huntington must walk the fine line between doing what’s right for the 2016 Pirates and keeping them competitive in 2017 and beyond. Keeping Walker and Melancon for one more year by paying each more than $10 million would give the 2016 team its best chance. Easy call, right? Hardly. Walker and Melancon then could leave as free agents with relatively little compensation, seriously weakening the franchise in the seasons ahead.

Huntington is strongly considering trading Walker and Melancon based on comments he made last week.

“We wouldn’t be doing our jobs if we didn’t explore what might be out there,” he told MLB.com. “How do we take a player with one year of arbitration left and potentially look to turn that into two players with multiple years of contribution or one player that has a significant number of years of contribution remaining?”

Advertise with us

Alvarez is left out of this conversation because it’s almost certain he will not be back in 2016. Management, not to mention manager Clint Hurdle, has to be tired of watching Alvarez’s defensive struggles. If the Pirates can’t trade him — it is believed they have been trying for more than a year — they are expected to non-tender him and allow him to leave as a free agent. There is no way they take him to arbitration again and get stuck with an $8 million contract for 2016.

Walker is a much tougher call than Alvarez because he is a better overall player. The Jung Ho Kang knee injury also must be considered. There is no guarantee he will be ready to play third base at the start of next season with Josh Harrison moving to second base. If Huntington can’t get what he wants for Walker in a trade, he likely will decide to keep him for one more season, swallow hard and pay him $11 million.

“We can afford players,” Huntington said last month. “The challenge is how do we afford a championship-caliber club. It’s not just that we want Player X. Player X allows us to do Y and Z. Player Z allows us to do A and B. It’s a puzzle that you put together. There’s no easy answer to it.”

Melancon’s situation is the most confounding. He was baseball’s best closer last season with 51 saves in 53 chances. But Huntington has acknowledged he is hesitant to pay big money to a closer. In the Pirates’ case with Melancon, it would be about 10 percent of their 2016 payroll. Huntington has shown he isn’t afraid to trade a top closer under similar circumstances. After the 2012 season, he traded Joel Hanrahan, coming off two consecutive All-Star appearances and with one year of arbitration left, and infielder Brock Holt to the Boston Red Sox for, of all players, Melancon and pitcher Stolmy Pimentel. That deal turned out great for the Pirates despite Holt developing into an All-Star. Hanrahan has had arm trouble since he left and pitched in just nine games, all in 2013.

But the Pirates are a different team than they were in 2012. It’s reasonable to think they can compete again for a National League Central Division championship next season. A big part of their success the past two seasons was the back end of their bullpen with Tony Watson and Melancon. They shortened games to seven innings. That has become so critical in today’s baseball. The Kansas City Royals, anyone? The Pirates believe Watson can take over as closer, especially because he’s mastered a slider to go with his fastball. That’s understandable. Watson is terrific and appears to have the mentality to get the final three outs, the toughest three in any game. But who pitches the eighth inning for Watson? Jared Hughes? Arquimedes Caminero?

Advertise with us

“To have that lock-down bullpen that we’ve had, it’s something that’s very intriguing,” Huntington said.

That probably won’t be enough to prevent the Pirates from trading Melancon. There’s no way they keep him and Walker and pay them a combined 20 percent of their payroll.

That’s too bad.

Let’s see what Huntington gets back for Melancon and perhaps Walker before we pass final judgment. Maybe he’ll get the first baseman the Pirates desperately need. Maybe he’ll add to the rotation, another area of need, especially if the team can’t bring back free agent J.A. Happ. Maybe we’ll forget about Melancon and/​or Walker.

Or maybe not.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.