SAN DIEGO — Go back to Sept. 4, 1983. Hall of Famer-to-be John Elway made his NFL debut against the Steelers at Three Rivers Stadium. He completed 1 of 8 passes for 14 yards and threw an interception before being benched at halftime because of a sore elbow and a bruised ego.

“He had no teeth and he was slobbering all over himself,” Elway allegedly said later of Steelers linebacker Jack Lambert. “I’m thinking, ‘You can have the money back. Just get me out of here. Let me go be an accountant.’ ”

That’s beautiful.

I thought of Elway when Keith Butler made his debut as Steelers defensive coordinator Sept. 10 against the New England Patriots. It did not go well. There was too much Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski. There was confusion and chaos. There were plays with 10 Steelers defenders on the field.

Advertise with us

It seemed fair to ask Butler if he had questions about his career choice.

“No, I don’t think so,” he said last week. “This is something I want to do. I want to try to be a good defensive coordinator here and try to help these guys win a championship. Unless we win a championship, it’s a failure to me.”

Butler has much work to do to get to that point, but his defense has improved significantly since that rotten start in Foxborough. It sacked San Francisco quarterback Colin Kaepernick five times in a 43-18 home win. It didn’t allow a touchdown in a 12-6 win at St. Louis. It played well enough in a 23-20 home overtime loss to Baltimore with five more sacks and two turnovers. Its 14 sacks in four games ranked fourth in the NFL after Week 4. It has forced four turnovers, including an interception in each of the past two games.

Butler won’t gloat. One reason is his defense allowed the Ravens to run for 191 yards. “I’ve got to make some better calls,” he said. “We were trying to get them on play-action pass and they caught us a couple of times in those defenses. It wasn’t the players’ fault. It was more my fault.” Another reason is Ravens quarterback Joe Flacco was able to connect for a 20-yard pass to wide receiver Kamar Aiken on third-and-10 late in regulation to set up the tying field goal. “We didn’t make enough stops,” Butler said. “It’s as plain and simple as that.”

Butler knows he and his defense are only as good as the next game — tonight against the Chargers in San Diego. This is his 13th season with the Steelers. He knows how quickly he can go from genius to idiot.

Advertise with us

“I’ve always said the bandwagon is a full ride,” Butler said. “Every time you do something good, everybody jumps on the bandwagon. Boy, you’re smart, back on top. But every time you screw up, you’re the most ignorant guy in the world. Why are you coaching? Everybody questions everything that you’re doing. That’s the way the league is. Now if I can just keep my wife from listening to it … ”

It has been all good lately.

The Steelers defensive front of Cam Heyward, Steve McLendon and Stephon Tuitt has been stout. Tuitt has 3½ sacks, Heyward 2. Tuitt made consecutive fourth-quarter stops against the Ravens to prevent a first down on third-and-1 and fourth-and-1 plays.

Butler talked about the “plethora of daggone riches” at inside linebacker with Lawrence Timmons as well as Sean Spence and Vince Williams, who are replacing injured Ryan Shazier. Timmons leads the team in tackles. Spence stopped a Ravens fake-punt attempt. Shazier will miss his third game in a row tonight with a shoulder injury.

Butler mentioned the depth at outside linebacker where Arthur Moats and Jarvis Jones have alternated effectively with James Harrison and Bud Dupree. Dupree has 2 sacks, Moats 1½. The ageless Harrison sacked Flacco with 2:04 left in regulation, a play that should have won the game.

Advertise with us

The surprise has been the play of the secondary. It is not happening the way Butler envisioned it. Antwon Blake and Will Allen have taken over from Cortez Allen and Shamarko Thomas. Will Allen had a late interception against St. Louis. Ross Cockrell, who has emerged as the third cornerback, had an interception and fumble recovery against Baltimore.

“Carnell Lake has done a good job coaching those guys up,” Butler said. “They are relying on each other and trusting each other.”

The Chargers are another test. Quarterback Philip Rivers has thrown for 1,248 yards, most in the NFL after four games.

“If we get a little bit of pressure and cover a little bit, we’ll be fine,” Butler said.

That is not a man who has doubts about his ability to coach.

Advertise with us

Butler waited a long time for this opportunity. He said he had “four or five chances” to become a defensive coordinator elsewhere in the NFL but decided to wait patiently as Steelers linebackers coach during Hall of Famer Dick LeBeau’s long, successful run as coordinator. LeBeau was not retained after last season because Mike Tomlin did not want to lose Butler. LeBeau moved on to run the Tennessee Titans defense.

“It was a very difficult situation. The transition. But I knew that going in,” Butler said.

“Mike has been good to me. The Rooneys have been good to me for a long time. I just always thought it would be easier for me to go to the Super Bowl as a coordinator here than it would be anywhere else. The Rooneys are patient. They’re not knee-jerk reaction people. They’re going to see things through and give you a chance to develop a good defense. Some other place might not give you that chance.”

Tomlin believes in Butler. The Rooneys believe. That’s why they encouraged LeBeau to leave. That won’t change no matter what happens tonight.

“I don’t know, I might be the dumbest sucker that ever laid an egg after this ballgame,” Butler said, grinning.

Advertise with us

Butler will take his chances with his guys and live with the results. That’s what makes a great coach, a great defense, a great team. There is no fear of failure.

So it is with Butler.

His fear doesn’t kick in until the morning after a loss.

When Mrs. Butler turns on talk radio.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.