Blame Gerrit Cole for the Pirates’ 4-0 National League wild-card loss Wednesday night to the Chicago Cubs. He was no match for Cubs ace Jake Arrieta. Two Chicago hitters and 10 Cole pitches in, the Pirates trailed, 1-0. Two innings later, they were down, 3-0, after Kyle Schwarber hit a Cole pitch into the night. Game over.

Blame the Pirates offense. The hitters can talk all they want about hitting the ball hard and about Arrieta getting a wide strike zone from home-plate umpire Jeff Nelson. The truth is they were abysmal, continuing a depressing postseason trend. A year ago in the wild-card game against San Francisco, the Pirates were beaten, 8-0, by Madison Bumgarner. In the 2013 playoffs against the St. Louis Cardinals, they lost Game 5, 6-1, to Adam Wainwright and Game 4, 2-1, to Michael Wacha. That’s a total of two runs in the past four playoff games. “That’s shocking,” Andrew McCutchen said. Sad, too.

Blame McCutchen. He has not hit a home run or driven in a run in eight playoff games. And they say Barry Bonds was bad in October.

Blame Neil Walker and Pedro Alvarez. If Wednesday night was their final game in a Pirates uniform, they couldn’t have gone out in a worse way. Walker went 0 for 3, and is 0 for 26 with nine strikeouts in the past seven playoff games. Alvarez struck out three times.

Advertise with us

Blame Starling Marte, arguably the Pirates’ hottest hitter. He went 0 for 4 and is 2 for 27 in the past seven postseason games. And they say Andy Van Slyke and Bobby Bonilla were bad in October.

Blame manager Clint Hurdle for starting Sean Rodriguez at first base instead of Alvarez or Aramis Ramirez. That was something Hurdle did just 12 times in the regular season, most recently July 25. So why now? Why in the biggest game of the year?

Heck, blame the Gatorade cooler in the Pirates dugout. Rodriguez certainly did. If only his teammates had attacked Arrieta with the same passion. At least Rodriguez apologized Thursday via Twitter to the cooler. No word if the cooler accepted.

Do you notice a pattern here?

There is plenty of blame to share.

Advertise with us

“It’s tough because we definitely felt like we had the team to be able to go,” McCutchen said. “I wouldn’t be surprised if [the Cubs] end up in the World Series.”

This should have been the Pirates’ year. The Cardinals are vulnerable because of a staggering run of injuries. The New York Mets and Los Angeles Dodgers have major flaws. The Pirates went 6-0 against the Mets this season, 5-1 against the Dodgers.

The Pirates wasted a wonderful opportunity by coming up so small against Arrieta and the Cubs. Cole. The hitters. Hurdle. All of ’em. Maybe they shouldn’t be regarded as failures after the team won 98 games in a magical regular season. But it is fair, at this point, to regard them as underachievers. They are too good to go out so quickly and so quietly.

“It [stinks],” McCutchen said.

The worst part is there is no guarantee the Pirates will be in this position again soon. When the early 1990s Pirates underachieved by losing three consecutive years in the playoffs, it was assumed they would take a step back because they didn’t have the financial means to compete. But who had them losing for the next 20 years?

Advertise with us

These Pirates should be competitive next season and for a few seasons after that. McCutchen is signed through the 2018 season, Marte through 2021. The team has contractural control over Cole through 2019 and Gregory Polanco through 2020. The four players are a nice start for any organization.

But, again, there is no guarantee.

Would you really be shocked if the Pirates don’t make the playoffs next season with the always-strong Cardinals and the rising Cubs in their division?

Certainly, it will be a much different Pirates team.

Ramirez and A.J. Burnett are retiring.

Advertise with us

Walker and Alvarez could be traded — likely will be traded — before the spring when they are eligible for salary arbitration one final time. Walker, who made $8 million this season and likely will push over $10 million next season, admitted late Wednesday night to thinking he might have played his final game for his hometown team. “I’d be lying if I said no.”

Closer Mark Melancon also could be traded because he should get a raise through arbitration from $5.4 million this year to $9 million or $10 million next season after his 51-save year.

J.A. Happ could go as a much-coveted free agent, leaving behind a rotation with veterans Francisco Liriano, Charlie Morton and Jeff Locke.

Jung Ho Kang might not be ready for the start of next season because of his devastating knee injury. He might never be the same player.

General manager Neal Huntington has much work to do between now and the opening game April 4 against the Cardinals. He might have to find a first baseman, a second baseman, a couple of starting pitchers and a set-up man if Tony Watson takes over for Melancon. I’m not saying Huntington can’t put together another winning team. He convinced me of his brilliance by finding life after Russell Martin after last season. I’m just saying it’s not going to be easy and that the Pirates’ success shouldn’t be taken for granted.

Advertise with us

To quote a famous baseball philosopher, the late great Joaquin Andujar:

“Youneverknow.”

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.