The Pirates postseason lineup came into clearer focus Thursday in a 9-6 loss to the Chicago Cubs, although not in the way manager Clint Hurdle preferred. Jung Ho Kang has a left knee injury and appears lost for the season, meaning Jordy Mercer will be the regular shortstop down the stretch and beyond. Pedro Alvarez made another error at first base — that’s 20 — to sabotage the team’s chance of winning, leaving no doubt that his potentially dangerous bat just isn’t worth the risk of playing him in the field in the wild-card game that the Pirates and Cubs seem destined to play Oct. 7. Aramis Ramirez has to get the start at first base with Josh Harrison playing third base. Michael Morse would be a better choice than Alvarez. Even Sean Rodriguez.

“We’ve got a lot of options. We’ve got great depth,” a somber Hurdle said after the Pirates’ third consecutive loss to the Cubs. “We took on injuries with Mercer. We took on injuries with Harrison. We were able to play through it and perform. We expect to play well.”

We’ll see.

The loss of Kang, who was hurt in the first inning Thursday on Chris Coghlan’s slide into second base, is rough. Kang, a strong rookie of the year candidate, has been one of the Pirates’ better players, batting in the middle of the lineup. His teammates know his value. That’s one reason the clubhouse was unusually subdued after the loss. It didn’t help that the team played lousy baseball in the four games against the Cubs. It committed six errors. It ran into four outs on the bases. It allowed six stolen bases and had four wild pitches and a passed ball. Its pitching wasn’t nearly as effective as the Cubs pitching, especially Charlie Morton Thursday. The Pirates faced Jon Lester and Jake Arrieta in the middle two games against the Cubs and must face Zack Greinke and Clayton Kershaw in the first two games of a series against the Los Angeles Dodgers, beginning tonight. They needed to beat the Cubs’ Kyle Hendricks Thursday. Morton didn’t give them much chance.

Advertise with us

“It was a rough day all over the place — for all of us,” Hurdle said.

“You want other teams, if you’re going to come out on the short end, to beat you. We continue to get in our way.”

The Pirates are fortunate to have Mercer to play every day at shortstop. They can be a championship team with him. Hurdle has called him “the glue” to the infield. Mercer is a .239 hitter, but he makes the plays defensively. We saw how important defense — or the lack of defense — is in the Cubs series.

“I’m ready,” Mercer said. “Obviously, defense is No. 1. It’s always been my priority. The offense comes. If I’m in a good position to hit and seeing the ball well, I think I’m as good as anybody.”

You wouldn’t know it from the people who called the talk shows before Kang’s injury, complained about Mercer’s offense and begged Hurdle to play Kang every day. Mercer is OK with that. His teammates appreciate him. That’s good enough.

Advertise with us

“It’s kind of like the offensive line,” Mercer said. “They don’t get a lot of credit, but if it wasn’t for the offensive line, a guy wouldn’t rush for 100 yards.”

Le’Veon Bell couldn’t have said it any better.

I’m not sure Maurkice Pouncey wouldn’t be a better choice than Alvarez at first base.

Alvarez butchered another play Thursday, leading to the final four runs in the Cubs’ six-run fifth inning. Later, he fielded a safety-squeeze bunt and nearly flipped the ball underhanded over catcher Francisco Cervelli’s head. Cervelli was able to come down with the ball and make the tag at the plate but nearly was hurt in the process. He finished the inning and then was removed from the game with a right foot injury that Hurdle said is minor.

At that point, Alvarez’s two-run home run in the third inning just didn’t seem that important. Not after he joined the 20-error club for the fourth consecutive season. Not after he failed to make another play that was scored a hit in the first game of the doubleheader Tuesday against the Cubs, a play that left Hurdle second-guessing himself for not replacing Alvarez with Rodriguez for defensive purposes.

Advertise with us

“It does make the game more challenging at times,” Hurdle said of Alvarez’s defensive struggles, biting off his words.

It’s hard to tell if Hurdle is more angry or frustrated with Alvarez. When asked how hard it is to continue to play Alvarez, he said, tersely, “We’ve got to continue to evaluate.”

I’m saying it’s a dead heat between angry and frustrated.

It doesn’t help that the options at first base aren’t as strong as they are with Mercer at shortstop and Harrison at third base. Ramirez has just four starts at the position — all this month — after starting nearly 2,100 games at third base. Morse is a good hitter but not much of a fielder. Rodriguez is a good fielder but not much of a hitter.

I’ll take my chances with Ramirez.

Advertise with us

It’s not fair to Alvarez to keep sending him out to first base. It’s really not fair to his teammates.

Alvarez has hurt the Pirates long enough.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.