He lost a win Tuesday. A couple of ugly wild pitches by reliever Joakim Soria took care of that. He also lost a shot at 20 wins. He’s sitting at 16 with just three regular-season starts left. But neither disappointment seemed to trouble Gerrit Cole. Not after the Pirates beat the Chicago Cubs, 5-4, in the first game of a doubleheader. What matters to Cole is he is back on track for those three starts and the one(s) that follow in the postseason. His teammates are thrilled. So is his manager.
“He pitched very, very well,” Clint Hurdle said. “Everything was in a good place so, yeah, we are confident moving forward with him.”
It’s a good bet the Pirates will face the Cubs in the National League wild-card game Oct. 7 at PNC Park with Cole getting the start. The Cubs can’t be enthused, although they almost certainly would start their ace, Jake Arrieta, who pitches tonight against the Pirates and can make his own pre-playoffs statement. Cole made a good one Tuesday. He struck out eight and didn’t walk a batter. He owned Cubs rookie-of-the-year candidate Kris Bryant, striking him out three times. He hit 99 mph on the speed gun and frequently mixed in off-speed stuff to keep the Cubs off balance.
Of course, the Pirates still plan on catching the St. Louis Cardinals in the Central Division. The Cardinals can’t be excited about seeing Cole in a five-game playoff series. He beat them in St. Louis Sept. 6 in his previous start, giving up two hits in seven shutout innings.
Cole, who will pitch Sunday against the Los Angeles Dodgers, is in line to start against the Cubs Sept. 25 in Chicago and at home Sept. 30 against the Cardinals. He sees that as neither an advantage nor a disadvantage should he pitch against one or both teams in the postseason.
“I faced them a bunch already,” Cole said. He is 6-1 lifetime against the Cubs with a 3.10 ERA and 4-4 with a 2.86 ERA against the Cardinals, including playoffs.
“I’m sure they have a pretty good idea what’s going to happen when I go out there. That’s what makes this game really cool. It boils down to execution. You’re not going to be able to trick them the whole time. You’ve got to make a good pitch.”

Hurdle said he wasn’t sure what to expect from Cole Tuesday because the team gave him eight days between starts to protect his young arm just a bit by keeping his innings-count down. Cole started slowly, giving up a first-inning run and needing 55 pitches to get through the first three innings. But from the third inning until the seventh, he retired 11 in a row with six strikeouts.
“Obviously, I felt fresh,” Cole said. “I had some good weapons today. I thought the stuff was pretty crisp. There was just a lack of execution in some key situations that could have kept the pitch count down and, obviously, got us out of the seventh inning.”
The Pirates led, 4-1, when Cole gave up consecutive one-out singles in the seventh. The first bounced off first baseman Pedro Alvarez’s glove, the second off Cole’s leg. Pinch-hitter Tommy La Stella followed, driving Cole’s low-and-away pitch the other way down the third-base line for a run-scoring double. Soria took over for Cole and allowed both inherited runners to score with wild pitches.
Hurdle second-guessed himself for not replacing Alvarez with Sean Rodriguez for defensive purposes at the start of the inning.
“If Rodriguez is there, you’re going, ‘Maybe Rodriguez catches that ball and puts it away … You’ve got maybe two outs and nobody on,’ ” Hurdle said.
Cole did benefit from some good defense. Right fielder Gregory Polanco made a nice play in the fifth inning when he threw out pitcher Trevor Cahill at first base after Cahill blooped what appeared to be a single down the line.
“That was great,” Cole said. “We, obviously, had him played right. You don’t see it a lot, but it looked routine.”
It looked as if it would be Cole’s day. But the Pirates’ normally reliable bullpen couldn’t save him. He won’t become the franchise’s first 20-game winner since John Smiley in 1991. He seemed a lock at the All-Star break when he was 13-3 with a 2.30 ERA, but he went 2-5 in his first nine starts after the break with a 3.36 ERA.
Cole offered a simple, “No,” when asked if he is upset about losing his chance at 20. “That’s as much of a team statistic as any. I’m fortunate to be able to have as many wins as I do right now.”
It’s the wins ahead that matter to Cole and the Pirates.
“I feel good,” he said. “I feel like we’re playing good team baseball. Who doesn’t want to take the ball right now?”
Know this:
Hurdle will be glad to give it to Cole when the games mean the most.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.