This is not the time for pats on the back. So says Pirates general manager Neal Huntington despite the team’s 79-50 record heading into September. Not for the players, manager and coaches, although Huntington appreciates their hard work and success. And not for him and his scouts.
“We’re in second place,” Huntington said. “We’ve got a long way to go to accomplish our ultimate goal of winning the World Series.”
The playoffs are a lock for the third consecutive season. The Pirates are on pace to win 99 games. They led the Chicago Cubs by 5½ games for the first wild card and the San Francisco Giants, who played late Monday night, by 10½ games for the second wild card. Their magic number to clinch a postseason spot is 23. It is not too early to start counting.
“The goal still is to win the division,” Huntington said.
That is hardly a lock.
The Pirates trail the St. Louis Cardinals by five games. It’s crazy to think they could win 100 games for the first time since 1909 and still not finish first. But if they come in second, they will have only themselves to blame. More specifically, they will be able to blame their record against National League Central teams.
It is 21-29.
The Pirates have owned the NL East, going 24-9. They have dominated the West with a 21-5 record. They have been good in interleague play, going 13-7. But they are just 6-6 against the Milwaukee Brewers, 6-7 against the Cardinals, 5-7 against the Cubs and, almost unbelievably, 4-9 against the last-place Cincinnati Reds.
Twenty-six of the Pirates’ final 33 games are against division opponents — including the next 17 — beginning with the game tonight in Milwaukee.
There are two ways of looking at that. One, the Pirates are due to have divisional success, especially considering they were just 36-40 against Central opponents in 2014. Or two, the misery is likely to continue and catching the Cardinals is going to be nearly impossible.

The Pirates have seven games left against the Brewers and six against the Reds. Is it wrong to think they can go 9-4 in those games? Maybe even 10-3? The Pirates’ talented bullpen is good enough to do it; it has won 17 consecutive decisions since the Reds beat Rob Scahill June 25. The bench is deep; Pedro Alvarez, Neil Walker and Jung Ho Kang were available off the bench Sunday against the Colorado Rockies. Talented and deep, indeed.
The Brewers aren’t the same team that swept the Pirates in a three-game series in Milwaukee after the All-Star break. They traded Mike Fiers, who since has thrown a no-hitter for the Houston Astros, Carlos Gomez, Gerardo Parra and Aramis Ramirez. It’s just too bad Huntington didn’t trade for Ramirez a week earlier. Ramirez crushed the Pirates in that three-game sweep, going 6 for 9 with a home run and three RBIs.
The Reds, who started the Pirates down their lousy divisional path with a three-game sweep to open the season, also are fairly unrecognizable. They traded notable Pirates killers Johnny Cueto, Mike Leake and Marlon Byrd. They also won’t get to take their hacks in three games next week in Cincinnati against Pirates ace Gerrit Cole, who is a career 0-4 with a 5.23 ERA against them. Cole is not scheduled to pitch in the series.
The Cubs are more formidable, but hardly unbeatable. Most of their key players will be playing meaningful September baseball for the first time. The pressure can be brutal, especially for a franchise that has won just one postseason series since 1908. Cubs manager Joe Maddon took an usual step to lighten the mood by wearing one-piece pajamas — complete with feet — on the team’s flight home Sunday night from Los Angeles. No word on how many players took his offer to do the same.
Maybe Pirates manager Clint Hurdle should have tried that in 2012 when many of his current players played significant September baseball for the first time. They went 17-37 down the stretch, one of the worst collapses in baseball history. The Cubs won’t be that bad — they will make the playoffs — but they won’t catch the Pirates for that first wild card.
That leaves the Cardinals.
The three games in St. Louis this weekend are frightening. It might not be enough that the Pirates are playing better road baseball with seven wins in their past eight road games, including a three-game sweep in New York against the first-place Mets. They have been awful at Busch Stadium, going 1-5 there this season after going 2-8 a year ago and 3-6 in 2013. That’s 6-19. The three home games against the Cardinals the final week of the regular season look much more winnable, but it might be too late. The Pirates are 5-2 this year against St. Louis at PNC Park after going 6-3 there last season and 7-3 in 2013. That’s 18-8.
“We’re chasing a really good team and we’re being chased by a really good team,” Huntington said of the Cardinals and Cubs.
A Cubs-Pirates matchup in the wild-card game seems inevitable. Can you imagine what that would be like at PNC Park? Cole vs. Jake Arrieta. It doesn’t get any better.
Of course, many Pirates fans already are worried. Arrieta threw a no-hitter Sunday night against the Dodgers. His 17 wins lead baseball, his 2.11 ERA ranks second.
I’ll still take Cole if it comes to that.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.