Will A.J. Burnett be back to make a September push for the playoffs? That’s not the most important question this morning. Is the rest of the Pirates rotation good enough to get the team to the postseason for a third consecutive year and maybe do some damage once there? That’s the query that really matters.
The Pirates can’t count on Burnett despite his certainty that he will pitch again this season after a doctor’s examination Monday revealed a flexor strain in his right elbow, not a ligament tear. He is 38 with nearly 2,750 major league innings on that right arm. Former Pirates teammate Jason Grilli had a similar injury in 2013 and went six weeks and two days between appearances. That would bring Burnett back in mid-September. He would have to jump into a pennant race without benefit of a rehab start because the minor league seasons will be over. That’s a difficult mountain to climb, even for Burnett, who has a bulldog mentality and incredible pain tolerance. It’s one thing to think he will pitch again, perhaps even as soon as the four-week estimate he offered Monday. It’s much more of a stretch to think he will pitch effectively. He allowed double-digit hits in each of his three starts after the All-Star break with a 10.13 ERA.
Now, to the rest of the rotation. Right now, it’s Gerrit Cole, Francisco Liriano, Charlie Morton, Jeff Locke and J.A. Happ, who will make his first start for the Pirates tonight against the Chicago Cubs after coming last week in a trade with the Seattle Mariners. The timing of the Burnett injury couldn’t have been worse. He went on the disabled list Friday, which was non-waiver trade deadline day. That left Pirates general manager Neal Huntington time to add only Happ. The team had released former starter Vance Worley one day earlier to make room for reliever Joe Blanton. There’s a chance the Pirates will be able to trade for another pitcher before the end of the month, but that pitcher would have to clear waivers. The team added outfielder Marlon Byrd and first baseman Justin Morneau in August 2013 under those circumstances.

Cole is as dominant as any National League pitcher, as long as he doesn’t have to pitch against the Cincinnati Reds. He has a good chance of winning every time he takes the ball and will surprise no one when he throws his first no-hitter. His stuff and mound presence are that good.
Liriano is nearly as good as Cole on many nights. It’s a shame his start Monday night against the Cubs at PNC Park was ruined/shortened by a two-hour, nine-minute rain delay. He allowed no runs, one hit and a walk with three strikeouts in two innings.
Morton was outstanding Sunday in his win against the Reds, pitching seven shutout innings with seven strikeouts and no walks. His problem has been consistency. For the Pirates to win big, he has to be good in many more games than he is bad. He has the stuff to do it.
Read More
Locke also is unpredictable, as most back-of-the-rotation starters are. He was virtually unhittable against the Cleveland Indians July 4 — eight innings, no runs, two hits, no walks, six strikeouts — but didn’t make it past five innings in three of his four subsequent starts. The Pirates should be thrilled if they get six decent ones from him.
The same is true of Happ. This is his seventh season in the big leagues, so experience isn’t an issue. But he wasn’t exactly mowing ’em down with the Mariners. He was 1-5 with a 5.92 ERA in his past 13 starts after going 3-1 with a 2.98 ERA in his first seven. Pirates pitching coach Ray Searage needs to work a little of his magic with Happ.
The good news for the Pirates is they don’t need a lot of length from Locke and Happ because their bullpen is so much stronger with the addition last week of Joakim Soria from the Detroit Tigers. The back end is as strong as any in baseball with Jared Hughes, Soria, Tony Watson and Mark Melancon. Soria has closing experience with 202 career saves, 24 this season. On most nights, the Pirates will win when they have a lead after six innings. The Kansas City Royals rode that formula all the way to the World Series last season.
Can the Pirates get there this season, even if they can’t catch the St. Louis Cardinals in the National League Central and have to do it as a wild-card team?
Yes, but only if Cole and Liriano are great and Morton builds on his wonderful start against the Reds. Morton is the key.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.