Barring injuries, the Pirates will make the playoffs for the third consecutive season. They have all but clinched a wild-card spot with their 53-35 record. More and more baseball people are predicting they will catch the St. Louis Cardinals in the National League Central Division and make it to the World Series. The chase starts again tonight in Milwaukee against the Brewers. Surely, the best is yet to come.
What’s amazing is the Pirates have put themselves in this terrific position without getting significant contributions from Pedro Alvarez. Think about how good the team will be if he starts hitting home runs, driving in more runs and playing better defense at first base. Pirates manager Clint Hurdle has thought about it. “You know that he’s a guy who can catch fire and carry you.” So has general manager Neal Huntington. “It’s been a challenge for him, but you do still see the signs.”
Let’s start with the positive. Alvarez has driven in six runs in his past seven starts. He had a tying single in the eighth inning Saturday night off Cardinals left-hander Kevin Siegrist, maybe his best at-bat of the season. He had a walk-off single July 6 against San Diego Padres setup man Brandon Maurer. He drove in the first two runs of a 3-2 win against the Atlanta Braves June 26 with a single off left-hander Luis Avilan.
“You still see that ability to drive the ball to left-center field like most right-handed hitters can’t do,” Huntington said. “You see a guy who can launch a ball as far as anybody, can hit a ball as hard as anybody. You see the signs of a guy who is commanding the zone better, that is swinging and missing less. You still see the ability to give us an amazing at-bat in a big situation as he did [Saturday] night.”
Now, the negative.
Alvarez fails too often at the plate. His batting average is .236, his on-base percentage .303. Both numbers are worse than those of the much-criticized Gregory Polanco. Alvarez is hitting .222 with runners in scoring position.
Huntington said Alvarez is at his best when he hits to all parts of the field, but that he too often tries to pull the ball and doesn’t take what the pitcher gives him.
“This is a big man’s league,” Huntington said. “Consistency is a huge separator between the elite and the great, the great and the good and the good and the guys who are trying to be good.”
Alvarez has 12 home runs and 41 RBIs and is on pace for 22 and 75. The Pirates need him to make a big push and finish closer to the 36 home runs and 100 RBIs he had in 2013. They need him to be the hitter he was against the Cardinals in the 2013 playoffs when he hit .353 with three home runs and six RBIs in the five-game series.
That hardly seems out of the question.
“We haven’t seen it for a year, but you still see the ability to get white-hot,” Huntington said.
Predicting better defense from Alvarez is much harder. To say he has struggled making the transition from third base would be an understatement. His 14 errors are at least eight more than the other first basemen in baseball. Hurdle routinely replaces him with Sean Rodriguez for defensive purposes late in games.
“We felt the transition would be smoother with the way his hands and his feet played at third base,” Huntington said of Alvarez. “The only reason we had to make the move was the throwing challenges that he had …
“He’s a reminder that first base isn’t as easy as we think it is. There’s a lot more to the position than just running over to first base, standing on the bag and catching the throw from the infielders.”
In some ways, Alvarez has improved. His throws to second base no longer seem to be such an adventure. He’s also better at knowing which balls he should go after and which ones he should leave for second baseman Neil Walker. That was a tough adjustment for him after a career at third base, where he went hard after everything hit to his right.
“There are still some things he’s working on,” Hurdle said.
Taking the throw from the pitcher on pick-off attempts has been difficult for Alvarez. That’s hard to explain. It should be the easiest part of playing first base.
“We’re going to continue to encourage him to just keep working,” Hurdle said. “Don’t worry about who’s ranking you here and what you’re ranked there. At the end of the day, that’s not who you are, that’s how they’re measuring you.
“He has done some things that have showed a lot of hard work. We’ve got to try to get better and make all the plays that he can make to help us. The only way he’s going to get better is with the attitude, the effort and the work.”
Alvarez’s work ethic is just fine. It always has been. He’s a great teammate. It’s Alvarez’s results that need to improve for the Pirates to be the championship team that many are predicting.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.