Gerrit Cole should be the starting pitcher for the National League in the All-Star Game because he had the most wins (10) and best ERA (1.71) in the league going into his start Thursday night against the Chicago White Sox. Andrew McCutchen should make the team because he’s one of the five best players in the game. A.J. Burnett should be a lock because he has the second-best ERA (1.89). So should Mark Melancon, who is the National League’s best closer this side of St. Louis’ Trevor Rosenthal with 22 saves in 23 chances going into Thursday night. Francisco Cervelli had the best batting average (.316) and best on-base percentage (.396) of all catchers. Starling Marte ranked third among NL outfielders with 45 RBIs and sixth with 12 home runs. Tony Watson has been among the best setup men with 17 holds, a 1.78 ERA and a 0.93 WHIP going into Thursday night.
But it’s ridiculous to think seven Pirates will make the All-Star team, right?
Almost as ridiculous as eight Kansas City Royals starting for the American League.
Unfortunately, eight Royals are a strong possibility. In the latest AL fan-voting, the only non-Royals player in the starting lineup was Los Angeles Angels outfielder Mike Trout. McCutchen (fifth) and Cervelli (third) were the only Pirates among the leading vote-getters at their position in the latest NL voting.
“You’ve got to give the Royals fan base a lot of credit because they’ve been repressed for a long time,” Pirates manager Clint Hurdle said this week. “They’re out there with the same opportunity that everybody else has got. They seem to be a little busier, a little more proactive.”
Hurdle declined further comment on the subject. “I don’t think I’m the person to validate the process whatsoever.”
I don’t have to be so politically correct.
The process stinks.
The All-Star Game, like those in other sports, is a farce.
Just when you think it can’t get worse, it does. In 2003, commissioner Bud Selig decided to give the winning league home-field advantage in the World Series. Last year, St. Louis pitcher Adam Wainwright admitted to grooving pitches to New York Yankees retiring legend Derek Jeter. Now, there is the ballot box-stuffing fiasco in Kansas City.
What a joke.
Royals manager Ned Yost defended the process, telling USA Today, “There’s nothing wrong … vote! The votes are the votes. If you don’t like it, go out there and vote.” Yost went on to point out the Royals have the best record in the AL. “Once you sit back and think about it, [eight Royals starters] is really not that surprising.”
Give Royals outfielder Alex Gordon credit for a little more honesty. He is third among outfielders behind teammate Lorenzo Cain and Trout. “To be honest with you, I’ve never agreed with the All-Star voting,” Gordon told USA Today. “I always thought that guys most deserving, and having the best years, should go … but it’s a popularity thing now, and after getting to the World Series [last season], we got popular.”
The All-Star game is July 14 in Cincinnati. Fan voting ends July 2.
“If we get [seven or eight] guys starting at the All-Star Game, they’ll change the rule,” Gordon said. “They’ll have to. It will be like a home game. Nobody wants to see one team playing against the other All-Star team. It kind of ruins the point of an All-Star Game.”
It’s just one more reason the game shouldn’t be played. They won’t eliminate it because there’s too much television and promotional money at stake. But you can’t tell me the players wouldn’t rather have four days off in July than travel to and play in a meaningless exhibition game. They would be happy just to be picked to the All-Star Game. They want the recognition and, in many cases, the bonus that goes with making their league’s team. That’s a column for another day. The Los Angeles Dodgers are paying Clayton Kershaw $30 million this season. You would think the least he could do is pitch well enough to make the All-Star Game.
Managers and players pick the All-Star pitchers and reserves. They should pick the starters, as well. Baseball will tell you the game is for the fans and is quick to point out that nearly 400 million votes have been cast this spring, 395 million from Kansas City. OK, so they won’t admit that last part about Kansas City. But the fan-voting process really does stink.
This isn’t the first ballot-box stuffing. In the 1957 All-Star game in St. Louis, fans voted seven Cincinnati Reds in as starters. Commissioner Ford Frick, after determining that half of the ballots came from Cincinnati, put Willie Mays and Hank Aaron in the starting lineup in place of Reds outfielders Gus Bell and Wally Post and took away the fan vote, which wasn’t restored until 1970. It’s nice to think commissioner Rob Manfred will take similar action before next month’s game if eight Royals are voted in as starters.
That wouldn’t help those deserving Pirates who are left off the National League team. With almost a month of baseball to be played before the All-Star game, the guess here is Cole will get the start over Washington’s Max Scherzer and McCutchen, Burnett, Melancon and Cervelli will make the squad. That leaves Marte and Watson out.
Considering the All-Star Game is a joke, a four-day vacation seems like a pretty good alternative.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com.Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.