Jexx Varner knew he had a job to do.

In the wake of leading his Robert Morris softball program to its first Horizon League tournament championship last spring — in addition to its first NCAA Division I tournament appearance since 2005 — Varner said he had a talk with Courtney Poulich, his power-hitting outfielder.

The discussion between the coach and the 2025 Horizon League Championship Most Valuable Player and first-team all-conference honoree focused on the future.

After all, Varner said he knew the focus moving forward would be on Poulich, who had set team records for single-season home runs (16), RBIs (53) and runs scored (45) in 2025.

Advertise with us

“We knew that they were all going to plan for her,” Varner said. “If she remains disciplined and she does what she needs to do in the box, and we do what we need to do as coaches in building a lineup around her, there’s nothing anybody can do about it.”

And so far in 2026, no one has done much to rein in Poulich.

The Mount Pleasant product and redshirt senior designated player is leading the Horizon League with 12 home runs, 36 RBIs and 41 runs scored through just 21 games for first-place Robert Morris (15-6, 3-0).

“Experience is the best teacher,” Poulich said. “This is my fifth year, so I just think having that experience under my belt, I am a little more confident in myself and confident in the team, so that definitely helps.”

With 34 home runs during three seasons in Moon, Poulich now sits just two long balls shy of eclipsing the Robert Morris career home run record of 35 set by power-hitting third baseman Kali Byers from 2003-06.

Advertise with us

“It’s crazy to think what she’s done,” Varner said. “If you watch her every single day, and you’ve seen her in her process for years — through the recruiting process, through the transfer process — and what she’s like in practice, you’re not surprised at all. She’s just that talented and works that hard and loves this that much.”

For Poulich, the inspiration for softball success arrived early and close to home.

Poulich said she can first remember trailing in the footsteps of her elder sister, Chloe, when the Mount Pleasant natives played youth sports around their hometown.

Their bond would only get stronger in 2018 when Courtney, just a freshman, got to play her lone high school season with Chloe, who won a PIAA championship with the Vikings a year earlier.

Courtney would also help lead the Vikings to WPIAL and PIAA Class 3A titles as a senior in 2021.

Advertise with us

“My sister played college softball,” Courtney said. “She played at Towson. She was always a big inspiration to me, and she was very successful. She was my go-to girl.”

As it turned out, even though Chloe was three years older, the feeling was mutual.

“Courtney has always been a phenomenal athlete and very competitive,” Chloe said. “From tee ball to soccer to eventually softball, she excelled in everything she played. I remember 8-year-old Courtney hitting home runs on local fields most 10-year-olds were playing on.”

Success didn’t always come as easily, though, for Poulich, especially at the collegiate level.

After playing a year at Division I Liberty, Poulich transferred to Robert Morris, where she then tore her hamstring and missed the 2023 season.

Advertise with us

Poulich has since flourished, hitting .325 with 105 runs scored, 105 hits, 34 home runs, 109 RBIs and a .734 slugging percentage over the past three seasons.

During her breakout 2025 campaign, Poulich hit .336 with 11 doubles, 16 home runs and 53 RBIs.

“It is unbelievable, all of what she has accomplished while at RMU,” said Chloe. “She makes hitting look so easy and effortless. She really is the hardest worker in the weight room, batting cage, etc. She is so dedicated to her team.

“I couldn’t be happier for her, but her records and statistics only scratch the surface of what an amazing person and player she is.”

Poulich is hitting .484 so far this season, which is good for second on the Colonials behind junior catcher Aglaia Rudd, whose .613 batting average, 1.821 OPS and 1.194 slugging percentage are all tops in the Horizon League.

Advertise with us

The Colonials have five players batting over .400 this season. Junior outfielder Eloise Facher, a Shaler product, is hitting .465, while freshman Alivia Hare, a Mohawk graduate, is hitting .452, and Mary Brant is chipping in a .435 batting average.

“We definitely have a lot of confidence right now,” Poulich said. “I think as a whole everyone’s had a lot of success, especially our hitters, which is really cool to see because I think every person in the lineup is seeing the ball really well.”

Poulich said she feeds off the success of her teammates.

“It’s awesome because I know if I’m struggling in a game that my team has my back,” she said. “Everyone in the lineup will. If someone else is struggling, I have their back. It’s not just a one-person type deal. It’s the whole team contributing, and that’s why we’re having all the offensive success that we are.”

The player who makes it come together, though, is undoubtedly Poulich.

Advertise with us

“Her dedication and the things that she does, it provides such a great example for everyone around her,” Varner said.

Notables

• Virginia senior Zoe Skirboll, a Fox Chapel product, earned two-time All-America honors in the 100- and 200-meter breaststroke events at the March 21 NCAA Women’s Swimming and Diving Championships at the McCauley Aquatic Center in Atlanta.

• Cincinnati junior catcher Jack Natili, a Peters Township product, tied a program record with three home runs in a March 21 win against Utah. He is hitting .336 with a 1.024 OPS, .627 slugging percentage, seven home runs and 28 RBIs this season.

• Seton Hill third baseman Brady McGuire, a Shaler graduate, was named Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference West Division Player of the Week for helping lead the Griffins to a four-game sweep of Slippery Rock. He was 6 for 11 with five runs scored, a home run, 10 RBIs and five stolen bases during the four-game span.