INDIANAPOLIS — Back in 2012, two years after a 29-year-old at Robert Morris became the youngest Division I head basketball coach, the baby-faced Andy Toole — his brown hair neatly slicked off to the side like a budding politician — could feel a program on the rise.
He was hired as an assistant in 2007, and the Colonials finished 26-8 that year.
They made the NCAA tournament in each of the two ensuing seasons under Mike Rice, and Toole stepped to the helm in 2010 with a pretty keen notion of how to sustain that success.
“All the gradual increases in the profile of the program, in the way the program is just run on a day-to-day basis,” Toole said in 2012, “… Hopefully 10-15 years down the line it will be even better.”
Now, 14 years later, there’s some evidence to back that projection.
Robert Morris lost to Detroit Mercy in the Horizon League semifinals Monday night, 70-64, at Corteva Coliseum. The Colonials went cold offensively for stretches of the second half, and the Titans limited Horizon League Player of the Year DeSean Goode to three points in the final 20 minutes.
Read More
“You could feel it when you came to Indianapolis,” Toole said. “You want to give yourself the best chance, the only chance you have, to be a part of March Madness. But we weren’t. We weren’t able to finish the job tonight, and that’ll be a disappointment.”
In the immediate aftermath, when the emotion was still raw, Ryan Prather Jr. — almost apologetically — said he “should have done more.”
Ultimately, of course, Robert Morris finished two wins shy of repeating as Horizon League champion and returning to the NCAA tournament for the third time in Toole’s tenure as head coach.
But even reaching this point is a testament to that vision Toole pictured in 2012.
Shortly following last year’s narrow loss to No. 2 seed Alabama in the first round of the NCAA tournament, there was a mass exodus of Colonials into the transfer portal that’s come to define so much mid-major basketball. Of the starting lineup, Horizon League Player of the Year Alvaro Folgueiras went to Iowa, Defensive Player of the Year Amarion Dickerson and Kam Woods ended up together at USC and Josh Omojafo headed to South Florida.
Quick success in today’s college sports landscape tends to bring that effect.
It’s unclear as of now who will be returning and who will be transferring, but starting forward Kaleb Brown exhausted his final year of eligibility. Goode, Prather, freshman guard Darius Livingston and center Nikolaos Chitikoudis all have remaining eligibility.
“For the guys that are moving on, hopefully there’s a lot of lessons that are learned because of this,” Toole said. “And for the guys that are returning, hopefully it’s a motivation.”
The growth of Robert Morris was attractive enough for Goode, who averaged 15.2 points and 8.7 rebounds this year, to stay within the Horizon League and transfer from IU Indy after a strong freshman campaign. He saw the Colonials’ run up close last season, and saw a program — only five years into its membership in the Horizon League — continuing to ascend.
“They just did everything that I would want to see myself doing,” Goode said on March 3.
Goode may be one of the players courted to play elsewhere when the transfer portal opens on April 7. Shortly after midnight following Robert Morris’ semifinal defeat, Goode lauded the support he received from his teammates and the coaching staff this year.
“Without them, I wouldn’t be in the position that I was in,” Goode said. “... Honestly, I don’t get any of that without my teammates or my coaches believing in me.”
On Feb. 4, after Robert Morris beat Wright State in the first of eight straight wins, Toole noted the program’s “competitive” NIL budget that’s given them “a chance to have a chance.”
When the Colonials first joined the Horizon League in 2020, they had recently opened the $50 million UPMC Events Center. They had the facility, Toole said, but everything else wasn’t quite in place.
Robert Morris went 4-15 in that first year and 8-24 the next season. In 2023-24, the Colonials limped to a 10-22 finish. Now, after back-to-back seasons with 22 or more wins, the program is starting to solidify its role in the league as a yearly contender.
Still relatively baby-faced at 45 years old, but his hair a few shades grayer, Toole has started to usher in momentum and adapt during a time of constant change.
He’ll soon turn to guiding the offseason. But however the Colonials look in a few months, whether there’s a similarly large-scale overhaul as last year or not, the emphasis will remain on maintaining a certain degree of success and building on the “profile of the program” Toole mentioned 14 years ago.
“If you’re not consistently in this position,” Toole said, “you don’t get to the ultimate goal.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.