The first four days of the NCAA tournament provided the kind of upsets that have made the event famous, including a No. 16 seed beating a No. 1 seed for the first time.
What better time to look back at another No. 1 seed falling (albeit on a slightly lesser stage)?
Five years ago Monday, Robert Morris was granted what amounted to the opportunity of a lifetime, a chance to not only play one of the iconic programs in college basketball — Kentucky — but to do so on its home court. The Colonials made the most of it, defeating the Wildcats, 59-57, in the first round of the National Invitation Tournament in 2013.
From a practical standpoint, the win wasn’t a colossal upset; Kentucky opened as a six-point favorite, a line that gradually moved down as the game drew closer. Symbolically, though, it was David besting Goliath, a school with barely 4,000 undergraduates in the Pittsburgh suburbs toppling one of the giants of the sport, a program vastly more powerful by any conceivably measurement.
How the game even came to be was a story in and of itself.
Robert Morris won the Northeast Conference regular season but faltered in the semifinals of the conference tournament, losing to Mount St. Mary’s and missing out on a chance at the NCAA tournament. Still, by virtue of its first-place finish, it earned an automatic berth in the NIT. At the time, it seemed like only a small bit of consolation, but it eventually became something more.
Read More
Entering the season, any thought that the Wildcats and Colonials would meet in anything other than a first-round NCAA tournament matchup would have seemed far-fetched. Fresh off a national championship and with another star-studded recruiting class coming aboard, Kentucky was ranked third in both of the major preseason polls, and although not as overpowering as many thought, it was still 17-6 and ranked in mid-February. At that point, though, star freshman Nerlens Noel sustained a season-ending knee injury and the Wildcats lost five of their final nine games to, improbably, end up in the NIT.
That Kentucky, a No. 1 seed in the 32-team tournament, and Robert Morris, a No. 8 seed, were scheduled to play each other wasn’t entirely surprising. Where it would take place was. Rupp Arena, the Wildcats’ home venue, was playing host to NCAA tournament games that week and was unavailable, thereby shifting the game to Sewall Center, Robert Morris’ musty 3,000-seat gym.
The week leading up to the game had no shortage of story lines. For Kentucky coach John Calipari, it was a homecoming, a chance to bring his team to the town in which he was raised and first developed a love for basketball. For Robert Morris’ players, it was an opportunity to play on a stage few, if any, of them would have expected.
“I mean, it’s Kentucky,” guard Velton Jones succinctly said when asked about the magnitude of the matchup.
What greeted the teams that night was nothing short of the circus many anticipated. Night classes were canceled to help free up as much parking as possible. Hundreds of students and fans lined up outside the Sewall Center hours before the game was set to tip. A building that housed more than 1,800 spectators only once that season packed in 3,444, with rows of bleachers added to each end of the court to accommodate the increased demand.
The game itself, even just five years later, seems like a blur.
A Robert Morris team that could have been easily overwhelmed instead rose to the moment, jumping out to a 10-0 lead and trailing for only 29 seconds of a possible 40 minutes. After falling behind by as many as 11 in the second half, Kentucky mounted a late rally, tying the game with 42 seconds remaining on a jumper from Archie Goodwin.
With 12 seconds remaining, Jones found an open Russell Johnson under the basket on a perfectly executed inbounds play. Johnson missed a layup, but teammate Mike McFadden got the rebound and was fouled on a layup attempt. He calmly made both free throws and Kentucky’s Kyle Wiltjer missed a 3-pointer as time expired, sending a frenzied student section rushing to the court.
A sea of red-clad fans embraced their victorious schoolmates and savored a moment in which they were at the center of the American sports universe. The school trended on Twitter, and rather than being known as the financier of the American Revolution, Robert Morris became synonymous with anything that once seemed improbable becoming attainable.
The win itself doesn’t seem quite as unbelievable with the gift of hindsight. The Colonials won 24 games that season behind a veteran-laden team featuring Jones, a spirited point guard who could have played in any conference in college basketball; Karvel Anderson, a future NEC player of the year who is still playing professionally overseas; and Coron Williams, who averaged more than 10 points per game the following season as a graduate transfer at Wake Forest. They bested a Kentucky team that, for all its talent, seemed unprepared or perhaps even unwilling to encounter what it faced that night, at the tail end of a contentious season in which Calipari said the program “almost got hijacked.”
The two schools met again eight months later, when a top-ranked Wildcats team that would go on to make the national title game routed Robert Morris by 38, a measure of revenge that, for the Colonials, at least came with a $140,000 paycheck. That year, they would again make the NIT and again knock off a No. 1 seed in the first round, this time St. John’s, but it didn’t have quite the same feel. There was frankly no way it could.

Five years later, much has changed, namely the Sewall Center itself, which is being torn down to make way for a 140,000-square-foot complex.
Remnants of the win still linger, though. Andy Toole, the team’s fresh-faced 37-year-old coach who became a national figure that night, is still on the Colonials’ sideline, having spurned interest from other programs, most notably Fordham in 2015. Before its demolition, Sewall Center was plastered with pictures from the game. Though Robert Morris has made the NCAA tournament in the past five years, even winning a play-in game in 2015, its win against Kentucky is still largely how it is known nationally (at least athletically).
March 19 will always signify something, especially to those who were there.
To me, the win always brings up one particular memory. About two years after it happened, my then-girlfriend and I went back home to Kentucky to visit family and ended up at her middle-school-age brother’s basketball game. As time wound down, the other team inbounded the ball under the basket coming out of a timeout. The player slapped his hand on the ball and in his meek, prepubescent voice, called out the play.
Its name? Robert Morris.
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.