Penn State’s regular season is over, which means it’s time to sort through the things that worked — and the things that didn’t. Here’s a look at five Pro Football Focus grades that hold the key to a more prosperous 2022.

Run defense (65.4) — It’s not terrible, but it’s not great either for what finished as the seventh-best scoring defense in the country. Especially when you consider that four of the Nittany Lions’ five losses came by a combined total of 12 points. Defensive lineman P.J. Mustipher’s injury is a clear dividing line here. In the two weeks before he went down against Iowa, Penn State posted its two best run defense grades of the year. Against Iowa and the following week against Illinois, it posted its two worst grades without him and lost on both occasions. It also struggled in what became a four-point loss to eventual division champion Michigan on Nov. 13. Long story short, this unit missed him a lot, making his decision whether to return in 2022 a crucial inflection point for the coming offseason. If he comes back, he could give the interior of this defensive line a real boost. If he moves on, Penn State will have to find a way to be better there or face similar vulnerability against the better ground attacks on its schedule.

Pass blocking (63.4) — The score ranks 67th in FBS and was the offense’s worst grade in any category. Worse, even, than its run blocking score of 67.2. This fact should not be overlooked amid the fair criticism of the ground attack in recent weeks. The reality is that first-year coordinator Mike Yurcich’s concepts pretty much worked beautifully whenever Sean Clifford was given proper time to throw. That’s reflected in a significantly stronger pass grade of 71.5 and individual grades of 73.6 for Clifford, his best as a starter, as well as 87.5 for All-Big Ten receiver Jahan Dotson and 78.9 for fellow wideout Parker Washington. They just didn’t get that time often enough. Against Iowa, that resulted in Clifford getting knocked out. Against Illinois, that resulted in him playing without much mobility amid his injury. And against Michigan, that resulted in him running for his life for most of the afternoon rather than looking downfield. If Penn State is fortunate enough to get Clifford back for 2022, protecting him needs to be the focal point for a line that must be revamped. The veterans Yurcich had in those roles this year — including redshirt senior Mike Miranda (61.5), redshirt junior Rasheed Walker (60.1) and senior Eric Wilson (64.6) — simply weren’t good enough. So it should be interesting to watch how a youth movement plays out. This grade suggests it shouldn’t be anything to fear.

Joey Porter Jr. (67.9) — It was a tale of two halves for the redshirt sophomore from North Allegheny. Through Penn State’s first seven games, he never posted a score below 64.5 and posted four scores over 70. He was cruising toward some nice postseason accolades. From that point forward, though, he never posted a score better than 56.1 and posted three scores below 50. The result was a third-team All-Big Ten selection that’s probably less than he was hoping for. Perhaps he was nagged by an injury late in the season, one we simply didn’t know about. Perhaps he just fell into a slump that’s characteristic of a younger player. Regardless of the reason, though, Penn State needs more consistency from him with several members of its prolific secondary set to move on. And who knows? With question marks at other positions on this defense, Porter may be one of the guys asked to lead this unit as a whole. He’s demonstrated the talent necessary. Now it’s time for him to maintain it for a full schedule as an upperclassman with hopes of following in his father’s NFL footsteps.

Advertise with us

Keyvone Lee (68.9) — To the extent that Penn State had a lead back, he was it. And when he got the rock, he was more solid than he was given credit for, averaging 4.8 yards per carry while posting the offense’s eighth-best grade. He was fairly complete as a back, too, with a reasonably competent pass blocking grade of 67.2 that lifted the team average. You’re probably not going to confuse him with Saquon Barkley any time soon, but the numbers suggest that if he can get better blocking, he can do some damage in 2022. And with Dotson likely to depart this offseason, he might have to do it, considering the state of Penn State’s receiving corps otherwise. Beyond Washington, no Penn State receiver or tight end who played more than 100 snaps posted a score better than Brenton Strange’s mark of 61.7. Disappointing for him after a promising 2020 and disappointing for the group at large that includes plenty of highly touted prospects. Either names including Keandre Lambert-Smith and Daniel George need to start stepping up, or Lee will probably have to carry more of the playmaking load.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.