As he watched a 43-yard field goal attempt from the normally reliable Jordan Stout sail wide right of the upright in a game his Penn State team trailed by eight in the second half, James Franklin couldn’t help but verbalize his frustration.
Television cameras aimed at Franklin in that moment captured the angst and pain in the face of the Nittany Lions head coach, as well as the expletive-laced phrase he groaned, one that even an amateur lip-reader could decipher.
It encapsulated what was yet another maddening day for Penn State against a highly ranked opponent in a season in which such showings have unnervingly become the norm.
The Nittany Lions’ 21-17 loss to No. 8 Michigan last Saturday at Beaver Stadium not only dropped them to 6-4 on the season and altered their outlook on what a successful season could still look like. It continued what has emerged as a trend. In 15 games against top-10 teams under Franklin, Penn State has gone just 2-13, which includes a 0-3 mark this season.
What can be a self-selective stat — only college football’s behemoths regularly fare well against top-10 teams and even some of them flounder at times — carries a particular sting for a program that has become one of the Big Ten’s best under Franklin’s guidance. Difficult as it may be to find a single commonality linking the various setbacks over the past seven years, especially for some of the closer losses, it’s something Franklin sees as an all-encompassing matter.
“It’s everything, right? It’s recruiting. It’s development. It’s scheme. It’s strength and conditioning. It’s nutrition. It’s everything,” Franklin said Tuesday during his weekly video teleconference. “We’ve done some really good things, but I also know there are some things that we’ve got to get better. That goes back to the point I’ve made since I got here — this is the most competitive sport in college athletics and you have to be willing to compete in everything year-round. The margin of error is very, very small. You have to be willing to commit. It’s not the Saturdays. Saturdays are a part of it. But you have to be willing to commit 365 days a year with what everybody’s doing in 2021.”
The 2-13 figure doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Seven of those losses came against division rival Ohio State, three of which were decided by a combined nine points. A number of those defeats have been close, as five of them were by a touchdown or less. The average margin of defeat in those 13 games was 16.2 points, a number inflated by some more lopsided games earlier in Franklin’s stint.
While not as ghastly as its record against top-10 teams, Penn State hasn’t been stellar against ranked teams under Franklin, either. The Nittany Lions are 10-19 against ranked foes since 2014, though it’s 10-13 in such games since 2016, when they won the Big Ten, made the Rose Bowl and reasserted themselves as one of the nation’s top teams after a several-year lull that came in the aftermath of the Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal.
But while the Nittany Lions have been slightly better against ranked teams while ranked themselves, with a 9-11 record in such games under Franklin, they’re just 1-7 against top-10 teams while they’ve carried a top-25 ranking.
This season, three of Penn State’s four losses have been to opponents that were ranked in the top 10 at the time of the game — then-No. 3 Iowa, then-No. 5 Ohio State and then-No. 9 Michigan. Those defeats came by a combined 16 points, with only a 33-24 loss to the Buckeyes coming by more than a single score.
In a season in which each of the Nittany Lions’ losses came by single digits, there is reason to believe they’re better than their 6-4 record might indicate, despite what long-established football axioms might say. Earlier this month, running backs Ja’Juan Seider said that if it weren’t for an injury to quarterback Sean Clifford, which pulled him from the Iowa loss in the second quarter of a game Penn State was leading by 14 and severely hampered him in a 20-18 loss to Illinois two weeks later, it would be, as Seider put it, “a different story” for the Nittany Lions.
Franklin is all too familiar with the frustration that mounts with such close setbacks, but he doesn’t believe it’s having a negative effect on his team.
“I would say that I look at how our guys played last week,” Franklin said. “You watch tape, you watch film and our guys played extremely hard. They competed their tails off. We had a chance to win the game. That’s been the case week in and week out. That’s kind of what I’m looking for at practice and what I’m looking for on Saturdays — how hard are we competing? How hard are we playing? Are there things we have to get cleaned up? There’s no doubt about it. But you look at the scores of our games and you look at the types of opponents we have played, I think our guys are motivated. But obviously, there’s frustration. There’s no doubt about it.”
Whatever on-field shortcomings Penn State experiences this season have been magnified by speculation linking Franklin to an increasing number of head-coaching vacancies across the country, namely USC and LSU.
Franklin is adamant those whispers haven’t been a distraction for him or his players. They’re just games his team has to win.
“I get people are trying to connect the dots there,” Franklin said. “All the things I’m able to control, I’m controlling. But I get it. I understand the business. I understand people’s concerns. I would just state — looking at my track record over my time here, eight years, my actions, my behaviors, I think they’ve been pretty consistent since I’ve been here.”
NOTE
The Nittany Lions’ game Saturday against Rutgers is the team’s senior day. What has traditionally been a signal of who will not be with the program beyond the present season isn’t exactly that anymore.
Due to the extra season of eligibility afforded by the NCAA in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, players who are listed as seniors on the roster have the chance to come back for one more year. Last year, for example, standout safety Jaquan Brisker, a senior at the time, took part in senior day festivities, but later opted to return for this season.
That means the official lineup of players who are honored Saturday isn’t a set list of players who won’t be returning, though super seniors like Brisker won’t have any remaining eligibility beyond this season. Instead, as Franklin said, some players may walk as part of the ceremony only to evaluate their options in the weeks and months after and decide to come back.
“It’s just kind of a mess,” Franklin said. “You can’t use any of the old data you’ve studied over the last 10 years to make predictions. It’s really challenging.”
Craig Meyer: cmeyer@post-gazette.com and Twitter @CraigMeyerPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.