IOWA CITY, Iowa — Sean Clifford stood near the 30-yard line, pads off and sporting a blue Penn State undershirt, a look of disgust plastered across his face. Meanwhile, PJ Mustipher struggled to take a couple steps and quickly returned to the bench.
Had No. 4 Penn State sketched out a plan for how it wished to attack No. 3 Iowa in a nationally televised game on Saturday, the Nittany Lions' first top-five matchup since 1999, this most certainly was not it. By early in the second quarter, Penn State was missing its starting quarterback and one of its best defensive players.
Give Penn State's defense ample credit. It did all it could to keep the Hawkeyes out of the end zone, but the Nittany Lions' inability to move the football ultimately proved too difficult to overcome during a 23-20 loss to Iowa at Kinnick Stadium.
"I’m going to remember this feeling," senior safety Jaquan Brisker said. "The team’s going to remember, too.”
Ahead, 17-3, after a Jordan Stout field goal with 12:31 to go in the second quarter, Penn State (5-1, 2-1) watched its lead disappear like sand through an hourglass. In the subsequent eight drives, Penn State amassed just 17 yards, its only points coming on a 44-yard Stout field goal.
During the final 11 drives of the game, with sophomore Ta'Quan Roberson replacing Clifford at quarterback, Penn State totaled just 50 yards.
Read More
"We weren’t able to do as much as we needed to in the second half," head coach James Franklin said.
Iowa (6-0, 3-0) scored a touchdown midway through the second quarter to make it a one-score game. Stout flashed his powerful leg at 6:40 of the third before Iowa's kicker, Caleb Shudak, made two (of his three) field goals in the second half to pull the Hawkeyes to 20-16 with 8:08 left.
The Hawkeyes took the lead for good at 6:26 of the fourth, as quarterback Spencer Petras faked a handoff and found wide receiver Nick Ragaini all alone while crossing the middle of the field, a unique play call that stood out when compared to Iowa’s vanilla offensive approach.
"Our defense is very strong, very together. But we could have done better," Brisker said. "We let up too many points, We have to keep getting better."
Facing an Iowa defense that was allowing just 11.6 points per game — second in the nation — and one that burnished its ball-hawking reputation by adding four turnovers to its NCAA-high total of 20, the loss of Clifford — and others — became way too much to overcome.
The demise
With 12:31 left in the second quarter, Penn State had accumulated 146 passing yards to just 14 for Iowa. The Nittany Lions, who entered the game 91st in the country in third-down conversion rate, picked up five of their first six while attempting 25 passes.
Then, everything changed. Although Franklin had no specifics on Clifford’s injury, it looked to potentially involve his clavicle or collarbone — neither of which is good for a quarterback. As Clifford was examined, Iowa marched 75 yards on the ensuing drive and scored on a 9-yard pass from Spencer Petras to Charlie Jones.
With seven pass attempts on his career, Roberson stood in the shotgun, clapped his hands and promptly fumbled the first snap from center Mike Miranda. Three Penn State offensive linemen committed false start penalties on Roberson’s first drive. His second ended with an interception. Penn State was called for eight false-start penalties.
“Not an ideal situation for a guy getting his first significant time,” Franklin said.
Historic matchup
Saturday marked the first top-five matchup for Penn State since 1999 against Arizona. Meanwhile, it was the first Big Ten matchup between top-five teams not named Ohio State or Michigan since 1962. Iowa has now played in seven top-five matchups in the history of the program, Penn State 12.
After snapping a six-game series losing streak by Penn State last season, Iowa stretched its winning streak to 12 Saturday. Penn State, meanwhile, lost for the first time in its past 10.
Strong start
Outside of a Clifford interception, which Iowa flipped into a 34-yard field goal from Caleb Shudak, Penn State enjoyed a terrific first quarter. The Hawkeyes misfired on nine of their first 10 passes and converted just one of their first five third downs.
After a poor decision led to an interception and an early Iowa field goal, Clifford recalibrated himself nicely, directing a nine-play, 75-yard drive that culminated with a 2-yard touchdown run from junior running back Noah Cain to give the Nittany Lions a 7-3 lead at 8:37 of the opening quarter.
Among the other statistical standouts, Jahan Dotson caught eight passes for 48 yards. Linebacker Ellis Brooks totaled 14 tackles, including eight solo stops, while Brisker and Arnold Ebiketie were second on the team with nine. Ebiketie added a sack and 3 1/2 tackles for loss.
“I’m very proud of the way we played defense,” Brooks said. “But obviously we need to continue to get better.”
Franklin frustrated
The injury tent got plenty of work Saturday. Clifford and Mustipher were the biggest names, but Penn State lost a half-dozen more players for a stretch or the entire game. When a Penn State player was hurt, Iowa’s fans showed no mercy, the booing angering Franklin.
“I don’t think that’s the right thing for college football, booing guys when they get hurt, however it looks,” Franklin said. “If one of those kids would’ve been significant hurt, you’re booing them, I have a hard time with that.”
Up next
Penn State is off next week before hosting Illinois on Sept. 23 at Beaver Stadium. Iowa, meanwhile, welcomes Purdue to Kinnick Stadium. With matchups later this season against No. 7 Ohio State, No. 9 Michigan and No. 11 Michigan State, Penn State still has plenty of time to make some hay. The Hawkeyes, meanwhile, have a fairly soft schedule the rest of the way in the Big Ten West.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.