Shortly after Penn State athletics published a letter Thursday to say the school wasn’t planning to have fans at fall events — including football — athletic director Sandy Barbour and other department officials briefed reporters on reasons for the decision and other topics via Zoom.
“As of today, the current large group gatherings guidance from the governor’s office limits capacity to 250 people for outside events and 25 people for inside events,” the letter read. “Therefore, under the current conditions and current state orders, our fall sports events would be conducted without fans in the general seating areas of our facilities. We continue to work with the governor’s office to discuss, and possibly be prepared for the opportunity to have spectators at our fall Penn State sporting events.”
Penn State presented football season-ticket holders with three options in place of them being in attendance for games in 2020. Fans could make the payment into a tax-deductible donation, use the money toward 2021 season tickets or request a refund. If fans take the refund option, they would have to deduct the seat-licensing fee, and the seat-licensing cost would become a tax-deductible donation. Barbour said some ticket holders were annoyed that choosing that option would not have their 2020 seat location or parking guaranteed for the 2021 season.
“There are probably no good answers here, and we had some difficult decisions to make,” Barbour said.. “I’m trying to make sure that in this difficult time, our fans had choices to pick from that fit their particular circumstance at this time, understanding that everyone is different. We know that there are going to be disagreements about how we’ve laid this out.”
Carl Heck (senior associate athletic director of capital, events and facilities) and Scott Sidwell (deputy athletic director) joined Barbour on the call. Here are a few highlights from the conversations:
• Barbour said she is taking a 15% pay cut due to the COVID-19 pandemic. She also said other administrators around campus and athletic staff are also taking cuts but wouldn’t confirm if head football coach James Franklin, who makes more than $5 million and is the highest paid public employee in Pennsylvania, is among them.
Read More
There will be a lot of money lost even if Penn State is fortunate to play a season. Those losses will grow exponentially if there isn’t one.
“Regardless of whether we play or don’t play, our revenue losses will be in the high eight figures, reaching nine figures in the case of no competition,” the letter said.
• Sidwell had a reasonable explanation of why school is deciding to forgo having fans attend games.
“We worked with several different universities around the country, consulted with pro sports leagues,” Sidwell said. “We tried to get a feel for what was happening in the industry as it related to the various options that could be provided to fans. A lot of the information that helped us make this decision was a lot of input from around the country and our fans.”
The school estimated that around 23,000 people could’ve attended games if the state government approved their plan to allow fans. Currently, outdoor gatherings in Pennsylvania are limited to no more than 250 people. With about 100 players on each team in addition to coaches, medical staff and referees, there wouldn’t be room for attendance under the current guidelines.
“I think at this point, it’s their concerns about where we are as a state, as a commonwealth,” Barbour said. “They’re not willing to extend it to that point, at this point.”
“Now, they’re open, and we continue to work with them, so we’ll continue to work throughout this, [and] see what flexibility might exist either through ... innovation or through a change to improve conditions.”
Barbour did say the school is trying to find a way to allow parents of Penn State athletes to attend events.
“That certainly is a group that is a high priority for us,” Barbour said. “Whether it’s conditions improving and the governor’s orders changing, or whether it’s trying to create a little bit of flexibility with what we currently have, being able to accommodate our parents in all of our venues, the parents of the student-athletes who are competing, is a top priority for us.”
• Thursday marked Barbour’s third virtual meeting with media since the COVID-19 pandemic began. She began the most recent press conference wearing a mask, the same way she did the previous two.
“There are some pretty simple things that aren’t going to make COVID-19 go away, but are going to help us control this and help us be able to do it in our everyday lives, whether it’s going to restaurants, going to parks or ... playing sports,” Barbour said. “For Penn State student-athletes in the Penn State community, these are things we have to do and that we can do.
“And I’m not going to let up on that. I feel like going downtown with a sign and saying everybody put your mask on, please.”
• Barbour initially didn’t want to play football games without fans, but she adapted in that area. Penn State’s revised 10-game Big Ten schedule was released earlier in the week, which presented some hope for the season. But Barbour knows everything won’t be easy.
“Whether or not I have confidence that we’re going to play, I’m certainly not sure we’re going to play. No. I wouldn’t say that,” Barbour said. “I do think we do still have some time for things to turn in the right direction. But again, at any point if our experts come to us and say look, even with all your testing, even with all the mitigation, all of the things that you’re doing to help mitigate the virus and protect students, we don’t think you can do this safely, then we won’t do it.”
Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com and Twitter @NubyjasW





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.