A plurality of top coaches support expanding the College Football Playoff. Penn State’s James Franklin is among them. Pitt’s Pat Narduzzi is not.
Those were some of the findings of an ESPN survey published Tuesday that took coaches’ temperature on a range of topics related to their sport’s postseason.
A total of 62 of the power conferences’ 65 coaches responded to the survey. Twenty-nine, including eight of his Big Ten Conference peers, joined Franklin in supporting an expansion beyond the four teams it currently includes.
Franklin took specific exception to the current system’s lack of coherent criteria for qualification. He was among 21 coaches who voted “no” when asked if he understood how teams are chosen.
“No, nobody does,” he said. “Each year it looks like there are different variables that are going to factor in because there are different people sitting in the room. That's going to happen. One person is going to have a bias toward one thing. It's natural. Somebody will have a bias toward another, and some people are going to feel like this is a more important metric.”
Thrity-five respondents — a majority — said they understood the criteria for qualification. Six voted “other.”
Read More
The Big Ten’s lacking support for the current system is understandable. The conference has been shut out of the playoff entirely for the past two years, and its conference champion has been excluded for the last three. Penn State won the conference in 2016 and finished fifth in the rankings, just missing out on a playoff berth.
Narduzzi, responding to a different question of trust in the committee, expressed more faith in the system.
“I think they've done a good job the last few years of getting the right teams in there,” he said. “All you have to do is get the one right team. There's one best team; there's three other teams that are going to take a shot and swing at them.”
The ACC’s champion, by contrast, has qualified for each of the five playoffs to date and won two of them, with Clemson following with titles after the 2016 and 2018 seasons.
Fifty-one coaches voted with Narduzzi in expressing trust in the committee. Just four voted no, while six chose not to comment.
Among the survey’s other findings:
● A majority — 36 coaches — opposed making conference titles a condition of qualification. Sixteen supported the idea, seven voted “maybe” and three responded with “don’t know.”
● A majority of 38 also voted “yes” on the question of whether power conference teams should face more uniform scheduling. Twenty-one voted “no” and three voted “other.”
Here, Narduzzi also weighed in on independent Notre Dame’s slate, which does not include a conference championship game.
”Why does Notre Dame get into the playoff if they didn't play in a championship game? They've got one foot in the door in the ACC,” he said, referring to a partial scheduling agreement with the conference. “How come they didn't have to go beat Clemson like we had to at a certain point?”
● Most coaches also think their players could handle the physical toll of the longer schedule an expanded playoff might require. Thirty-six voted “yes” on the question. Just 11 voted “no” while 15 responded with “maybe.”
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.