James Franklin talks Sean Clifford and whether or not this year’s defense is the best he’s had at Penn State
Penn State’s Big Ten history has been one of distinct peaks and subsequent valleys.
The Nittany Lions won 10 or more games in three of their first four seasons of league membership beginning in 1993 but reached that total just once from 1997 to 2004. And that one is widely considered to be a squandered opportunity — the 1999 squad reached No. 2 in the polls before sputtering to a 10-3 finish.
Michael Robinson, Paul Posluszny and Co. led a relatively brief renaissance that included three 11-win seasons from 2005 to 2009. Then, the Jerry Sandusky scandal crashed into Happy Valley, waylaying the program for half a decade.
Now the program is in the midst of a third true winning cycle. It has averaged double-digit wins since its thrilling 2016 Big Ten title run and become a darling of national media who have been dazzled by its impressive offensive numbers and gaudy recruiting class rankings.
The question now is whether coach James Franklin can prevent the backslides of the past and maintain a consistent presence in the national top 15, and 2019 will be key in that effort.
“Last season brought some damaging setbacks. The Nittany Lions blew late leads to lose to Big Ten East division rivals Ohio State and Michigan State at home. They were blown out of Michigan Stadium by the Wolverines. Then, they delivered a pitiful postseason performance against Kentucky — decidedly a basketball school — in the Citrus Bowl.
Read More
““The realty is, we’ve gone from an average football team, to a good football team, to a great football team, but we’re not an elite team yet,” Franklin said in an emotional news conference after the loss to Ohio State. “The work that it’s going to take to get to an elite program is going to be just as hard as the ground and the distance that we’ve already traveled to get there.”
Those remarks made a lot of headlines because of how candid and raw they were, coming from the mouth of a man known for his slick sales pitch.
They also captured the challenge well, though. It seems trite to say, but hot programs can only stay hot if they keep winning. Clemson under Dabo Swinney is a good example. It didn’t become a super power overnight; it just never lost momentum.
A 10-4 season in 2011 became 11-2 seasons in 2012 and ’13, then a 10-3 campaign in 2014. It was only afterward that the dynastic success followed — four College Football Playoff berths, three title game trips and two titles since 2015.
Penn State’s path need not be that clean. Auburn’s undefeated 2010 national championship was famously preceded by a ho-hum 8-5 campaign. And successful programs can hit the skids as quickly as any others. Think Florida after Urban Meyer’s departure in 2010.
Still, winning is easier when your program cultivates a sense that it’s inevitable. When boosters can invest with confidence. When recruits can expect big bowl games every year. When pundits can look like geniuses for picking you on “College Gameday.” You can see it in the Alabamas. The Clemsons. The Ohio States.
You can’t see it in Penn State yet. Not when it’s blowing those late leads. And not when it’s getting clowned by the DJs at the Big House.
That — more than anything else — is why the Nittany Lions are being picked to finish fourth in the Big Ten East, even as ESPN’s Football Power Index considers them Michigan’s closest challenger with Week 1 looming.
Penn State doesn’t need to win the Big Ten to regain that confidence, though it would certainly help. It does, however, need to show that it’s bigger than departed stars Saquon Barkley or Trace McSorley by exceeding expectations without them.
That means beating the teams you’re supposed to. Finishing off superior opponents when they’re on the ropes. And if you’re going to lose, doing so in a way that demonstrates your upside.
Penn State did those things in 2016. Less so in 2017 and especially ’18. Now is the time to reverse that trend, or risk falling into one of those frustrating valleys of the past.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.