College football history is messy. Conference and divisional realignment has been a constant. Power programs have come and gone. Particularly in the early days, quality of competition varied widely, leading to many disputed national championships.
Untangling that volatility to create a definitive ranking of all-time great programs is a tall task, but ESPN’s stats department tackled it this week and sought to determine the top schools of the past 150 years. Using a formula that weighted success at the top level in the past 50 years most, the publication came up with an interesting top 50. And yes, both Pitt and Penn State made the cut.
The Nittany Lions came in at No. 12 and were definitely beneficiaries of the weighting system. Here’s ESPN’s explanation.
The story of Penn State's football success is the story of the past half-century. Joe Paterno created a national power at the base of Mount Nittany. Penn State finished in the AP top 10 twice prior to Paterno becoming head coach in 1966. The consistent excellence of his 47 seasons is historical record; so too is the awfulness of the scandal that engulfed him and his legacy. That Bill O'Brien and James Franklin so easily rebuilt the program is testament to the foundation that Paterno laid.
Pitt, meanwhile, came in at No. 33 on the strength of its dominance in the beginning of the 20th century.
From 1915 through 1938, under the legendary Pop Warner and under Jock Sutherland -- a coach Gen. Robert Neyland thought to be the best ever -- the Panthers walked among the college football elite. In 1937, they won the second AP title despite a tie with Fordham; they might have won the first, in 1936, if not for a tie with Fordham. (The teams tied in 1935 too, but there was no AP poll.) But Sutherland resigned in a dispute with the university after the 1938 season. And save for a decade under Johnny Majors and Jackie Sherrill from the mid-1970s to mid-1980s, the Panthers have been just another program. It's hard to win in the shadow of an NFL team; Pitt is a tenant at the Steelers' Heinz Field.
Both schools lagged behind other historical heavyweights. Alabama topped the list and was followed in the top 10 by Notre Dame, Ohio State, Oklahoma, Southern California, Michigan, Yale, Nebraska, Texas and Football Championship Subdivision powerhouse North Dakota State.
Still, inclusion is a nice feather in the cap for two rivals who face off in their last scheduled meeting in a little less than a month.
Read More
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.