Pitt and Penn State fancy themselves “Running Back U” and “Linebacker U,” respectively, because of their traditions of consistently producing star players at those positions. From Tony Dorsett to Jack Ham, from James Conner to Michael Mauti, both programs have enjoyed excellence that spans decades.
ESPN, however, isn’t too high on their modern track records. In an analysis posted Tuesday, the website ranked Penn State’s linebacker unit No. 5 and Pitt’s running back group No. 6 since 1998, the start of the Bowl Championship Series age of college football.
No explanation for Pitt’s ranking — bolstered by the likes of Conner, LeSean “Shady” McCoy and Dion Lewis — was offered, while author Chris Low wrote of Penn State’s:
“Historically, the Linebacker U tag might have been reserved for Penn State, and the Nittany Lions are still up there. But [Georgia claims] the top spot since the start of the BCS in 1998, thanks to their array of run-stuffing inside linebackers, pass-rushing specialists on the outside and do-it-all guys cut from the mold of Boss Bailey, who was the heartbeat of the 2002 Georgia defense that ranked fourth nationally in scoring.
“Speaking of Penn State, it's hard to find a more decorated trio at one school in the past 20 years than LaVar Arrington, Paul Posluszny and Dan Connor, though the folks at Ohio State would be quick to counter with such legendary names as Andy Katzenmoyer, James Laurinaitis and A.J. Hawk.
The Nittany Lions actually ranked higher in the defensive line category, coming in at No. 3 overall on the strength of the standout careers of names including Courtney Brown, Tamba Hali and Devon Still. No other units from either school were ranked in the top 10.
In its methodology, ESPN considered “all-conference performers, All-Americans, NFL draft picks and stars from the pro ranks” since 1998. That obviously excludes some of the biggest names who helped craft the RBU and LBU labels in the first place. Dorsett and Craig “Ironhead” Heyward for Pitt. Ham, Greg Buttle and Shane Conlan for Penn State.
Here’s guessing neither school will give theirs up without a ranking that consider those guys, too.
Read More
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.