Year in and year out, wrestlers from the WPIAL move on to the college ranks and dominate in the NCAA tournament like no other region in the country. This year was no different, only for one exception — they got to do it in front of their family, friends and hometown fans at PPG Paints Arena.
For the first time in more than 60 years, the NCAA Division I wrestling championships — or as Iowa associate head coach and two-time world champion Terry Brands calls it, “The toughest tournament in the world” — returned to the mecca of amateur wrestling in Western Pennsylvania to showcase the sport’s brightest stars from all over the country.
Penn State did what it always does — win. The Nittany Lions have won four NCAA team championships in a row and eight out of the past nine.
So did Spencer Lee, a three-time PIAA champion and three-time age-level world champion from Franklin Regional High School who has yet to lose a match at NCAAs in two trips while outscoring his opponents, 113-10.
But while most of the favorites won as expected, no one is safe from the imminent danger of a tournament where 330 of the nation’s top wrestlers are competing for the same goal, with only 10 national championships to go around. Someone has to leave empty handed.
This year, the brutal three-day gauntlet claimed one of Pittsburgh’s most decorated local stars as its latest victim.
Only four wrestlers in NCAA Division I history have won four national titles, and Central Catholic grad Vincenzo Joseph had high hopes to become the fifth. After he pinned two-time defending champion Isaiah Martinez in the 2017 NCAA finals as a redshirt freshman, Joseph jumped into the crowd to celebrate with his family and told ESPN’s Quint Kessenich in his post-match interview, “One down, three to go.”
Joseph defeated Martinez again in last year’s finals to win his second-consecutive title, and went undefeated throughout the 2018-19 regular season. But a chink appeared in his armor at this year’s Big Ten championships when he lost to Iowa’s Alex Marinelli in the finals, 9-3.
The loss dropped Joseph, a Penn State junior wrestling at 165 pounds, to the No. 2 seed, but when No. 8-seeded Mekhi Lewis of Virginia Tech upset Marinelli in Friday morning’s quarterfinals, Joseph’s path to a third title seemed to open up. That is, until he ran into Lewis in Saturday night’s championship finals.
Lewis cradled Joseph to his back for four points at the start of the second period to break open a scoreless tie, then added a takedown in the third period to cap off a convincing 7-1 victory. Fresh off winning a junior world championship, the redshirt freshman announced himself as college wrestling’s next big star at the expense of an already established one — exactly what Joseph did to Martinez two years ago.
Joseph will still have the opportunity to become a three-time NCAA champion next year, something only 52 wrestlers have accomplished. But he’ll likely have to go through Lewis to do so.
The upset that wasn’t
Joseph wasn’t the only Nittany Lion from the WPIAL gunning for his third title over the weekend. Senior Jason Nolf, considered by many the best pound-for-pound wrestler in the tournament, entered as one of its main attractions and an overwhelming favorite to win his third-consecutive title.
Other than an injury default in a dual meet against Rutgers last year, Nolf had only lost two matches in college — both to Martinez as a freshman. But the Kittanning grad ran into his toughest test of the season against North Carolina State sophomore Hayden Hidlay in the 157-pound semifinals.
Nolf had defeated Hidlay in last year’s finals, 6-2, in one of his closest matches since his freshman year. Unlike all of Nolf’s other opponents in the past three years, Hidlay actually looked like he belonged on the mat with him, even if Nolf was still on another level. Still, nobody gave him a chance to beat Nolf the second time around.
Friday night, Hidlay got a second chance to shock the world — and many believe he did enough to do just that. But his first-period takedown got overturned by a coach’s challenge, even though replays appeared to show Hidlay with control of Nolf while he was still on the mat.
With less than 20 seconds left in the third period and Hidlay trailing by one point, he got in deep on a shot and hoisted Nolf’s leg up into the air. But Nolf used his incredible mat savvy and otherworldly flexibility to fight off the takedown until time expired, barely escaping with a 3-2 win.
Hidlay couldn’t believe it. He’d just come so close to beating one of the sport’s all-time greats in what was supposed to be Nolf’s big send-off. Instead, Nolf averted a disaster, and Hidlay’s dreams were dashed — again.
After a 10-2 major decision win against No. 2 seed Tyler Berger of Nebraska in the finals, Nolf’s place in both Penn State and NCAA wrestling lore was secure as one of the best to ever step on a mat. He has three NCAA titles and a Penn State-record 60 career pins to prove it.
But for seven minutes on a Friday night in Pittsburgh, Hidlay nearly etched his own name into the history books. He came up just short, but the fans in attendance will always remember his captivating performance.
Out-of-town perspective
Everything seemed to run smoothly during the three-day event, with one exception: fans had to wait about an hour to get inside for the first session Thursday morning. And because the doors only opened an hour before the first match, some fans didn’t make it in time for the start of the session.
Having not hosted this event in more than 60 years, city officials may have underestimated just how passionate these fans are about their teams. One of those die-hard supporters is Kenny Cleveland, 21, of Tulsa, Okla., who was attending the tournament for the 13th year in a row.
“Really good food here, so I enjoyed that,” Cleveland said. “Venue-wise, I like it a lot. I think there’s not a bad seat in the house, honestly.”
Cleveland made it inside right before the first match to root on his beloved Oklahoma State Cowboys, but others weren’t so lucky.
Wes Creason, 63, of Indianola, Iowa, was making his 33rd trip to the NCAA championships to cheer on the Hawkeyes, but he never encountered a snag in the previous 32 trips like the one on Thursday morning.
“I missed the 125-pound matches completely. We were in line almost an hour,” Creason said. “Maybe they didn’t know about the crowd, or someone didn’t explain it to them good enough, but it shouldn’t have happened.”
An emerging power
Fans from all over the country traveled in droves to back their schools, with national powerhouses Iowa and Oklahoma State bringing two of the strongest contingents as always. But if any other team and fan base owned the weekend other than Penn State, it had to be Rutgers and its rabid group of supporters.
The Scarlet Knights’ wrestling program went without a national finalist for its first 86 years until Nick Suriano made the finals last year. This year, Suriano and teammate Anthony Ashnault both made it, and both delivered for their fans to become the school’s first-ever national champion wrestlers.
The Rutgers section, one of the loudest fan sections all weekend, nearly blew the roof off the building when Suriano took down Oklahoma State’s Daton Fix in double overtime in the 133-pound finals.
Chris Saul, 50, of Leesburg, Va., made the trip to support his father’s alma mater and watch Suriano and Ashnault make history.
“I grew up in Pennsylvania, but obviously with my father going to Rutgers, I’m a big supporter. All the fans are fantastic,” Saul said. “I think what they’ve done is built the program enough where the best kids are going to want to go to Rutgers.”
Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.