UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — There were dozens of plays during Penn State’s 27-26 loss to fourth-ranked Ohio State on Saturday night at Beaver Stadium.

Most, of course, were standard stuff, easily forgotten.

Others were spectacular, like the 93-yard catch-and-run touchdown on which Nittany Lions quarterback Trace McSorley and wide receiver K.J. Hamler connected during the second quarter.

The one that was discussed most after the game — after Penn State (4-1) had absorbed its first loss of the season, as well as a serious blow to its chances of qualifying for the national championship playoff — would have fallen squarely into the former category most of the time.

Advertise with us

It was a pretty ordinary 2-yard loss by Penn State running back Miles Sanders, who never had any hope of eluding Buckeyes defensive end Chase Young in the backfield.

What made it so significant — and controversial — was that it came on a fourth-and-5, with just over a minute left in regulation and Penn State trailing by a point.

Offensive coordinator Ricky Rahne opted for a handoff to Sanders, who finished the game with 43 net yards on 16 carries, an average of 2.7 yards per touch, rather than put his team’s fate in the hands of McSorley, who had the most productive game ever by a Penn State quarterback.

McSorley set a school record with 461 yards of total offense, including 175 on the ground, and had what might have been the finest game of his collegiate career.

And while he didn’t quibble with Rahne’s play call — “I know exactly what Coach Rahne saw [from the Ohio State defense],” McSorley said. “I saw the same thing.” — Penn State coach James Franklin was less charitable.

Advertise with us

“Obviously, we should have called something different there,” he said.

Later, Franklin volunteered that “that’s on me. Nobody else.”

The loss snapped at streak of 16 consecutive victories for Penn State at Beaver Stadium, where a record crowd of 110,889 turned out Saturday.

Franklin was unapologetically emotional during his postgame press conference, after watching his team lose to the Buckeyes by one point for the second year in a row.

“The reality is, we’ve gone from [being] an average football team to a good football team to a great football team, and we’ve worked really hard to do those things,” he said. “But we’re not an elite football team yet.”

Advertise with us

The Buckeyes are, which is why they turn up in the national championship conversation every winter.

Ohio State showed its pedigree by rallying from a 12-point deficit with eight minutes remaining in the game to score a pair of touchdowns.

The game-winner came with 2:03 to play, when quarterback Dwayne Haskins hit wide receiver K.J. Hill with a 24-yard scoring pass. About 4½ minutes earlier, Haskins and Binjimen Victor had connected on a 47-yard scoring play, during which Victor broke several tackles.

“This one hurts, obviously,” Franklin said. “We didn’t finish the game the way we should have finished the game. No doubt about it.”

Penn State’s defense neutralized the Buckeyes’ offense, which had been averaging 54.5 point per game, for most of the first half, allowing points only after Ohio State recovered a Sanders fumble on the Nittany Lions’ 25.

Advertise with us

Later in the game, though, Ohio State consistently got the ball to its skilled players in situations where they had room to operate.

“No question that we need to tackle better in space,” Penn State linebacker Koa Farmer said. “Ohio State did a great job in doing that … that was an adjustment they made, and it hurt us.”

Buckeyes coach Urban Meyer and his staff never did come up with a way to contain McSorley, though, which is why his teammates were so confident that he would find a way to salvage the victory for them when Penn State had its final possession.

“He does it all the time,” cornerback Amani Oruwariye said. “There was no doubt in my mind, at all.”

At least not until that fourth-down stop on Sanders, following the Rahne decision that will provide plenty of fodder for State College talk radio until Michigan State comes to town Oct. 13.

Advertise with us

Not that McSorley believes the second-guessing about it will be rooted in reality.

“The play was there to be made,” he said. “We just didn’t make the play.”

Dave Molinari: dmolinari@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG.

Do you appreciate good journalism? If you do, consider subscribing.

Support journalism. Subscribe today.