At 19 years old — his life seemingly still before him — Timothy Piazza entered a familiar destination and the last he would live to see, a dwelling near Penn State University distinguished less by its Tudor Revival brick construction than three Greek letters.

By the time medics removed the young pledge from the Beta Theta Pi House half a day later, he was bleeding internally from injuries including a lacerated spleen and a fractured skull, his body bruised and in a stupor from alcohol nearly four times the legal limit.

His death a year ago today drew expressions of shock and anger. Perhaps none were more pointed than what then-Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller said in May after announcing a grand jury report and charges against the fraternity and its members.

"There's just nothing about this case that isn't heartbreaking," she said. "No one goes to college to die."

Advertise with us

But death, by itself, did not make the sophomore engineering major from Lebanon, N.J., and his grieving parents a national symbol.

After all, excessive drinking, fraternity hazing or a combination of both have been snatching young campus lives for decades, despite a parade of campus crackdowns and administrator protestations that what is occurring over and again is not the norm.

Only in this case, the torment was captured and memorialized by video surveillance from inside the fraternity house, and by text messages that captured the moment-by-moment responses of young adults suddenly faced with a life-changing decision. They could get the medical help Mr. Piazza desperately needed, and in doing so, risk severe campus sanctions. Or, they could leave him as he moved for hours closer to death, arguing about the severity of his injuries and applying gruesomely amateurish techniques to help him ride out what they apparently saw at first as a rite of passage.

Further magnifying it all was that it involved Penn State, a mega brand and magnet for media attention, with a legion of devoted followers nationwide but also vocal detractors.

"It was a perfect storm," said Hank Nuwer, a professor at Franklin College in Indiana who has researched and written extensively on hazing deaths.

Advertise with us

The sight of young fraternity men in ties and jackets, moving without expression past cameras on their way to and from the courthouse in Bellefonte, Pa., made for grim theater last summer as one of the nation's largest fraternity prosecutions inched forward. Charges were filed, the most severe dismissed, and later refiled.

A changeover in the district attorney's office ultimately placed the case in the hands of the state attorney general.

Penn State President Eric Barron on Thursday summarized sweeping changes made over the last year, including some 14 fraternities suspended or banished, and a decision by Penn State to wrest chapter oversight away from the Interfraternity Council.

He said the school had sought to turn its community pain into action, but added, "We must do more."

Mr. Piazza's parents, James and Evelyn Piazza, on Friday shared their own call to action against hazing and their thoughts on a life cut short. In a statement, they recalled watching at Hershey Medical Center as their son was taken off life-support.

Advertise with us

"He just wanted to join an organization," they said. "How could this happen?"

The government does not track hazing incidents, though an effort in Congress would change that. For now, it falls to those like Mr. Nuwer, 71, who counts at least 42 hazing deaths in the last 10 years — nearly all involving college fraternities.

The toll has grown, even since Mr. Piazza's death.

Mr. Nuwer said the Penn State case has brought change to a degree. Florida State, Ohio State and Ball State, among other universities, seem more inclined to answer misconduct with campuswide Greek life suspensions or social probation.

"The're a new urgency for fraternities and sororities to prove to schools that they deserve campus recognition," he said. "That's been a change since Piazza's death."

Advertise with us

Still, some cases are being handled with scant disclosure, something Mr. Nuwer said allows the behavior to fester. He cited the University of Pittsburgh, which placed its Greek system on probation last month and suspended its Sigma Chi chapter but was slow to release basic details about a recruiting-week event that left an underage student hospitalized for excessive drinking.

Pitt told parents by email Thursday that campus police found no evidence of “criminal hazing,” and that the student who has recovered “voluntarily drank to excess.” Mr. Nuwer said his concerns about disclosure remain.

"This secrecy is not reform, not acceptable, Pitt," he said in a blog post Tuesday.

The tally he keeps, with photos of the deceased and news clippings, may only scratch the surface of the problem.

"I couldn't even keep track of how many students are hospitalized, how many close calls there were, where they maybe were a drink or two away from death."

Advertise with us

------------------

Timothy Piazza was not as lucky.

In a family photo, the strapping red-haired teenager smiles as he poses in his high school football uniform with his parents, during senior night at Hunterdon Central Regional High School's stadium in Flemington, N.J.

The young man who wore No. 65 for the team took advanced placement courses and honors engineering, volunteered as a peer mentor and liked to golf and visit the Jersey Shore. As a Penn State freshman, he was leaning toward mechanical or electrical engineering, his webpage said.

He became a fraternity rush on a campus where misconduct by the Greek life system already had triggered alarm, including highly publicized instances of excessive alcohol consumption, sexual misconduct and hazing.

Advertise with us

Fraternities and sororities account for 17 percent of campus enrollment, but Greek life students self-report excessive drinking at a rate four times higher than the average student, according to Penn State. Most sexual assaults are linked to alcohol, and association with Greek life yielded a sexual assault victimization rate 50 percent higher than the average student, the university found.

In 2015, another fraternity there, Kappa Delta Rho, made national headlines after discovery of a private invitation-only Facebook page in which nude photos of female students, some unconscious, were posted online along with degrading comments.

There were complaints over how little was released about the status of campus discipline. The fraternity ultimately was shut, and the episode prompted Mr. Barron to announce a task force to address Greek life problems.

He said fraternities and sororities were part of the campus fabric.

"However, incidents of sexual misconduct, hazing and alcohol abuse here and across the nation are all-too-common and demand immediate attention,” the president told the campus on March 23, 2015, in announcing the review.

Advertise with us

But the task force did not reach full consensus. Some of its recommendations were implemented after Mr. Piazza's death, as part of an escalating crackdown on some Greek organizations that at one time numbered about 80.

Mr. Barron and other Penn State officials point to a history of efforts to rein in behavior by these chapters that are separate from the university and, like Beta Theta Pi, operated off campus in privately owned houses.

Nevertheless, the school faced withering criticism from Ms. Parks Miller, a grand jury that met in the Piazza case and others about what they called grossly ineffective monitoring. They said campus climate enabled what transpired on Feb. 2, 2017.

--------------

On that night, Mr. Piazza and 13 other pledges were at the Beta Theta Pi house for a bid acceptance ceremony. They underwent a drinking ritual called "the gauntlet,'' in which they were required to move from one alcohol station to another, consuming vodka, "shotgunning" beer and consuming wine, investigators said

Advertise with us

Authorities later concluded that Mr. Piazza consumed 18 alcoholic drinks in under 90 minutes.

The ritual was forbidden by the campus and by the fraternity's own international rules. It occurred in a house that, in theory at least, was dry and did not engage in hazing.

But investigators found otherwise. They obtained register receipts indicating $1,179 worth of alcohol had been purchased in the days before Feb. 2 for use that night and at other events, according to a grand jury report.

Mr. Piazza'a last hours, some captured by video, depicted a nearly helpless individual.

Almost unable to stand, he stumbled and fell repeatedly, including down the basement stairs. He came to rest at one point face down and was hemorrhaging. He was carried upstairs and put on a sofa.

Advertise with us

But instead of an ambulance ride, he spent several hours drifting in and out of consciousness, twitching on occasion and vomiting. Fraternity brothers at times seemed irritated and at other times panicked.

A liquid was thrown onto his head. His face and abdomen were slapped in attempts to revive him. One member pleaded with others to get him medical help, only to be pushed away, according to the grand jury report.

A book-laden backpack was placed on him to prevent the young pledge from rolling over and choking on vomit.

As midnight approached, a fraternity member wrote in a group text message: "...Tim Piazza might actually be a problem. He fell 15 feet down a flight of of stairs, hair-first, going to need help."

Some 12 hours would elapse before an ambulance was summoned.

Advertise with us

Investigators found one text to a fraternity brother from the chapter president that said, "[m]ake sure the pledges clean the basement and get rid of any evidence of alcohol."

------

During late winter and spring last year, Penn State announced a Greek Life crackdown and initiatives to discourage misconduct including a fraternity report card system to give prospective pledges and others information about chapter behavior.

In a letter to campus on April 10, Mr. Barron called it troubling that Greek life misconduct continued despite reforms, and he noted that even some parents were visibly intoxicated while visiting for parents' weekend.

Penn State warned the system itself could be in jeopardy but the university stopped short of eliminating it altogether.

Advertise with us

On May 5, Ms. Parks Miller announced charges against 18 fraternity members, including eight charged with involuntary manslaughter, a misdemeanor, and aggravated assault, a felony.

The grand jury blamed Mr. Piazza’s death on an “environment so permissive of excessive drinking and hazing that it emboldened members to repeatedly act with reckless disregard for human life.”

Mr. Barron said the blame was misplaced.

“If the behavior is entirely secret, and all outward signs are that you have a model fraternity, then I don’t see how any university in the country can know what’s going on unless we sit somebody in a house,” he said. “We do not own the houses. We do not own the property. We do not manage them. We do not govern them."

On Sept. 1, after a week-long hearing, District Judge Allen Sinclair dealt the prosecution a blow by dismissing without explanation the most serious charges.

Advertise with us

Defense attorneys who had said the prosecution overreached hailed the decision. They said the death was tragic, but not a crime.

But Ms. Parks Miller refiled charges, and on Nov. 13, added new ones — including involuntary manslaughter — against previously uncharged individuals.

The charges were based in part on discovery of video that had been deleted but recovered by police and the FBI. Police charged a fraternity member with evidence tampering, alleging he deleted the tape with investigators in the house.

Ms. Parks Miller, who lost a primary, left office this month. The new district attorney, citing a conflict, successfully sought that the prosecution be assumed by the state attorney general, who has agreed to conduct an independent review.

------

Advertise with us

Later this month, at least 15 sets of parents from across the nation who have lost a child to hazing will meet for a closed retreat in Greenville, S.C. They will plan strategies to root out hazing.

Keynote speaker will be Mr. Nuwer, a journalism professor and author of five books on hazing, including "Hazing: Destroying Young Lives."

Meanwhile, campuses in Pennsylvania and beyond are studying the reforms at Penn State and elsewhere. They want to see what aspects could be applicable at their own schools, said one administrator, Scott Irlbacher, director of special programs and student community standards at Robert Morris University.

Mr. Irlbacher, who previously worked in the Greek Life office at Penn State, recalled Beta Theta Pi as being considered above average in reputation. “That’s the scariest thing for professionals — that a group that performs very well to the campus expectations still can have individuals who express really terrible judgment.”

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner