BELLEFONTE, Pa. — Standing up for one of Jerry Sandusky's victims cost Mike McQueary his reputation and his career, his lawyer said today in a final pitch to jurors weighing the former assistant football coach's whistleblower case against Pennsylvania State University.

But the school's lawyers said Mr. McQueary has only himself to blame for the hardships he has faced since emerging as the central witness against Sandusky and three Penn State administrators accused of ignoring or covering up his crimes.

“This is not a case about Jerry Sandusky,” said university lawyer Nancy Conrad in her closing argument. “Any harm that Mike McQueary has suffered ... is the result of his own failures.”

The jury of eight women and four men — which includes two Penn State employees — is expected to begin deliberating this afternoon in a Centre County courtroom, after a two-week trial in which Mr. McQueary claimed university officials ousted him from his $104,000-a-year coaching job and defamed his character because of his involvement in Sandusky's case. He is seeking at least $4 million in compensation.

Advertise with us

“What Penn State has done to Mike McQueary is outrageous,” his lawyer Elliot Strokoff told the panel. “He should not have been a scapegoat in this matter, and certainly not for five years.”

University lawyers maintain that the school simply chose not to renew Mr. McQueary's contract — along with those of other assistant coaches — in a routine staffing shake-up after the firing of head football coach Joe Paterno.

Under state law, the trial judge, senior Chester County Judge Thomas Gavin, will rule on Mr. McQueary's whistleblower claim, while jurors will be left to decide if the university defamed him or knowingly lied to him in the aftermath of Sandusky's 2011 arrest.

Whatever the reason for Mr. McQueary's dismissal, it became clear through testimony of dozens of witnesses that the impact of the investigation that put Penn State's football culture under a national microscope continues to ripple five years later. And few, Mr. McQueary testified last week, had felt those effects more than he had.

He quickly found himself a pariah and a target for death threats from some portions of Penn State’s avid fan base, which blame him for tarnishing the reputation of the school’s storied football program and Paterno, its iconic coach, who was fired days after Sandusky's arrest.

Advertise with us

Others questioned why he did not do more to intervene in February 2001, after witnessing Sandusky's sexual assault of a young boy in a campus locker-room shower.

Mr. McQueary has said that he reported what he saw to Paterno and two administrators in the days after the attack. None of them informed police or child welfare authorities.

Now divorced, jobless and living with his parents at their State College home, the 6-foot-5 former quarterback testified Friday that he has been unable to find work since Penn State placed him on paid leave, citing safety concerns in the days after Sandusky's arrest, and later decided not to renew his contract.

“He happens to be a very good football coach,” Mr. Strokoff told jurors on Thursday. “But much more important than that is that he is an incredibly decent and good person ... Mr. McQueary has endured an awful lot in silence and with dignity."

But throughout the trial, Penn State lawyers pushed back at any suggestion that the university is to blame.

Advertise with us

In videotaped testimony shown to the jury, Bill O'Brien — who immediately succeeded Paterno as head coaching and has since gone on to lead the Houston Texans — said he came to Penn State in 2012 with a list of his own staff he wanted to bring with him. He never considered Mr. McQueary for a job and his decision had nothing to do with Sandusky.

Matt Rhule, Temple University’s head coach and one of Mr. McQueary's longtime friends and former teammates, told jurors he deemed McQueary too unseasoned to offer him a job when he took over the Owls' program in 2013.

“There was nothing remarkable about Mr. McQueary’s resume,” said Ms. Conrad, the lawyer for the university. “He stayed at one school, under one head coach. He had not developed the contacts or the resume to land a job in this competitive field of professional college football.”

Since 2012, the school has paid more than $93 million to settle claims from 32 Sandusky accusers. And university officials have acknowledged the school bears some responsibility to the victims of its former assistant football coach, who is serving a 30- to 60-year prison sentence for the sexual abuse of 10 boys.

Mr. McQueary is still expected to return to a courtroom as a star witness if the still-pending child endangerment case against former Penn State president Graham B. Spanier, ex-athletic director Tim Curley and former vice president Gary Schultz goes to trial.

Jeremy Roebuck: jroebuck@phillynews.com on on Twitter @JeremyRRoebuck