UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — Penn State athletic director Sandy Barbour lamented the NCAA Division I Council’s shutdown of satellite camps earlier this month when speaking at the Associated Press Sports Editors Mid-Atlantic Region meeting Monday at The Penn Stater Conference Center Hotel.
Barbour said she has heard a lot of discussion after the ruling on both sides of the argument, and there’s a chance the NCAA Board of Directors could overturn the decision at a meeting at the end of this month — although she guesses the board likely will uphold the council’s decision.
“I do think it’s a shame on a number of different levels,” Barbour said. “One is that there’s no doubt that the ACC and the [Southeastern Conference] ... their opposition is around trying to protect an inherent advantage that they have. And that’s fine. I get that.
“I do think that probably the thing that prior to the vote that got undersold was the [Football Championship Subdivision] or the non-power five schools, what benefits they were reaping,” Barbour said. “We completely undersold what we are now hearing from students about their opportunities. I don’t think that was on anybody’s radar, really, that was trying to shut it down.”
The bickering over satellite camps started in 2014, when Penn State coach James Franklin and his staff worked at camps held in Florida and Georgia.
“From the beginning, if the rule was going to be legal in the Big Ten ... I felt like we needed to do everything in our power within the rules to give Penn State the best chance to be successful,” Franklin said after a spring practice last week.
“The rule now is not legal. So now everybody’s back on a level playing field. So I’m OK either way.”
While Barbour said the rule change will hurt prospective student-athletes who might not have the ability to travel to different school’s camps, she said Penn State has a big enough brand that holding camps and clinics at its own facilities probably won’t significantly harm the Nittany Lions. But she said with recruiting escalating in every sport, there might have to be rule changes around earlier visits to deal with the absences of satellite camps.
Barbour also gave her thoughts on paying student-athletes, and some of the gray areas that come with playing in the NCAA. She said full scholarship athletes at Penn State have their tuition and fees as well as room and board paid. They also recieve a 21 meal per week plan and a cost of attendance stipend of $4,738 per academic year.
“Frankly, I believe that we’re giving them something far more valuable, in terms of setting up the rest of their life, than compensation,” Barbour said. “I don’t want to call what they’re getting compensation, but what they’re getting is an investment, a very serious investment, in the rest of their life.”
Barbour added there was uncertainty when it comes to issues of student-athletes selling their autographs and such, as that’s the gap between what the school provides and pays for and what the student-athlete does on his or her own.
“There are a number of restrictions and a number of rules from an NCAA standpoint that don’t make a lot of sense in today’s world,” she said.
Something that also needs cleaning up is the disparity of pro eligibility between different sports, but that is often out of the NCAA’s control. Barbour said she thinks how Major League Baseball runs its draft eligibility is probably the best system. In that system, a player has the opportunity to turn pro after high school, but, if he turns it down, he must complete at least three years of college before entering the draft again.
“We hear a lot about one and done, which used to be none and done,” Barbour said. “If we can’t increase it to at least two, if not three … we ought to go back to none. Because I think some of what you’re seeing in some places is a true subversion of the academic vision. And I think we have to acknowledge, maybe, at some point, that not everyone is interested in going to college. And we’re making them do that from a basketball standpoint.”
As far as Penn State’s Intercollegiate Athletics’ facilities master plan, Barbour said the process has gone well, with input from many different stakeholders. She said the school is looking at it from two perspectives — what is best for student-athletes and competition and what appeals to fans in terms of comfort and cost.
Of Beaver Stadium, Barbour said “renovation is the direction” in which to head, but it was premature to put a time frame on that since the extent and cost of the renovations remain unknown.
“We’re looking at late summer for maybe some initial look at what the future might hold,” Barbour said. “Because, again, the facilities master plan, we’re talking about a 15- or 20-year look at that.”
Megan Ryan: mryan@post-gazette.com and Twitter @theothermegryan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.