The chants started cascading down from the upper reaches of Beaver Stadium’s soggy student section in the closing minutes of Penn State’s 28-3 clobbering of Rutgers on Saturday night.
“WE’RE not RI-vals!” (Clap…clap…clap, clap, clap.) “WE’RE not RI-vals!” (Clap…clap…clap, clap, clap.)
They were jeers the Scarlett Knights better be ready to hear for a while because they’ve utterly failed, two years into their Big Ten odyssey, to give anyone in Happy Valley a reason to hate them.
Of course, they’ve talked a big game in trying to establish a rivalry with their neighbor to the west.
Suspended coach Kyle Flood last year continually referred to Penn State as “the team from Pennsylvania,” a tortured spin on Ohio State and Michigan coaches’ long history of refusing to refer to each other by name.
And wide receiver Leonte Caroo last September reacted to a perceived slight from now-former Penn State running back Bill Belton by telling the Asbury Park Press: “I wanted to stay home because I wanted to bring a championship back to New Jersey. You've got guys like Bill Belton saying that he wanted to go to Penn State because he wanted to play big-time football instead of staying home. Well, I guess we're going to have to show him he made a terrible decision."
Neither man, though, was even around Saturday to back up that bluster. Flood was suspended last week by the university president for trying to meddle in the academic affairs of one of his players, while Carroo was banned in connection with assault charges against him. Also conspicuous in their absence were six players dismissed by Flood who’ve been charged with crimes around the Rutgers campus in recent weeks.
And so the Knights were pounded into a pulp by a Penn State squad that only two weeks prior had suffered a humiliating defeat against long-time wannabe rival Temple and still is grappling with depth issues in the wake of NCAA sanctions related to the Jerry Sandusky child sexual abuse case.
A year after playing the Lions close in Piscataway, N.J., leading much of the game before succumbing to a late rally led by Penn State quarterback Christian Hackenberg, the Knights were uncompetitive offensively, managing just those three points and never seriously threatening the endzone.
And they weren’t much better defensively, allowing Lions running backs Akeel Lynch and Saquon Barkley to roll up 325 rushing yards on the evening, a miraculous turnaround for an offense that itself struggled immensely during the first two games of the season.
It was pathetic. And it should sting the Knights for a long time because this game, along with last season’s, represented probably their best shots for the foreseeable future to cut into Penn State’s 24-2 edge in the all-time series and build some genuine animosity between the schools.
Penn State, after all, is set to welcome the nation’s eighth-ranked recruiting class this winter, according to Rivals.com, after signing the No. 15 class for 2015 in February. If the trend continues, Penn State will be if not a powerhouse, then consistently in a league beyond Rutgers’ relative mediocrity of the last decade.
On top of that, Penn State will likely be distracted by far more compelling series with other foes in the years to come. Historic foil Pitt returns to the schedule for four years beginning in 2016, Maryland will be looking to fan the flames of discontent following its 20-19 win in State College last year in which the Terrapins infamously snubbed Penn State captains in the pre-game handshake, and annual games against the tradition-rich Buckeyes and Wolverines remain the dates Lions fans circle on their calendars.
With all that to look forward to, it’s hard to blame anyone sporting blue and white for looking at Rutgers’ angst with anything more than fleeting amusement.
There certainly was, and maybe still is, potential here. New Jersey is a state increasingly divided between Rutgers and Penn State alums as the latter has become more of a Mid-Atlantic magnet rather than simply a Pennsylvania phenomenon. A competitive series could have easily pitted those groups against each other household to household, street to street and cubicle to cubicle in much the same way the Pitt rivalry once stirred the passions in Western Pennsylvania.
But if Rutgers doesn’t step up its game soon, this series will remain exactly what it’s been historically: a formality.
Adam Bittner writes sports commentary for The Pittsburgh Press. He can be reached at abittner@post-gazette.com or via Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.