NORFOLK, Va. -- Next to the one-on-one drills and in front of a group of high schoolers, James Franklin pulled a handful of kids aside, one by one.
These were the select few football players whose technique, physical build or both made the Penn State coach point to -- or in some cases walk to the other side of the field and grab -- one of his Nittany Lions assistants, encouraging them to take a closer look.
The players smiled and nodded in agreement as Franklin, a whistle around his neck, talked with them. He told them he wanted to see more of the same dominance that caught his attention in the first place. If they could show that, maybe there would be a scholarship offer down the road.
Only a handful of the 1,000 kids at this June camp at Old Dominion University will be talented enough to earn a scholarship offer, but this satellite camp left Franklin smiling as his golf cart ripped out and he headed across campus to deliver the camp's closing remarks.
Two years ago, Franklin was not allowed to do this -- travel to "satellite" camps to talk to prospective athletes away from his campus at Vanderbilt University and make inroads with some of the country's best players. While the Southeastern Conference outlawed its coaches from attending satellite camps, the Big Ten permits it, and since being hired at Penn State before last season, Franklin has used the disparity to his advantage to expand Penn State's recruiting footprint.
"It's not just in the players you sign," Franklin said. "It's about maybe in different parts of the country having conversations about Penn State that maybe you haven't had conversations about Penn State before."
He's not alone, either. While NCAA rule 13.12.1.2, passed in 2007, doesn't permit coaches to play host to out-of-state camps more than 50 miles from their campuses, NCAA rule 13.12.2.3.3 allows them to serve as guest coaches at another school's camp.
Of coaches in the power five conferences, those in the Big Ten, Big 12 and Pac-12 are allowed to branch out beyond their campuses to serve as guests at whatever institution is willing to have them. Coaches in the SEC and ACC, whose conferences have rules against it, see this as an unfair advantage.
Alabama coach Nick Saban said at SEC media days in July it's important that all college programs have a level playing field when it comes to being allowed to participate in satellite camps. Even former Pitt coach Paul Chryst, now in his first season at Wisconsin where he is allowed to take part in a satellite camp, said "everyone should have equal access."
"There's change that's going to happen," Chryst said at Big Ten media days. "We have an opportunity to do what's right. I think we have great leadership in this conference at the forefront of that change, and I think you shouldn't be able to have one conference able to do it and another that's not."
While satellite camps are an attractive offer for coaches looking to make an impact with unfamiliar players, it also is an enticing opportunity for high school prospects. The camps help cut costs for players and their families, sometimes eliminating the need to travel to each school's individual one-day camp, where coaches can record times and measurements on prospects and work with them throughout the camp to see if they are a good fit.
Old Dominion coach Bobby Wilder said his family spent upward of $4,000 taking his son Derek to each school's one-day camp the past two summers. That's partly why Wilder has decided to partner with opposing coaches to stage satellite camps, where this June, 43 different coaching staffs, including Penn State's, came to his campus to evaluate hundreds of prospects.
"It really bothers me that we're at the point in college athletics that we're forgetting that there's a family, there's a student-athlete, there's folks that are trying to figure out how to pay for college," Wilder said. "And we're telling them -- much like my own son was told -- that you've got to do all these different one-days and you have to work out for just that school."
Wilder's Old Dominion staff will partner with Michigan and Penn State next summer for more satellite camps, with both Big Ten staffs looking to lure recruits from talent-rich Virginia.
While camps help coaches evaluate prospects, they are also a valuable tool for high school players to garner attention.
"Video doesn't always do you justice," said Robert Matos, whose son Yetur picked up a scholarship offer from Penn State after the Old Dominion satellite camp. Yetur, a 2017 defensive end with 12 scholarship offers, has since visited Penn State. "Some schools saw his video and they had reservations, but as soon as they saw him in person, it was a done deal."
Each camper's satellite camp registration fee -- $50 at Old Dominion -- goes to the host school while visiting coaches foot their own travel bills. Penn State athletics declined to disclose how much it spent on satellite camps the past two summers, but Penn State's recruiting budget continues to increase.
Recruiting expenses nearly tripled from fiscal year 2011 to fiscal year 2013, when the team spent $736,739 on recruiting. In fiscal year 2014, Penn State football's recruiting expenses jumped to $1,391,332.
"Contrary to popular opinions, we have budgets at Penn State," athletic director Sandy Barbour said. "You take a look at what our needs are, what our needs are to be competitive. It's interesting because you can't just say, dollar for dollar, 'Well so and so spends this much, so we need to spend this much.' "
The price of attending satellite camps deters some Big Ten coaches. Illinois coach Tim Beckman saw firsthand how to use them as a recruiting tool when he was the defensive coordinator on Mike Gundy's Oklahoma State staff in 2007-08. Gundy's staff worked at satellite camps in Texas long before the use of such camps became a national story line the past two summers, fueled by Franklin and new Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh.
At Illinois, Beckman's staff only holds camps in-state. Maryland coach Randy Edsall said his staff will not conduct satellite camps because he believes in the talent that solely resides in the program's recruiting footprint.
"It's definitely a money situation when you're making those decisions and you have a budget," Beckman said. "It was, I guess, a reward at Oklahoma State at the time, with the signing of quite a few players from the state of Texas."
Said Indiana coach Kevin Wilson, whose staff has yet to do a satellite camp despite being approached about it: "I'd be interested to look at these guys' budgets and the alumni jets they've flown around from place to place to place to place to place."
Michigan's self-titled "Summer Swarm Tour" took Harbaugh and his staff to nine satellite camps in recruiting hotbeds such as Alabama, Florida, Texas, California and even Pennsylvania. In two summers at Penn State, Franklin has taken his staff to Michigan, Florida, Illinois, Georgia, North Carolina and Virginia. Only time will tell if there is a positive return on those investments.
"I don't think there's a way to tell that right now," Franklin said. "Even our camps right now on our own campus, you're not getting a whole lot of players from your camps for that specific year. It's always the next year out. ... We'll find out in this year's class as well as next year's class. Did that first round have an impact?"
Sometimes judging the success of a satellite camp comes from part of the evaluation process that nobody outside the program ever sees, said Rutgers coach Kyle Flood. Rather than focusing on players gained because of the camps, eliminating those athletes who looked like a fit on film but weren't when they worked out in person is a key factor.
Rutgers went back to Florida this summer, a state whose pipeline to New Jersey began when former Scarlet Knights coach Greg Schiano planned one-day camps in South Florida in the early 2000s to help build his team. Using his former recruiting ties from his days as a defensive coordinator at Miami, Schiano plastered Rutgers billboards around the Sunshine State, and in 2006, Rutgers had 21 players from Florida on its roster.
The Scarlet Knights now have 10 players from Florida, still an unusually high number for a Big Ten team. Flood's staff also participated in satellite camps in Pennsylvania, Maryland and the Midwest this summer.
Satellite camps, he said, are worth the time and money because they give coaches more information and add to the evaluation process.
For Franklin, even a small return might make it worthwhile.
"[Recruiting] six hours from our campus is really important for us," Franklin said. "But, we've got to be able to complement those athletes with players from different parts of the country, and it may only be a handful.
"If it's one or two, and it's the right one or two, then it's worth it."
Audrey Snyder: asnyder@post-gazette.com and Twitter @audsnyder4.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.