UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. — The advantages of leaving college a year early and trying to cash in on an opportunity in the NFL make sense in some cases.
For the high-end prospects projected to go in the first or second round, leaving early is enticing. But for Penn State’s three underclassmen — tight end Jesse James, defensive end Deion Barnes and left tackle Donovan Smith — their decisions to skip their final year of eligibility and leave a year early for the NFL comes with many questions.
“I think most guys are susceptible to ego,” said Gil Brandt, the former Dallas Cowboys vice president of player personnel and NFL.com senior analyst. “[Agents] pull up the charts and say you’re going to get a $600,000 signing bonus or whatever it may be, and they don’t realize if you wait until next year instead of a $600,000 signing bonus you might get a $2 million signing bonus.
“The three of them that declared they probably would be best in school and developing their skills at Penn State and in the Big Ten.”
The race to the second contract, the one where NFL players have a chance for more financial security than their rookie deals, is a factor for many players. Making sure the players have a pattern of success in college that would make the early leap to the NFL worthwhile is where Dan Shonka, who works for Ourlads.com, a NFL scouting service that scouts and ranks pro prospects, questions the trio’s decisions.
Potential workouts at the NFL scouting combine and Penn State’s pro day will give them a chance to bolster their draft stock. Shonka has James as the highest-rated of the three (third or fourth round), with Barnes (in the fourth or fifth) and Smith (fifth) following.
James, the 6-foot-7, 254-pound tight end who wrapped up his junior season with 38 catches for 396 yards and three touchdowns, might benefit from the lack of tight-end depth in the class, Shonka said.
“I couldn’t really state a good argument for him to stay in school,” Shonka said. “He could be one of the bigger, faster guys in this draft. … I’m going to say third or fourth round and can’t really argue that he might’ve increased his stock a year from now, but I think his was probably a well thought-out plan and about the depth in this draft.”
Conversely, the depth at offensive tackle left Brandt wondering why Smith, a member of the Penn State line that surrendered 44 sacks this season, wouldn’t return for another season. Brandt wants to see the 6-5, 335-pound Smith’s arm length and strength, two factors that could boost him higher than his current ranking as 18th-best offensive tackle on Brandt’s list.
“This guy has the best chance as a long-range player of doing something,” Brandt said. “I don’t see him being drafted in the first two days and I would say that because if the guy came back he would do nothing but enhance his draft status.”
Perhaps Smith could also slide inside to guard, becoming what Shonka calls a “four-for-one” player? Such versatility would help his stock. So, too, would a strong showing at the Reese’s Senior Bowl. Smith received an invitation to that All-Star showcase because he had earned his degree even though he had a year of eligibility remaining.
As for Barnes, questions about his size (6-4, 255 pounds) and consistency persist. Barnes’ lack of production in his redshirt sophomore season — after claiming the Big Ten’s Randle El Freshman of the Year Award — and bounceback season in 2014 will be dissected.
So, too, will every combine event, interview and draft projection.
“When I did this last year, he was not a guy who rated very high,” Brandt said of Barnes. “He was not a very productive guy.
“Somewhere along the line, you’ve got to rate people on production. … I think you’d have to move him to that linebacker, 3-4 type of spot and just see what he can run.”
Audrey Snyder: asnyder@post-gazette.com and Twitter @audsnyder4.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.