UNIVERSITY PARK -- Lacking a quorum, nine Penn State University alumni trustees nevertheless pressed their case informally today for their school to sue the NCAA over 2012 campus sanctions and criticized the board’s majority for skipping the special meeting.

Chairman Keith Masser stayed away from the session, as he said he would last week. Penn State President Eric Barron, who was said this weekend to be keeping his options for attending open, also was not present for the 4 p.m. session.

“That will not stop us from having a discussion,” trustee Anthony Lubrano said.

“We’ll get as much done at this meeting as we do at any other meeting,” trustee Al Lord told about 45 people assembled in a meeting room of the Penn State Conference Center Hotel. “We won’t walk out on you if you start to talk, we’ll listen to you.”

Advertise with us

“This board must change,” he added. “...This board began digging the sewer that we’re in 2011 and we’re still digging.”

Trustee William Oldsey, who participated by phone given hip replacement surgery, told the room, “My backbone is fine .... I do think that’s an important quality when you’re on the board.”

Read More

State Sen. Jake Corman and state Treasurer Rob McCord. filed their lawsuit against the NCAA, challenging the validity of the consent decree that then-Penn State President Rodney Erickson signed with the NCAA amid the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal.

The decree set in motion landmark sanctions against the university and its football program, some since lifted, that included a bowl ban, $60 million in fines, lost scholarships and forfeited wins under late coach Joe Paterno.

Penn State is now a defendant in the lawsuit, but the nine recently elected alumni trustees want Penn State to switch sides and become a plaintiff. They used a little-known bylaw that allows seven or more of the board’s 30 members to secure a special meeting, though 16 attendees were needed for the trustees to take official action.

Advertise with us

Mr. Masser, who called the special meeting reluctantly, said last week said the board already had agreed not to take up the lawsuit again until after the New Year. He asked the nine to reconsider but they declined.

He told fellow trustees they as well could choose not to attend and later said a quorum was not likely.

As a result, Penn State said it would not stream today’s session live. That decision seemed to deprive the nine insurgent alumni members of a valuable public platform as they seek to persuade the board to switch sides in the NCAA lawsuit, joining plaintiffs who want sanctions imposed by that body against the university overturned.

“I continue to be concerned by the single-minded focus and the steady stream of resolutions that have required inordinate amounts of trustee time spent on one issue ... (diverting focus) from a wide range of vital university issues,” Mr. Masser wrote.

Mr. Lubrano in response said Thursday “that one issue” Mr. Masser cited had cost Penn State $150 million so far in sanctions and other costs. “Without question, it has increased the cost of education,” he said.

Advertise with us

That comment drew a sharp response from Ms. Powers, who on Friday reiterated a position Penn State has maintained since 2012, that “costs associated with the Sandusky matter are not funded by student tuition, taxpayer funds or donations.”

She said the university maintains General Liability and Directors & Officers insurance policies that the school wants to cover legal claims brought against the university and its officers, employees and trustees. She said other expenses not covered by insurance are to be handled using interest revenues related to loans made by Penn State to self-supporting units within the university.

Penn Staters for Responsible Stewardship, or PS4RS, a group of alumni and others long critical of the university’s handling of the Sandusky matter, registered its displeasure today with Mr. Masser’s position and Penn State’s decision not to enable alumni and others to watch the proceedings remotely on a live stream.

“It is disappointing that the Chairman of the Penn State Board of Trustees has stated that he will not support a special meeting to discuss the single most defining event in the history of the university, one that has cost Penn State more than $150 million and counting,” spokeswoman Maribeth Roman Schmidt said. “Worse, it is derelict to purposefully deprive an engaged and passionate alumni constituency from a live stream of the meeting.”

Sandusky, a retired assistant football coach at Penn State, is in prison after conviction on multiple sex assaults against boys.

Advertise with us

The session today was to discuss a motion by Mr. Lubrano regarding the lawsuit. He and alumni-elected trustee Robert Jubelirer called the lack of attendance at the meeting “one of the saddest days” of their careers. Jubelirer called Masser’s no show “irresponsibility” and “absolute arrogance.” Discussions of fiduciary responsibility and what the board of trustees role should be moving forward were brought up by the alumni-elected trustees.

A statement by there was a statement from state senator John T. Yudichak was read to the meeting.

“Regrettably, as a result of Chairman Keith Masser’s unprecedented move to prevent a quorum from being present, you are not able to vote on the resolution,” it read. “Separate from the merits of the resolution, which I fully support, the egregious actions of Chairman Masser point to a disturbing trend by the board majority to contravene the spirit of University bylaws and to stubbornly ignore long-standing state laws that prescribe membership on the Penn State Board of Trustees.”