A day after Penn State University’s trustees board chairman reluctantly called a meeting, then said he would neither attend nor participate and told other trustees they could do the same, some obvious if awkward questions remained.
Just who will show up in the board room of the Penn State Conference Center Hotel, University Park, at 4 p.m. Monday?
Will the university follow normal practice and stream the proceedings live on its website — at least until a roll call determines if a quorum exists?
And no matter what the turnout, how can a governing board so seemingly divided reach consensus any time soon on which side it should be on in the ongoing lawsuit against the NCAA over sanctions it imposed on Penn State in 2012?
“I’ve never experienced anything quite like the board of trustees at Penn State,” said trustee Anthony Lubrano, one of nine alumni-elected members who used an obscure board rule that lets seven or more members compel the 30-member board to schedule a meeting. Sixteen must attend to constitute a quorum to conduct business.
He and the other recently elected alumni members want the board to rethink what they contend was an ill-conceived and inappropriate decision by former Penn State president Rodney Erickson to sign the NCAA consent decree in the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse case.
Read More
The university is a defendant in the NCAA suit, brought by state Sen. Jake Corman and state Treasurer Rob McCord, challenging the validity of the consent decree and seeking to enforce a state law requiring a $60 million fine to be spent on child abuse programs in Pennsylvania. The consent decree led to landmark sanctions against the state’s flagship public university and its football program, some since lifted, that also included a bowl ban, lost scholarships and nullified wins.
The alumni members want Penn State to become a plaintiff and challenge all of the sanctions.
In a message to the board released Wednesday night by Penn State, chairman Keith Masser said he asked the alumni to reconsider their meeting request, given that the lawsuit had already been discussed. But the nine refused.
“I continue to be concerned by the single-minded focus and the steady stream of resolutions that have required inordinate amounts of trustee time spent on one issue, and deflected attention from a wide range of vital university issues,” Mr. Masser wrote.
Then, an unusual note became even more so.
“Given that the Board has already clearly and formally expressed its determination to consider the resolution proposed by Trustee [Anthony] Lubrano in January, I am not intending to attend or participate in any special meeting to consider the matter,” Mr. Masser wrote. “Members of the Board are likewise free to decide whether or not to attend any such meeting.
“I note that under the Bylaws, no action may be taken at any regular or special meeting unless a quorum of the members of the Board are present.”
Mr. Lubrano said that disappointed him. He said the single issue the chairman refers to is mammoth and “has cost Penn State $150 million so far. Without question it has increased the cost of education.”
Keith Masser’s full message:
To the Members of the Board of Trustees:
The alumni elected trustees sent a letter to me dated December 8, 2014 notifying me that they had called a special meeting of the Board of Trustees for Monday, December 15, 2014 at 2:00 p.m. at the Penn Stater to continue consideration of the resolution presented by Trustee Lubrano at the November 14, 2014 meeting. (A copy of the letter is attached.) Yesterday, I asked the alumni elected trustees to withdraw their call for a meeting, but they declined to do so. As set forth in the Bylaws, the Secretary of the Board is required to give notice of the meeting and therefore, tomorrow you will receive a notice from the Board office with respect to the meeting.
I continue to be concerned by the single-minded focus and the steady stream of resolutions that have required inordinate amounts of trustee time spent on one issue, and deflected attention from a wide range of vital university issues. This is a significant problem. It is incumbent upon this Board to devote more time in 2015 dealing with the critical issues that affect our University and, most importantly, our students. Our fiduciary responsibility as trustees demands this.
Each year, over 90,000 families entrust their children to Penn State. We must devote serious time and attention to the issues of access and affordability, and work together to ensure our students don't enter the workforce heavily in debt. As President Barron has noted, our University is also an important economic development force in Pennsylvania. This Board must explore ways in which we can maximize the University's role, and in doing so, create better job opportunities for our graduating students. Other strategic imperatives demand our intention, including the potential merger with PinnacleHealth System, which will dramatically change how we educate our medical students and provide care. I urge each member of the Board to consider how we might better work together in 2015 to enable our University to better serve our students and other important constituencies.
This requires we pause to reflect on the constant resolutions being put forward and meetings being called.
You will recall that after discussion the Board voted in November to postpone consideration of Trustee Lubrano’s proposed resolution until the Board’s executive session in January. Notwithstanding the fact that the Board determined to postpone consideration of the resolution until January, and even though time has been reserved at our January executive session for this discussion, the alumni elected trustees are now seeking to accelerate the discussion to a time of their choosing. Given that the Board has already clearly and formally expressed its determination to consider the resolution proposed by Trustee Lubrano in January, I am not intending to attend or participate in any special meeting to consider the matter. Members of the Board are likewise free to decide whether or not to attend any such meeting. I note that under the Bylaws, no action may be taken at any regular or special meeting unless a quorum of the members of the Board are present.
I recognize that there is a trial set for early January and the proposed resolution could be moot by the time of the January meeting. Nevertheless, this was known at the time the Board voted to postpone consideration, and a clear majority voted for the postponement. In these circumstances, I think it is counter to the will of the majority to go forward with a discussion and action prior to the time expressly set by vote of the Board of Trustees in November.
In the coming year, I hope all Board members are prepared to work together on the many critical issues our University faces.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.