Ron Zook was talking about reputation.

The Illinois football coach was on the podium at the Big Ten Conference meetings in July, talking about the Big Ten's image, and specifically about how the Big Ten didn't look so big these days -- especially when compared to the SEC, where Zook previously coached.

At first Zook fell back on a familiar game plan: blame the media. But then he said what most suspect many have been feeling for a long time.

It's time to put up or shut up.

Advertise with us

"Until we go win, until we win the bowl games and obviously win the games out of conference, there's not really a whole lot we can say," Zook said.

Because the numbers don't lie.

The Big Ten is on a losing streak in big-time games. The conference is 0-fer in its past six BCS bowl games, including two losses by Ohio State in national championship games. In the Rose Bowl, The Granddaddy of Them All, the Big Ten has lost six in a row. Here's more: The conference went 1-6 overall in bowl games last season and hasn't had a winning bowl campaign since 2002.

Now does that sound like a reputation that needs a little burnishing?

Conference coaches can crunch numbers with the best of them. They know things have to get better or Big Ten bashing is only going to get worse. But, heading into this fall's action, optimism still rules.

Advertise with us

"I think our league is poised to have a big bowl performance, very soon," Michigan coach Rich Rodriguez said. Of course, grain of salt time: Rodriguez took over at Michigan last year and promptly had the program's first-ever nine-loss season.

Indeed, Michigan's sudden fall from national grace is one of the Big Ten's problems when it comes to its national credibility. Face it: For the Big Ten to be a player, Michigan has to be playing well.

"Look at who's coming back in our league," Rodriguez continued. "As a league, once we get a few big wins -- whether it's regular season, nonconference or BCS bowls or bowl games, that perception is going to change."

Perhaps. But how did it get to this?

Opinions vary.

Advertise with us

Gerry DiNardo is a commentator for the Big Ten Network. He's seen both sides of the Big Ten-SEC debate, as a head coach at Vanderbilt, LSU and Indiana.

"I think the SEC has been the best conference recently," he said. "With all the quarterbacks in the Big 12, you could make a case they're the second conference recently. I've always felt the top teams in all the conferences are pretty close. ... But I don't think the Big Ten is at its strongest point right now."

Part of it is cyclical, DiNardo said. A conference's overall quality is going to ebb and flow. Michigan -- the winningest team in the history of college football -- is down, and that's not good for the league.

There hasn't been a bevy of great quarterback play in the Big Ten in recent seasons, either, though that could be changing. DiNardo also pointed to Notre Dame, a traditional Big Ten nonconference rival. The Irish have been down as well, which hasn't helped.

Getting tougher

Advertise with us

Too many Big Ten teams have gone the cream puff route in nonconference play. Take Penn State. This season the Nittany Lions, coming off a Rose Bowl loss to USC, has the killer lineup of Akron, Syracuse, Temple and Eastern Illinois. The Lions could roar through all of those games and what will it prove? Better yet, how will it make Penn State better prepared for postseason success?

Too many schools go with a preseason-lite formula trying to become bowl-eligible with six victories. Even Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany has admitted he's not sure this is the right thing to do. Conference teams with fewer than eight victories heading into bowl games have won only three of their past 16 bowl games.

Gophers coach Tim Brewster has been an advocate of tougher nonconference schedules since coming to Minnesota. This season the Gophers play at Syracuse and play host to Air Force and California. In 2010 and 2011, there is a home-and-home series with USC.

"Each coach has got to go the direction he feels like his particular school needs to go," Brewster said. "We at the University of Minnesota have chosen a more aggressive path, and it's a path that I think is going to allow us to reach our ultimate goal, and that's win a championship in the Big Ten."

Playing later

Advertise with us

Another issue is when the games are played. The Big Ten traditionally has not played after Thanksgiving, which often meant long layoffs between the end of the regular season and bowl games while other teams were playing into December. This season Illinois' Zook and Wisconsin coach Bret Bielema will have their teams playing the week after the Big Ten schedule ends.

"It's a great opportunity for our guys to prolong the season," Zook said. "To me, that's one way we feel we can help ourselves."

Zook would like an open date in the 12-game schedule, pushing games into December.

"I think it's a tough deal for a Big Ten team to go out and play a team that's had two good tough games after we've finished and we're sitting around," Penn State coach Joe Paterno said.

Restoring tradition

Advertise with us

Michigan is in a mini-swoon. But Rodriguez has a history of doing well in his second season at a school. And let's face it, the Big Ten needs a strong Michigan program. In the past 40 years, conference teams have finished in the top 10 of the final AP poll 63 times. Michigan accounts for 24 of those.

This season the Wolverines and Rodriguez will turn to a new quarterback (or three) to try to lead Michigan back. The Big Ten's reputation could go along with it.

Big play-makers

Big Ten fans, take heart: There is a lot of talent returning this season. High-profile talent.

The top six quarterbacks from last season are back, including Ohio State's Terrelle Pryor, Penn State's Daryll Clark, Illinois' Juice Williams and the Gophers' Adam Weber. Seven teams have 14 starters or more back. Pryor leads the Buckeyes, one of two Big Ten teams in the preseason top 10. Penn State has more preseason candidates for national awards than any other conference team.

Advertise with us

We'll know if there is reason for hope when Ohio State plays USC on Sept. 12.

"I still go back to 2002, coming into this meeting," Iowa coach Kirk Ferentz said at the Big Ten meetings. "The sky was clearly falling. That was the tenor of the meeting. At the end of the season, we had four teams in the top 13 with Ohio State winning the national championship."

------

(c) 2009, Star Tribune (Minneapolis)

Visit the Star Tribune Web edition on the World Wide Web at http://www.startribune.com

Advertise with us

Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

----------

ARCHIVE PHOTOS on MCT Direct (from MCT Photo Service, 202-383-6099):

"BIG TEN FOOTBALL"