STATE COLLEGE -- A rape charge and all other criminal charges against former Penn State running back Austin Scott were dropped yesterday.

The decision came after the state Superior Court ruled earlier yesterday that jurors could hear testimony about the alleged victim's involvement in a separate sexual assault case in 2003. The defendant in that case was acquitted.

The Centre County district attorney's office said in a statement it withdrew the charges because there was "no reasonable likelihood" it could meet the burden of proof.

"It is with deep regret that we ... withdraw the charges against Austin Scott," the statement said.

Advertise with us

Scott was en route yesterday from State College to his home in Allentown.

"Finally, justice," defense attorney John Karoly said in a phone interview from his Allentown office.

Karoly said Scott was "happy and troubled" when he heard the news, and that Scott questioned why the case started in the first place when prosecutors were aware of the previous case.

Scott, 23, never played for Penn State again after Paterno suspended him Oct. 5, citing a violation of team rules. Police charged Scott a week later.

A team spokesperson declined comment on the development.

Advertise with us

On Tuesday, the day before the trial was to begin, prosecutors appealed Centre County Judge Thomas Kistler's ruling allowing evidence of the woman's involvement in the earlier case to be heard.

The woman in the earlier trial "admitted, under oath; to lying about the sexual intercourse being forced and stated that it that was, in fact, consensual for several hours," Kistler wrote in one order.

The state Superior Court sided with the defense in allowing the evidence.

"The facts of the case have not changed from the time he was arrested," said the statement from the district attorney's office. "However, the trial judge has ruled evidence of the victim's past is relevant to this case though it has always been our position that the evidence of the victim's past is irrelevant."

Karoly said Scott was offered a plea bargain after the appeals court ruled but declined and was confident he would be acquitted at trial. The case, Karoly said, was pursued with "unusual vigor" by assistant district attorney Lance Marshall.