Q: Complaining about officials seems like whining, but the two calls Saturday regarding the dropped pass and the non-interference were so blatant that I wonder when the media decide to investigate officiating within the Big Ten. Specifically: how are officials selected; how much are they paid; are they graded, if so, by whom; what are grades assigned the officials at Penn State Saturday; what are results of instant replay within Big Ten to date; why was the review of officiating performed by the people being assessed, and was any action taken regarding officials working the game?

Have your own question for Ray?

Click here to submit your question

J. R. from Bel Air, Md.

Advertise with us

FITTIPALDO: Me and the rest of the beat writers for Penn State can answer most of your questions because we've had so much experience talking to Big Ten officials, including David Parry, the supervisor of officials. First off, I called Penn State sports information director Jeff Nelson on Monday and asked if Penn State had filed any kind of official complaint with the Big Ten office. He said he was unaware of anyone doing that. He said the way it normally works is that Paterno will splice a videotape together and send it off for Parry to review. Parry will then get back to Paterno at some point. Officials are selected by Parry. Most of the officials the Big Ten hires come from the Mid-American Conference. The Big Ten has a working relationship with that conference developing officials. When a Big Ten official graduates to the NFL or is demoted, another official is promoted. Yes, they are graded every week. Parry goes to a game every week. When he attends a game in person, he will sit down with officials immediately following the game and watch the videotape with them on site. I'm sure grades were assigned to the officials for the Ohio State game, but the Big Ten does not make them public. I don't know how much they are paid. But like NFL officials they are not full-time employees of the conference and work other jobs during the week. The results of the study the Big Ten is conducting on replay will not be made public. Commissioner Jim Delany said he will discuss instant replay after the study and decide whether it can be used next season in some form. The so-called "comprehensive review" of the officiating last season was done by Parry and Delany. It was merely done to appease Penn State and they went through the motions in doing it. Only a few officials were disciplined or demoted. I also called the Big Ten this week. Associate commissioner Scott Chipman said the league has no formal process for filing a complaint. He said coaches usually just deal with Parry. The conference has apologized for poor officiating in the past. There was a game involving Illinois and Michigan a few years back, where a couple of obvious call went against the Illini. Delany sent out a press release, which infuriated Michigan coach Lloyd Carr because he thought it diminished his team's victory. If an apology is issued to Penn State, I don't think the conference will send out another press release. I think the public will find out about it through Penn State. So far, that hasn't happened.

Q: After watching this game, it is again obvious the Big Ten officials are against Penn State. The bad calls were so blatantly wrong the announcers were in disbelief. (I don't have to list them everyone knows what they were.) There is no way these refs can continually be this incompetent. They purposely make calls against Penn State - there is no doubt about it the evidence is clear. This should be the last straw. We really should get out of the Big Ten. Call the ACC tomorrow; or go to the Big East, or anywhere else. How can fans help make this happen? Also, will these calls be reviewed and the refs disciplined or hopefully fired?

Gus Gianikas of Ocala, Fla.

FITTIPALDO: It's easy to understand why Penn State fans feel so passionate about the blown calls. Not only are the officials making mistakes, but they are making them in the fourth quarter in crucial situations. The mistakes made last season were also in overtime or in the fourth quarter. I don't think the officials are sticking it to Penn State on purpose. I just think they're incompetent. And that's why Big Ten commissioner Jim Delany has to figure out a way for replay to be used in his league's games. Too many mistakes have been made and there doesn't seem to be any improvement from year to year. This has been a three- or four-year saga involving the league's officials. No other conferences has this many problems with officials. Paterno has been more diplomatic about the mistakes. He said after the Ohio State game that the officials deserve to have replay, so some of the pressure can be alleviated. My problem with the mistake on Ohio State's winning drive was that no official signaled a catch until about 5 or 10 seconds after the play had ended. It was obvious that none of them had seen the play happen. How can this happen? How can one official out of eight not see the football hit the turf. It's one thing to make a mistake. It's another to be indecisive and wrong at the same time. The officials ruined what otherwise was a tremendous college football game.

Q: Ray, I enjoy your Q&A column each week. Many of your comments are about highly recruited high school athletes who are unsuccessful at Penn State. What is going on? When Kevin Jones picked Virginia Tech a couple of years ago his family disagreed with the strength training PSU does -- is this the problem?

Advertise with us

Brian from Seattle, Wash.

FITTIPALDO: The strength and conditioning program at Penn State has been a topic of discussion in recent years because Penn State's interior lines have not performed well. They are getting physically pushed around in the trenches. Penn State's strength and conditioning program utilizes a high intensity training philosophy which maximizes time and efficiency and effort in workouts roughly 30-45 minutes in duration. Muscles are trained to and beyond exhaustion using the same philosophy employed by the Baltimore Ravens, New York Giants, Pittsburgh Steelers, St. Louis Rams, Washington Redskins and several other NFL teams, according to the Penn State media guide. Penn State coach Joe Paterno treats strength and conditioning coach John Thomas like the pope, shrouding his methods and practices in secrecy. He does not allow Thomas or other strength and conditioning coaches to speak with reporters. Obviously, there have been critics out there. Some have taken to the program. Others have not. Paterno has admitted that it takes longer for his players to get bigger and stronger because they are doing it "the right way." In other words, Penn State players are not using steroids or doing things that can potentially damage players later in life.

Q: Pre- and post-Big Ten membership, what is Joe Pa's record against the leagues "Big Two"?

Dr. Charles T. Fortine of Wildwood, Fla.

FITTIPALDO: Penn State is 3-7 against Michigan under Joe Paterno, with all games in the series coming since 1993. The Wolverines have won the past six meetings. Penn State is 6-9 against Ohio State under Paterno, 4-7 against the Buckeyes since '93. The Buckeyes have won three of the past four in the series.

Advertise with us

Q: I have several questions concerning walk-ons. Do they report to summer camp at the same time the scholarship players do? Do walk-ons have to make the team each year? Do they participate in the winter program and the training table?

Ron Harding of Baltimore, Md.

FITTIPALDO: There are two kinds of walk-ons. There are preferred walk-ons and walk-ons. Preferred walk-ons report to summer camp with the rest of the team and don't have to make the team every year after the first season. They do participate in the winter program, but they are not allowed to eat at training table with the team under NCAA rules. Other walk-ons do not report with the rest of the team at summer camp, but try out when school begins. They also can participate in the winter program and are not allowed to eat training table. Walk-ons can be given scholarships at any time. Some are given scholarships after only a few weeks on campus while other wait until their final season for some aid.

Q: A few years ago Penn State recruited a highly ranked quarterback from California. I don't remember his name. As I recall he enrolled at Penn State early and played during Spring drills, but then left school. Any idea as to what became of him?

Jim Rebel from Ocean Pines, Md.

Advertise with us

FITTIPALDO: The player you are thinking of is Zac Wasserman, and he might be out of college football all together. After leaving Penn State after his freshman season, he went to Los Angeles Valley Junior College. Then, he transferred to California, where he was supposed to vie for a backup position behind Kyle Boller last season. I looked at Cal's roster for this season and he wasn't on it.

Q: WOW! It was nice to finally see a couple of guys in blue catch the ball. While last Saturday was yet another loss, I can't help but feel that this young team is at least approaching a corner to turn. The offensive line appears to be making strides, even though the running game was non-existent against the Buckeyes. At least Mills had plenty of time to make his reads. I especially noticed Charles Rush seems to be showing signs of his blue-chip status. Does the coaching staff feel anyone else is starting to stand out? Have they finally settled on a consistent line?

Mark Sprague from Sterling, Va.

FITTIPALDO: Yes, it was nice to see some players making catches for Mills. I was impressed with Terrance Phillips, who had two catches for 47 yards, including one twisting catch that helped set up Penn State's first touchdown. Where has he been all year? Humphrey also seems to be coming along. The potential is there for next season, but there is still a long way to go. They are making mistakes because of their inexperience. Humphrey was supposed to run an 8-yard out on the second-to-last play of the game. He ran a 3-yard out instead. But hey, at least he caught the ball. As for the offensive line, they're going with what they've got. It's a young group that is average right now. With some seasoning, they could be good in a year or two.

Q: Do you have any insight into why Tim Johnson never plays? The season is lost and we need to be building for next year. Capone has been lousy and Ryland and Johnson should be playing more.

Advertise with us

Carmen White of Tallahassee, Fla.

FITTIPALDO: Johnson is a redshirt junior who has had his share of injuries and spent his share of time in coach Joe Paterno's dog house. He was arrested for driving under the influence a few years back and had an injury last season. He is playing on special teams. I agree that Capone is not playing all that well, but he did make second-team all-Big Ten last season. The players in front of him aren't as good. I'm not so sure Johnson or Ryland would make much of a difference if the coaches put them in there.

Q: I have a confession to make. In late August my wife and I found out that she was pregnant with our first child. As a paranoid father-to-be, I made a bet with God to endure the worst football season imaginable in exchange for a healthy baby. Since that promise, Penn State lost five games in a row. My other favorite team is the Steelers. No need to explain further. So I wanted to formally apologize to all the Penn State fans for this selfish act. Pin this season on me. Stop blaming Joe, the refs, the coaches, or the team, because it is not in their hands anymore. I feel much better getting this off my chest. I promise to think twice about making a similar bet for our second child. Maybe I'll hope for the worst imaginable baseball season, the last 11 Pirates seasons have prepared us well.

Rob York of Alexandria, Va.

FITTIPALDO: Way to take one for the team, Rob.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.