Pitt volleyball coach Dan Fisher knew there were aspects of his team that, given the right set of circumstances, could be exploited.

Those weaknesses were exposed by Southern Methodist, which knocked the Panthers (14-1, 4-1 ACC) from the ranks of the unbeaten

In what looked like it would be a win going away by Pitt, sixth-ranked SMU (13-2, 5-0) rallied and, in doing so, took over sole possession of first place in the ACC with a stunning 3-1 (21-25, 25-19, 38-36, 25-22) upset victory against the No. 2-ranked Panthers on Wednesday at Petersen Events Center. The loss ended the Panthers’ NCAA-best 58-match home winning streak that included matches at The Pete, Fitzgerald Field House and Victory Heights.

Pitt’s last defeat on its home court came on Sept. 14, 2023, in a 3-2 decision to Oregon at Fitzgerald Field House.

Advertise with us

“I think it’s one thing having Fish tell us what we need to do better and it’s another having it completely reflect in a game and it’s the reason why we lost,” Pitt outside hitter Olivia Babcock said. “It just confirms what Fish has been doing. He’s been holding us to a high standard in practice and telling us what we need to work on and we just haven’t been able to flip the switch. SMU saw that and took advantage of it and it worked.”

When the match opened it appeared it would be just another sweep for Pitt. Although SMU took a 1-0 lead in the first set, it was the only lead the team had in the opening stanza as the Panthers leaped out to a 14-7 advantage and eased into a 25-21 win.

It didn’t get any better in the second set for SMU as Pitt opened fast. Babcock notched her 176th career ace in the second set to break a tie with Lindsey Zitzke for the program record and, with that point, gave the Panthers an early 7-3 lead.

But aces are also what helped SMU get back into the match.

SMU chipped away and got back within striking distance at 10-11 with libero Victoria Harris serving. Harris had three consecutive aces to give the Mustangs their first lead at any point since the opening point of the match, while they never relinquished as they took the second set, 25-19.

Advertise with us

Babcock then set another Panthers benchmark with her 14th kill of the match in the third set. That gave her 1,853 kills in her career to eclipse former record holder Diana Andreyko.

Even the record couldn’t hold back SMU, which opened up a 22-19 lead in the third set and appeared to have Pitt on the ropes.

Although the Mustangs did win the set, the Panthers didn’t make it easy on them. Pitt fought back behind a SMU service error and a kill from Blaire Bayless to tie the set at 23. The two teams went back and forth and the Mustangs even had a set point taken away from them on review when Pitt was incorrectly called for four touches at 30-29.

But Pitt could not take advantage of five early set points, which eventually gave SMU the opening it needed. Natalia Newsome finally finished the set off with three consecutive kills to give the Mustangs a 38-36 win and a 2-1 lead in the match.

“It’s been a long time since we’ve been in a nail-biter set like that and we’ve got to experience those emotions,” Fisher said. “Both teams were nervous and making mistakes in that third, but I thought we got our vibe back a little bit even though we didn’t pull it out.”

Advertise with us

Turning point

Pitt had a 21-20 lead in the fourth set when SMU took a timeout to stem the tide. It worked to perfection as the Mustangs reeled off three consecutive points to take a 23-21 lead and force the Panthers to take a timeout of their own.

Unlike SMU, Pitt came out of the timeout and immediately dropped a point, which gave the Mustangs three match points. Not surprisingly it was Newsome, who was tied with Suli Davis for the team lead with 17 kills, who put it away.

Quick hits

Babcock led the Panthers with 25 kills and now has 1,864 in her career. It the most she’s had in a match this season since she finished with 27 on Kentucky in the opener.

With the loss Pitt dropped to 6-1 against ranked teams this season. The Panthers were 2-0 against top 10 teams.

In the third set the two teams staved off a combined 13 set points.

Advertise with us

Pitt had not lost two sets in a match this season and had won 28 consecutive sets before dropping the second against SMU. The Panthers’ last set loss came in the first set of a 3-1 win at Utah on Sept. 6.

Quotable

“There’s a lot of season left and we want to be at our best in December when we’re in the tournament. I think this loss gives us a lot things to want to work on in practice and this team will take the challenge, for sure.” — Bayless.

Up next

Since this was the first in a home-and-home series, the Panthers will have to take a long, hard look at the video from this one since they travel to Dallas for a rematch with SMU. The two will square off Sunday at 3 p.m. on ESPN.

“I think that it just gives us a chance to reflect,” Babcock said. “They’re a really good team and they showed us things that we knew that were wrong with our game that we just didn’t fix.”