The NCAA voted to expand its tournament for basketball to 76 teams Thursday. Here are some relatively recent local teams that may have benefited from the expansion to participate in March Madness instead of being snubbed:
2025-26 West Virginia
Just this past March, the Mountaineers were one of the first teams out of the 68-team field. Many bracketologists projected they’d make the final cut, so their exclusion was a bit of a surprise to some.
They finished with a .500 record in conference play, which is typically good enough for an at-large bid from a power conference, especially considering the Big 12 was strong enough to put eight teams into the tournament this year.
Alas, West Virginia lost its first game in the Big 12 tournament against Colorado. And it struggled down the stretch, dropping five of its last seven games to finish with 14 total losses. So coach Ross Hodge’s team fell short, while mid-major darling Miami (Ohio) was admitted as an at-large team after losing just once all season.
2023-24 Pitt
Hopes were high for this squad after coach Jeff Capel had returned the Panthers to the tournament for the first time since 2015-16 the previous spring.
The group was led by veterans Blake Hinson, Ishmael Leggett and and Zack Austin and complemented by impressive freshmen Jaland Lowe and Bub Carrington, who was subsequently drafted into the NBA. Unfortunately for Capel, the team couldn’t overcome one of the lowest-rated nonconference schedules in the entire country.
Read More
The ACC was perceived to be very weak that year, as it placed just five teams in the field. Pitt’s ability to impress the committee with its 12-8 conference record was therefore diminished, so the Panthers were listed among the committee’s first four out, signaling they’d have been in the now-expanded field.
2017-18 Penn State
As PennLive.com columnist Dave Jones noted at the time, no team had been left out with a .500-or-better league record and at least two wins in the Big Ten tournament — until this group of Nittany Lions was.
Led by Lamar Stevens and Tony Carr, who two years later helped Penn State surge into the top 10 nationally before the tournament was canceled because of the COVID-19 pandemic, Penn State pulled three upsets of ranked Ohio State teams. But a nonconference loss to Rider proved damaging, as the Lions were forced to settle for the NIT.
It’s questionable whether this group would have made the Big Dance, considering it was just a No. 4 seed even in the lesser tournament. But Penn State fans will long play the “what if?” game, considering coach Patrick Chambers was able to rally his group to win the NIT title and finish with 26 wins, the second-best total in program history.
2008-09 Penn State
No. 1 on that win total list for the Nittany Lions was this group that had a winning conference record at 10-8, with four of those wins coming against ranked teams.
That was good enough for a fourth-place finish for coach Ed DeChellis, a Pittsburgh area native who surrounded star Jamelle Cornley and veteran point guard Stanley Pringle with talented freshmen Talor Battle, Andrew Jones, Jeff Brooks and D.J. Jackson.
However, nonconference losses to Rhode Island and Temple, plus a second-round exit in the Big Ten tournament, proved too much to overcome. The Nittany Lions were forced to settle for a No. 2 seed in the NIT, which they went on to win at Madison Square Garden. This team likely would have made the cut amid the expansion.
2006-07 West Virginia
The best team by record on this list benefited or suffered from a weak schedule, depending on how you look at it.
Coach John Beilein’s group collected two ranked wins against No. 12 UConn and No. 2 UCLA at home. It faced just two other power-conference foes and had Division II Slippery Rock on its regular season slate.
The committee was unimpressed in the end, especially within a top-heavy Big East that placed five teams in the final AP poll of the season.
The standout starting group of Frank Young, Darris Nichols, Alex Ruoff, Joe Alexander and De’Sean Butler — all of whom averaged double-figure points per game — were left with only a top NIT seed to hang their collective hat on. Like the Penn State teams above, they proved their bona fides by winning the NIT and probably would have been the surest lock to make a 76-team field on this list.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.