When the exodus started, the reaction was immediate.
Players entered the transfer portal in waves and with each departure, the anxiety around Pitt men’s basketball roster grew louder. By the time the dust settled, the Panthers were left with just one returning scholarship player — a near-complete teardown of the previous season.
Less than two weeks later, the tone shifted just as quickly.
Pitt has added eight transfers, rapidly constructing a brand-new roster through the portal. In the modern era of college basketball, roster turnover is expected. But what Pitt is attempting ahead of the 2026-27 season goes beyond typical churn.
The question now isn’t how the Panthers got here — it’s whether this kind of overhaul actually can work.
The normalcy of it all
At a baseline level, Pitt’s reliance on the transfer portal isn’t unusual. It’s almost unavoidable.
Read More
Across the sport, most programs bring in multiple transfers each offseason to fill out their rotation. Over the past four years, Pitt has averaged roughly three portal additions per season — a number that aligns with what many high-major programs consider standard.
But there is a threshold where “normal” begins to blur.
“Pretty much every team at the high-major level is looking to bring in multiple transfers to be in their rotation,” said George Michalowski, co-founder of The Portal Report. “It’s very normal to bring in multiple transfers. Anywhere above five transfers you’re bringing in to play a lot of minutes. That’s where you kind of get less predictable.”
Pitt already has surpassed that mark.
That’s not to say traditional recruiting and four-year players are gone. There are schools that really value that continuity, with Purdue and Michigan State being two examples. Those programs have seen success with that retention, but even then they’re still bringing in a transfer or two.
Even players in stable, successful situations are leaving. That’s a reflection of how fluid the sport has become. Take Kansas’ Flory Bidunga, who recently landed at Louisville. He was a main player for the Jayhawks and still decided to look elsewhere.
Roman Siulepa from Pitt had a major role lined up for the 2026-27 season. He’s headed to Mississippi.
“There’s no real certainty anymore — other than that talented, successful players are going to have options,” Sporting News columnist Michael DeCourcy said. “From there, it’s up to them to decide whether they want to keep growing where they are or move on because they think they can earn more or develop more somewhere else.”
That uncertainty is what defines Pitt’s current moment. The Panthers aren’t just participating in the portal era — they’re operating at its extreme.
The duality of overhauls
If Pitt’s strategy feels risky, recent history would agree.
Teams that push past that threshold of five transfers tend to fall into two very different categories — those that click and those that collapse.
On one end, there are success stories.
Iowa cleaned house when Ben McCollum took over. Legacy Hawkeye Pryce Sandfort even headed elsewhere. McCollum essentially started from scratch. He brought over a few players from Drake with him and even landed Robert Morris’ Alvaro Folgueiras.
That brand-new team made a deep NCAA tournament run, reaching the Elite Eight.
“They brought in nine transfers last season and we saw them make a nice run in the tournament,” Michalowski said. “That’s a program that, especially when we’re talking about Pitt, is pretty comparable. A trip to the Elite Eight is a great run for a program like Iowa. It’d be a great run for a program like Pitt.”
Texas A&M is another good example. They brought in 11 transfers and pulled out a first-round NCAA tournament win.
But for every Iowa and Texas A&M, there’s a cautionary tale.
Memphis (13 transfers), Southern California (11) and Xavier (11) struggled, finishing with losing records despite aggressive portal rebuilds.
“Once you get above five or six transfers in a class, it’s been pretty rare — at least this past season — to see a group like that make a real run or even reach the NCAA tournament,” Michalowski said.
The difference often comes down to more than talent. Fit, personality and willingness to sacrifice all play a role in whether a collection of transfers becomes a team. It’s truly the difference between being an Iowa or a Memphis.
That variability is what makes Pitt’s outlook so difficult to project. The Panthers could follow the Iowa or Texas A&M path — or end up closer to Memphis.
Continuity still matters
If there’s a common thread among the most successful teams in the portal era, it’s not just who they add but who they keep.
Michigan, which won a national championship with six transfers, is often cited as the model. But even that roster wasn’t built entirely from scratch. They brought back Nimari Burnett, Will Tschetter, Roddy Gayle Jr. and L.J. Cason.
“They did a really nice job and an underrated job at Michigan of retaining culture,” DeCourcy said. “Nimari Burnett is an example. Will Tschetter, too. Guys who were leaders that they valued, kept and ultimately were able to win a championship.”
Those returning pieces weren’t the stars of Michigan — that goes to players such as Yaxel Lendeborg or Elliot Cadeau. But they provided leadership and continuity, which is something that can’t easily be replaced.
At Pitt, that element is absent. The only player they return played sparingly.
The 2022-23 team that reached the NCAA tournament is a useful comparison point. That roster added key transfers such as Nelly Cummings, Greg Elliott and Blake Hinson, but it also had an established core in Jamarius Burton and Nike Sibande.
“That was the team where they kind of plugged in some players perfectly,” Michalowski said. “They had a culture in place that was able to be passed down from [Jeff] Capel to Burton to the newcomers. Now, it’s very different, honestly, from that 2022-23 team.”
This time around, Pitt is building almost entirely from scratch. There’s no clear holdover leader, no established identity to pass down.
“Continuity to win championships is essential,” Michalowski said. “Continuity to make the NCAA tournament is not required.”
That distinction matters.
Can this work for Pitt?
That’s where the conversation ultimately lands — and where the stakes are highest.
With Capel facing mounting pressure, the margin for error is thin. An NCAA tournament berth isn’t just a goal; it’s likely a requirement.
“When you’re cleaning house and putting an entirely new team on the floor, you’re saying, ‘We’ve put all our chips in the middle. We’re all in on this group,’” Michalowski said. “You believe this roster can get you to the NCAA tournament. That’s how success is measured. It’s unfortunate, but it’s the reality.”
On paper, Pitt’s additions offer some reason for optimism.
The Panthers have brought in proven high-major contributors in Naithan George, Baye Ndongo and Jonathan Powell, along with productive mid-major scorers such as A’lahn Sumler. They’ve also added high-upside players from bigger programs looking for expanded roles.
DeCourcy believes the roster, at least in theory, is functional.
“They have done a nice job of building up a team that should not be overwhelmed physically,” DeCourcy said. “They should be skilled enough at important positions. Then we will see whether they can compete in the ACC. If you’re looking at this roster going into this year, it seems more promising than last year’s going into last year.”
But theory only goes so far.
“Pitt is in the position where we look at their roster, you can try to predict how they’re going to look together,” Michalowski said. “That combination of players is so new. It’s going to be really hard to spend this offseason nailing down who they’re going to be better than this year.”
That’s the gamble Pitt has made.
The Panthers have built a roster with experience, production and size — and addressed a long-standing need for scoring. On paper, the pieces make sense. But paper doesn’t win games.
The range of outcomes is wide. Pitt could be a cohesive, dangerous group that surprises in the ACC. Or it could struggle to find identity and consistency. Only time will tell.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.