For a stretch this spring, Pitt baseball looked like it might be on the verge of something it hasn’t done since 1995.
The Panthers were one of the hottest offenses in the country, scoring in bunches, winning series and pushing themselves into the conversation for a possible NCAA tournament two seed. At their peak, they looked like a team that didn’t just belong in the postseason picture — but one that might host its way into it.
Now, with roughly 20 games left, the conversation has shifted. The Panthers started out 14-4, but heading into Wednesday’s game they’ve gone 8-8 since. Pitt sits squarely on the NCAA bubble — viewed by some bracketologists as one of the last four teams in, by others among the last four out. The margin is razor thin and the timing of the slide couldn’t be worse.
Since the end of March, the season has tilted in the opposite direction. Pitt dropped a series to Wake Forest, including a game in which it surrendered 22 runs, then followed it with a series loss to California. What was once an explosive, confident group has instead been searching for answers in all three phases of the game.
The numbers reflect it. Through April 14, Pitt is averaging just five runs per game while allowing 10.6. For a program that has built its identity around offense, that imbalance has flipped the script.
“We just got punched in the mouth this weekend,” pitcher Drew Lafferty said after the Cal series. “We need to get better at attacking hitters, getting ahead in counts, instead of putting them in advantage counts where they can do damage.”
Read More
That “punch in the mouth” has become a recurring theme — not as panic, but as a reality check. The ACC schedule has arrived and it has not been forgiving.
Part of Pitt’s early success came during a softer nonconference slate, when the lineup looked unstoppable and the pitching staff was able to largely control games. But ACC play has exposed how quickly things can change when the level of competition rises.
That has shown up most clearly on the mound.
In conference play, Pitt owns a 9.22 ERA — one of the worst marks in the ACC, ahead of only Louisville, Stanford and Virginia Tech — as opposing lineups have consistently forced pitchers into high-stress situations. The Panthers have also recorded 104 strikeouts against 86 walks in ACC play, a margin that underscores ongoing command issues and extended innings for opposing offenses.
Defensively, the Panthers have been closer to the middle of the pack in the ACC. But they are still inconsistent, posting a .967 fielding percentage with 17 errors that have extended innings and added pressure on a staff already working in tougher counts.
It doesn’t help that the offense — long considered the team’s strength — has gone from carrying the group to trying to rediscover itself, averaging just 6.67 runs per game in ACC play.
“This league is just different,” Lafferty said. “There’s no off days. You’ve got to roll out your best every single day to get wins.”
Still, the statistical profile is not one of a lifeless team. Pitt remains top-10 nationally in scoring, averaging 9.6 runs per game on the season. Lorenzo Carrier continues to anchor the lineup, hitting .386 and ranking among the top 50 in the country.
But those season-long numbers mask the recent reality. In April, the offense has been far quieter and the pitching staff has been unable to stabilize games long enough for the bats to matter.
Senior shortstop Caden Dulin insists the identity hasn’t changed, even if the results have.
“I wouldn’t say anything really feels different,” Dulin said. “The ball’s just not going our way. We’re sticking with our approach… I don’t think we should be nervous or feeling bad about ourselves.”
That belief has been central to Pitt’s response. The messaging from within the program has not turned to panic or overhaul.
“We just have to get back to this word we used early on, which is relentless,” Dulin said. “We can come back from anything, even when we’re down runs. We just have to keep pushing forward.”
That word — relentless — is not just rhetoric for Pitt. It has been part of the team’s internal identity since the beginning of the season. The problem, by Dulin’s own admission, is that it has faded slightly during the downturn.
The challenge now is not rediscovering a new version of the team, but restoring the one that existed when things were working.
Coach Mike Bell has echoed that sentiment, emphasizing that the season is still defined more by response than results.
“It’s a marathon, not a sprint,” Bell said. “The goal is making sure we’re playing our best baseball where our feet are.”
That message matters now more than ever, because Pitt’s schedule offers little room for error. The Panthers close the regular season with four ranked opponents — No. 3 North Carolina, No. 8 Florida State, No. 9 Virginia and No. 15 West Virginia — along with key ACC series against Virginia Tech and Notre Dame.
It’s a postseason gauntlet before the postseason and there’s no time to ease into it.
The formula isn’t complicated. The Panthers feel they just need to clean up the details that have slipped during this stretch.
“The goal is to be playing your best baseball in May,” Bell said. “Because that sets you up for June.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.