When Pitt basketball asks fans to “trust us,” it’s a hard sell. Looking at the track record over the past few months — nevertheless going back further — makes it easy to see why skepticism runs high.

It began with a lot of people believing Jeff Capel should be fired. Athletic director Allen Greene bucked those naysayers and chose to retain him.

Add in the recent roster losses and the issue grows.

The Panthers have lost two starters, two of their top bench players and top freshman recruit Anthony Felesi decommitted. Roman Siulepa, arguably last year’s best player, has left town, too.

Advertise with us

On paper, it looks like a complete roster collapse. For fans, it’s nearly impossible to see the vision behind the moves, and the call for trust feels out of touch with reality.

When Greene announced Capel would return for a ninth season, he said, “Our focus turns to welcoming a highly regarded recruiting class, retaining key contributors and strategically using the transfer portal to add experience and balance.”

But looking at the facts, that hasn’t necessarily been the case.

  1. “Welcoming a highly regarded recruiting class” — Felesi is gone.
  2. “Retaining key contributors” — Siulepa, Omari Witherspoon and Brandin Cummings are gone.
  3. “Strategically using the transfer portal” — that part remains to be seen.

From the outside, it looks like everyone is leaving and the staff is asking fans to accept that everything is under control.

But departures aren’t always about coaching or loyalty. In the modern college basketball landscape, NIL deals and portal mobility give players a level of leverage that didn’t exist a decade ago.

Advertise with us

Some returning players in the portal are leaving for reasons that make sense within this context — timing, fit or opportunity — even if it frustrates fans.

The reality is that some returning players are asking for deals or incentives that the staff feels aren’t justified given the players’ previous track records or the team they’re trying to build. That may make their departures frustrating to watch, but it doesn’t mean the program is acting recklessly or blindly.

Take Felesi: He’s a talented player who could likely make a lot of money wherever he goes. Maybe in this “rebrand” that Jay Kuntz is working on, they decided it wasn’t worth the risk to spend a substantial amount of money on a player who is unproven at the college level.

That kind of decision is part of the complex planning teams now face in the modern era. It’s definitely an unpopular decision, and one that causes fans to have even less trust.

For those watching the portal, it can feel like the program isn’t targeting the top players. The names Pitt has been connected to aren’t exactly the most well-known guys. The staff is likely trying to avoid putting all their eggs in one basket, preferring to spread resources to build a balanced roster.

Advertise with us

Investing a large portion of the budget in a single player carries risk no matter the circumstances, and the staff must weigh potential impact against uncertainty.

The NIL era has fundamentally changed college basketball. Programs must weigh talent, cost, risk and roster balance all at once, and Pitt’s offseason reflects just how layered that process has become. Pitt isn’t trying to spend the most — it’s trying to spend smarter.

From the outside, though, those layers are hard to see. Fans are being asked to trust a vision that feels abstract, especially as familiar faces leave and tangible results remain uncertain.

Understanding the nuances doesn’t erase the pressure — it amplifies it. With so many moving parts and so little margin for error, the expectation to get this right has never been higher for both Capel and Greene.