Izzy Starck ended her freshman year at Penn State on top of the sport: a national champion, National Freshman of the Year and a season marked by excellence, guiding a team that lost just twice all year.
By January, she was the talk of college volleyball. By August, the weight of it all began to settle in. The hype around Penn State’s repeat chances was immediate, the roster stacked with returning stars from the championship team and high-level additions.
For Penn State, it looked unfair.
For Starck, it felt suffocating.
The matches began. She wasn’t playing like the freshman of the year — not by her standards or anyone else’s.
It was the pressure cooker — the expectations from herself, the team and the sport that had made her a star — that prompted Starck to make a decision few athletes do. She stepped away from Penn State to focus on her mental health and used the time to rebuild her mindset, train on her own and reassess how she wanted to approach the game.
Read More
That pause ultimately led her to a new chapter at Pitt, a program with elite talent and high expectations but also a culture that matched the clarity and perspective she had gained.
“You put on so many high expectations for yourself,” Starck said. “You want to get every possible expectation and reach it. You get to a point where you need to think realistically. You need to think how much you can handle. And I'm only 19, and sometimes when you put that much pressure on yourself and you’ve never experienced that in an environment playing before, it’s hard.”
For a setter, expectations don’t exist in isolation. Every rally runs through her hands — every hitter’s rhythm, every offensive adjustment and every in-match reset begins with her. As a freshman, Starck had been the spark; as a sophomore, she was expected to be the stabilizer.
That shift was subtle but significant. By the start of the 2025 season, the pressure was no longer just about wins — it was about who she was supposed to be on the court. Starck realized she was chasing the version of herself from December: the fearless freshman playing with nothing to lose, instead of allowing herself to grow into something new.
Stepping away wasn’t an escape from the sport. It was a deliberate pause to separate her love of volleyball from the weight of expectation.
“It's definitely a tough decision to make,” Starck said. “Listening to myself and knowing this is what is best for me and what I need in this moment, it was the best thing. I'm the happiest I've been, I'm loving the sport, and it's just really great.”
Pausing didn’t mean she was stepping away completely.
During her time off, Starck focused on both the physical and mental aspects of training. She would hit the gym to lift and condition solo. Her father, Doug, himself a former collegiate volleyball player, came in to help with the actual volleyball skills.
She went to therapy and began reassessing her relationship with volleyball — unpacking how she approached competition, how she handled different forms of pressure and how her own mindset shaped her experience.
“I have such a better mentality for myself,” Starck said. “I give myself so much more mental grace. I see everything I feel like in a different way. Now it's like, when I'm playing, I'm not putting so much pressure on myself, setting such a high expectation. There's good pressure to give yourself because it allows you to push yourself and practice every day, but not so much where it's affecting your play and you're putting that much pressure.”
Eventually, that healing journey led her to Pitt.
One of the most sought-after setters in the portal, Starck had options. Programs across the country were looking for a player who had already proven she could run a championship offense.
SMU was searching for a setter. Texas A&M, the reigning national champion, made sense on paper. Pitt was firmly in the mix.
What sealed the deal for Starck was the team’s culture — a mix of competitiveness, discipline and genuine camaraderie that made it clear Pitt was a place where she could grow both on and off the court.
“The way they form their players, not just as players on the court, but also as people, that's what I was looking for,” Starck said. “They want the best for our school, sports, our life, everything. Even on Day 1, stepping in here, I knew that everyone wants to be here and everybody wants the same thing.”
Adjusting to a new city and a new program brought a different kind of transition. After growing up in Florida and spending much of her life in smaller towns, Starck had to acclimate not just to a new team, but to Pittsburgh’s pace and climate.
The winter hit harder than she expected, especially after arriving during a relatively mild stretch. What initially felt manageable quickly turned into a crash course in Western Pennsylvania winters . Beyond the weather, there was the rhythm of city living — learning Pittsburgh’s tight streets, unpredictable parking and neighborhood flow became part of her daily routine.
In just a short time, she found her spots — her go-to coffee stop, the roads to avoid and the shortcuts that make the city feel smaller. The adjustment wasn’t seamless, but it became part of the process of building comfort in a new place.
On the court, the transition has been much smoother, thanks in large part to her teammates.
Fellow setter Haiti Tautua’a has been a constant guide.
“Titi knows everything about the fundamentals and the setting position, the footwork and everything,” Starck said. “So if I just don't know, I just get to look at her and I don't ever have to question it.”
Having played with Olivia Babcock and Blaire Bayless on Team USA before coming to Pitt also helped.
Playing with Babcock has been a new and exciting chapter for Starck. Babcock was the National Freshman of the Year in 2023 — a year before Starck — and went on to win back-to-back National Player of the Year honors in 2024 and 2025.
The two faced each other once as opponents, but now they’re building chemistry on the same side of the net.
“It's so fun,” Starck said. “We have such a good, open line of communication. It's like we never have to wonder what each other's thinking. She's such an adaptive hitter, and even if I have a bad set, she's getting there and she's still having a perfect swing. It's just so cool to see how good of a hitter she is, but also, just an all-around volleyball player.”
Coming to Pitt never meant escaping expectations. If anything, the spotlight burns just as bright. The Panthers have reached five straight Final Fours and are still chasing the program’s first national championship. The standard isn’t participation — it’s winning in December.
Starck understood that before she ever stepped on campus.
There would be eyes on her return. Questions about how she would respond. Assumptions about what she could bring to a team already on the brink. The pressure to contend for a title wouldn’t disappear simply because the jersey changed.
The difference this time isn’t the expectation. It’s her relationship with it.
“Every team that I would ever be on has that pressure and has the same expectation of winning a national championship, and me as a player, wanting to be the best at my position,” Starck said. “The pressure doesn't change at all as it did at Penn State, but I think I have a new mindset and way of looking at it, where I'm able to handle and deal with it better and look at it through a new lens.
“I’ve learned to give myself mental grace, to push myself in ways that help me improve but don’t overwhelm me. I can relax and have more fun while playing, and that makes me a better teammate, too.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.