In the summer of 2023, I crafted an extensive profile on then-Pitt athletic director Heather Lyke. At that time, she could do no wrong.

The football program was humming, having won 20 combined games over the past two seasons. Men’s basketball had not only just returned to the NCAA tournament, but gave fans a legitimate reason to believe better things were to come.

The volleyball program had successfully captured the city’s attention, while other Olympic sports teams, such as men’s and women’s soccer, were coming off deep runs in their respective national tournaments.

This success made Lyke a star. She was viewed as one of the country’s best athletic directors, one who aimed to make each of her university’s athletic teams a national contender. A large chunk of the Pitt fanbase worried she would soon leave for another job at a higher-profile school.

Advertise with us

Instead, Lyke was fired in September 2024. And she left quite the mess behind.

Today, Pitt’s athletic department is in shambles. The football team is losing some of its top players in the transfer portal. The men’s basketball team is unwatchable. The women’s team is equally bad and is allegedly an even a bigger issue off the court. And some non-revenue sports might not be around much longer.

Lyke’s replacement, Allen Greene, is now responsible for fixing these problems. Over the next year, he will be the one forced to make a series of tough decisions, ones that will, at least temporarily, make him an unpopular man in Oakland.

2026 will undoubtedly be a challenging year for Pitt’s athletic department. And they indeed have Lyke to thank.

What went wrong

Lyke had a noted desire for “comprehensive excellence,” treating every Pitt athletic team with equal importance. While in theory this was a fair stance, in reality, that’s simply not how the world of college athletics works.

Advertise with us

Two sports matter above all else: football and men’s basketball. If those two programs do well, there is more money for all. Lyke’s inability to appropriately allocate resources toward what actually mattered has brought Pitt to where it is now.

Her most notable misstep was the Victory Heights initiative, an ambitious multi-sport facility that would serve as a replacement to the aging Fitzgerald Field House.

“For far too long, a significant percentage of our student-athletes have been forced to compete in facilities that do not reflect the lofty standards and aspirations of the University of Pittsburgh,” Lyke said in a university issued press release in 2023. “Today’s announcement is the first step in transforming that liability into a game-changing asset in our quest for comprehensive excellence.”

Lyke’s heart was in the right place. She wasn’t wrong to believe Pitt’s current athletic facility for those sports was outdated. But she ignored one key component that makes or breaks every major decision made in today’s world of college athletics: money.

Lyke signed up for a $240 million project with little to no funding secured beforehand. She hoped her big swing would inspire alumni to donate more. It did not. And to make things worse, that facility, whenever it is finished, will add no legitimate revenue moving forward.

Advertise with us

Lyke also wasted money on her numerous coaching hires and firings. She gained notoriety in town for canning nine head coaches in her first two years in Oakland. Some coaches were dismissed with remaining years on their contract, meaning Pitt was paying two head-coach salaries for one non-revenue sport — again, meaning that the additional money spent wasn’t ever going to be recuperated.

Her final major sin pertains to NIL, the biggest determining factor of success in today’s college sports. Some athletic directors immediately embraced the concept when it was legalized in 2021. Lyke, instead, pushed back.

When seeking donation money from alumni, the Victory Heights project or other athletic facility upgrades took priority over laying the foundation of a productive and competitive NIL collective. Rather than learning innovative ways for Pitt to compete in the NIL space, Lyke was known to speak against the concept as a whole, at times even encouraging other ACC athletic directors to do the same, per multiple sources.

Even when things seemed great during Lyke’s tenure, time would eventually prove those days to be nothing more than a house of cards. Pitt athletics fell way behind the times under her leadership, and by the time the university acted, it was already too late.

Cleaning up

Last month, Greene announced that Pitt will be tarping off the upper deck stands along both sidelines for its home football games at Acrisure Stadium. The goal is to not only create a more lively atmosphere on Saturdays, but also create a higher demand for Pitt football tickets — something that has never truly existed, save for rivalry matchups against Penn State, West Virginia and Notre Dame.

Advertise with us

“Today’s announcement is just the first step in showing we’re committed to being both creative and bold in pursuing every opportunity that strengthens our program,” Greene said.

That move was mostly applauded throughout the city. But Greene shouldn’t expect a similar reception toward future decisions he has to make.

Football and men’s basketball have to improve. That doesn’t happen without better players. Per an ACC source, a competitive NIL budget starts at around $30 million; $20 million for football and $10 million for men’s basketball. Pitt, per numerous conversations, isn’t there now but could be in the near future.

Every choice must be approached with money — and money only — in mind. If it doesn’t directly create more NIL opportunities for those two programs, it’s probably something that shouldn’t happen.

Soon, Greene must decide the future of his men’s and women’s basketball programs. Both head coaches deserve to be fired. But such moves cost money — money that Pitt athletics doesn’t have the luxury of wasting.

Advertise with us

Jeff Capel’s teams have flopped after getting a minor taste of success in 2023, the lone NCAA tournament appearance he has delivered in eight years. But a hefty buyout might give Capel a ninth year in Oakland. Losing is only part of the problem for Tory Verdi, who has been accused of creating an abusive culture around his team. If he can’t be fired due to cause, he also might be back next winter.

Saving money with coach retention is only one unpopular move on the table. Pitt must also consider if it’s worth maintaining funding levels for certain non-revenue sports, or if it’s worth keeping certain programs at all. Such a move would relinquish opportunities for dozens of Pitt student-athletes, all in the name of better NIL for revenue sports. But better days for all don’t exist without better results on the gridiron and hardwood.

Still early into his tenure with Pitt, the most overwhelming criticism surrounding Greene is visibility. At a time when the sky is seemingly falling, he is rarely in the spotlight. But perhaps, at least for now, that’s Greene’s smartest play.

For the foreseeable future, Greene will have to be the bad guy. He’s going to have to make a series of unpopular choices, ones that upset many individuals he’s paid to represent and support. He’s not the reason for these problems, and it remains to be seen if he’s capable of resolving them.

Allen Greene has quite a mess to clean up in 2026, and he has Heather Lyke to thank.