For the first 10 minutes Saturday afternoon, Pitt looked capable of trading punches with one of the ACC’s more explosive offenses. The Panthers defended, rebounded and controlled tempo against SMU, which entered the day averaging a league-best 86.4 points per game.

What followed, however, was a reminder of how thin the margin is for the Panthers. SMU eventually found its rhythm, Pitt’s offense unraveled, and the Mustangs turned a tight first half into an 86-67 win that underscored how quickly things can slip away for a team still searching for consistency.

Here are three takeaways from the loss:

Pitt’s early defense was real and effective

Pitt’s defensive effort early was exactly what it needed to be against a high-powered SMU offense. The Panthers forced tough looks, limited clean perimeter shots and controlled the glass in a way that kept the Mustangs uncomfortable for much of the first half.

Advertise with us

That tone was set just under seven minutes into the game when Kieran Mullen denied Jaden Toombs at the rim, then Nojus Indrusaitis cashed in a second-chance 3-pointer on the other end. On the next possession, Mullen converted another offensive rebound into points off a feed from Omari Witherspoon forcing an early SMU timeout.

“I feel like we moved the ball well,” Indrusaitis said. “We got in transition and we just played well off each other. Miss or make, we just kept finding each other. I feel like we just played harder.”

The Mustangs didn’t hit their first 3-pointer until the 9:46 mark of the first half and went nearly three full minutes — from 14:26 to 11:36 — without a field goal. SMU started the game just 2 of 13 from the floor, and the Panthers out-rebounded the Mustangs, 20-17, in the opening half, including 12 defensive boards.

That defensive work mattered. SMU, which averages 43.2 points per half, was held to 34 points at the break and led by just two, 34-32. Pitt also limited two of SMU’s top scorers early: BJ Edwards, who averages 13.6 points per game, scored just three points in the first half, while Corey Washington (11.1 ppg) was held scoreless.

For a stretch, the Panthers looked organized, connected and capable of dictating how the game would be played. Against an offense like SMU’s, that’s no small feat.

Advertise with us

“We were getting back in transition,” coach Jeff Capel said. “Individual, one-on-one defense was pretty good. They missed some shots. We were doing a pretty good job of rebounding — defensive rebounding — so not giving them second-chance points.”

The problem is that kind of defensive precision is hard to maintain, and Pitt couldn’t sustain it once the game sped up.

The second half flipped everything

Any hope the Panthers had of building off their first-half defense evaporated almost immediately after halftime.

SMU opened the second half on a 7-0 run, prompting Capel to call timeout before the two-minute mark — a signal that things were already sliding. The Mustangs added two more baskets before Pitt finally got on the board at the 16:35 mark on a Cam Corhen dunk, and by then SMU had pushed its lead to double digits.

The sequence that followed summed up the Panthers’ afternoon. On one possession, Corhen missed a 3-pointer, Mullen grabbed the offensive rebound, Barry Dunning Jr. missed a 3, grabbed his own miss, then Corhen missed a dunk at the rim. SMU grabbed the rebound, and while it didn’t score immediately, another Pitt miss allowed Jaron Pierre Jr. to drive down the lane and score, pushing the lead to 57-43 with 12:35 remaining.

Advertise with us

There was still time on the clock, but at that point, the game felt out of control.

“They went on that [9-0] run to start the half, and we could never really recover from that,” Capel said. “At one point, we got it back to 12, forced them to call a time out right around the eight-minute mark, and from there, we couldn't get stops and we couldn't make shots. So obviously frustrating for us.”

SMU shot 19 of 27 from the field and 6 of 10 from 3-point range in the second half, carving up a Panthers defense that couldn’t recover once the Mustangs found their spacing and tempo. Pitt, meanwhile, went just 12 of 33 from the floor and 3 of 15 from beyond the arc after halftime.

The Mustangs finished the half with 52 points and shot nearly 70% over the final three quarters of the game, turning a competitive contest into a lopsided result.

A narrow path forward

Saturday’s loss dropped the Panthers to 9-15 overall and 2-9 in ACC play, and the bigger picture is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.

Advertise with us

The Panthers are edging closer to one of the worst full-season records of Capel’s tenure. Pitt finished 10-12 during the COVID-shortened 2020-21 season and went 11-21 in 2021-22. With seven games remaining, the path to avoiding those marks is narrow.

Those final seven include Duke at home and a trip to North Carolina, along with matchups against Notre Dame, Stanford, Cal, Florida State and Syracuse. According to KenPom, the Panthers are favored in just two of those games — Notre Dame and Florida State — and neither is guaranteed.

Pitt is mathematically alive in the ACC tournament race, but the path forward requires near perfection and help elsewhere in the league. Performances like Saturday’s leave little room for optimism unless consistency arrives quickly.

The defensive blueprint the Panthers showed early against SMU is something it can build on. Whether it can sustain it — and pair it with enough offense — will determine how this season ends.