The vast majority of Pitt’s 2025 roster, with two NFL draft opt-outs and a handful of backups who hit the transfer portal as the only exceptions, made the trip to Annapolis, Md., for the Military Bowl. But few of them showed up with any designs of actually winning the game.

“Not happy with the performance,” coach Pat Narduzzi said. “Give East Carolina credit. Good football team. They did a nice job on defense. But we just had too many missed opportunities.”

The Panthers, given every advantage in continuity against East Carolina, capped their latest campaign with a mess of a loss. Bowl games matter only so much. They are, at the end of the day, exhibitions between makeshift lineups after long layoffs in underwhelming environments without much at stake. But Pitt ended the 2025 season with a whimper.

It was a disorganized and disinterested effort against a team which was significantly more undermanned. It featured five turnovers, two more giveaways on downs, 10 offensive points scored and another loss to a Group of Five opponent. It is a sour way to end a year in which the Panthers built toward something bigger.

Advertise with us

“Just disappointing. We had more yards, but you’ve got to put the ball in the end zone,” Narduzzi said. “You turn the ball over five times and two times on downs, that’s seven if you count turnovers on downs, hard to win a football game against any opponent, period.”

Each of Pitt’s five losses revealed flaws specific to this team. In defeats to West Virginia and Louisville, quarterback play was lacking. Against Notre Dame and Miami, the line play was not up to snuff. And in losing to East Carolina, it was apparent Pitt had neither overwhelming talent nor the level of discipline to compensate for it.

Especially after finding a solution to that first problem, the Panthers were a good team this season but nothing more. They, for the large part, took care of business and beat the teams they were better than, but that only gets you so far.

Of Pitt’s 12 FBS opponents played this season, five finished with nine wins or more, and Pitt beat one of them. Against everyone else, the Panthers went 6-1.

Eight wins, including an upset or two, is nothing to scoff at, but the next step for this program is on the other side of great. And to get there, it needs to grow up. The Panthers need to improve their talent in some areas, but they also need some of the talented-but-green teenagers leading them and growing into sharper college football players.

Advertise with us

Mason Heintschel needs to be smarter with the football. Ja’Kyrian Turner must hold on to the football. And Shawn Lee Jr. can’t miss tackles that allow explosive plays.

“Mason’s still a young quarterback. He’s a freshman,” Narduzzi said. “But when you put the ball on the ground — 376 yards is not awful. But it’s just turnovers.”

“We don’t make a tackle and leverage the football,” he added later of Lee. “You’ve got a freshman corner on the field who’s got to leverage and set that back outside of him.”

There will be transfer exits and additions that change the nature of the roster, but much of this program’s core — from Heintschel, Lee and Turner to Ryan Carretta, Cruce Brookins and others — was either in the first year starting or out of college football altogether. So there is room to grow, but the Panthers were in a similar position coming out of the 2024 season and had to reinvent themselves after two bad, avoidable losses early in the season.

They recovered and got their heads above water by season’s end, but the year finished in drowning — with three losses in four games and all of them coming with varying degrees of embarrassment.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, on the other sideline Saturday was a team desperate to prove it was more than the big names you might have heard who departed. The victory second-year coach Blake Harrell and his team earned on Saturday was the result of buy-in to the highest degree from the players and coaches who stayed. The difference between East Carolina’s postgame celebration and Pitt’s frustration was striking.

You don’t want to put too much stock into a disastrous postseason showing. But Pitt’s comedy of errors in the Military Bowl and its 2-6 record in bowl games under Narduzzi is a black eye on the program. Next season — again — is a chance to demonstrate the kind of consistency the program needs to move forward.