Their team didn’t quite let up 100 points, but as the clock ran out at Acrisure Stadium, it hardly mattered to the Pitt fans brave enough to stay for the entire game. Their coach opened the week by saying this game, in the grand scheme of things, was irrelevant. They better hope Pat Narduzzi was right.

No. 22 Pitt (7-3, 5-1 ACC) was defeated soundly by No. 9 Notre Dame 37-15 in a performance not befitting the stage it was given. The boundless energy generated on Pittsburgh’s North Shore by a visit from ESPN’s “College GameDay” and a capacity crowd was quickly marred as spectators realized these Panthers were not up to the task at hand.

“I apologize to the fans. It was a great showing. It was a heck of a day, at least to start, for our Pitt fans, for the University of Pittsburgh, for this city of Pittsburgh. I appreciate everything they did,” Narduzzi said. “I wish I could have given them more.”

Here are three takeaways from a deflating loss in a big moment:

Advertise with us

No luck against the Irish

Notre Dame continues to be a program whose resources and talent overwhelms Pitt’s. There is a lot of history to this series of 74 games, which dates back to 1909, but it is filled with misery for the Panthers. The recent history illustrates how big the gap between these two programs is. In five games against the Fighting Irish since taking over as coach, Narduzzi has five losses and his teams have been outscored 201-71.

The offense in particular, which has scored six touchdowns in the last five games against Notre Dame, has proven unable to compete, even as quarterbacks, coordinators and other personnel are churned through. A Pitt starting quarterback has not thrown a touchdown pass against the Fighting Irish defense since Nathan Peterman in 2015.

The Fighting Irish’s power on both lines was more than the Panthers could handle. For all the depth Pitt built up front during the past offseason, which had served it well to this point, it did not materialize when needed most.

Pitt fell into a 14-0 hole before the midway point of the first quarter. Jeremiyah Love raced for a 56-yard touchdown run to break the ice, and Tae Johnson made it 14-0 with a pick-six off Mason Heintschel on the very next play from scrimmage.

With a two-score lead, Notre Dame was able to exercise its physical advantages. They leaned on an overpowering run game and showed no fear bringing pressure against Heintschel over the final 45 minutes of the game. Pitt averaged 0.6 yards per carry on 11 attempts and gained only 74 yards on 21 pass attempts in the first half. In the second half, Notre Dame rushed for only 3.8 yards per carry, but it was enough to help them burn clock on three drives of four minutes or more.

Advertise with us

The Panthers were, in fact, the more disciplined team on Saturday. Notre Dame committed eight penalties, which cost them 81 yards, compared to five penalties for 41 yards called against Pitt. The Panthers didn’t beat themselves like they did in their first two losses, but take the penalty differential with the final scoring (minus-22) and yardage differentials (minus-166), and it only illustrates the gap in talent that currently exists.

Good teams beat bad teams, and Pitt did that during its five-game winning streak but no longer. Great teams beat good teams, and Notre Dame did that. The Panthers will have two more opportunities to beat good teams, with Georgia Tech and Miami following over the next two weeks, but this performance doesn’t inspire much confidence they stack up with like competition or better.

Defense gets no help again

Pitt’s defense, with some reinforcements arriving in the form of Rasheem Biles and Jaeden Moore, could only keep a lid on Notre Dame and its talented group of playmakers for so long.

Superstar tailback Love was held in check for most of the game. He gained 147 yards on 23 carries, but the 56-yard touchdown run did most of the heavy lifting for his impressive stat line. CJ Carr, who had been accurate and poised for most of his debut season as a starter, showed some of his inexperience when throwing two interceptions, including a pick-six, and passing for 6.6 yards per attempt. When the game was still in doubt, Pitt’s defense gave the team every opportunity to cut into Notre Dame’s multi-score advantage.

On the first drive of the game, the defense held Notre Dame out of the end zone and forced a missed field goal. Kavir Bains-Marquez, a revelation at safety since transferring from FCS UC Davis, picked off Carr to halt another drive around midfield and set the offense up inside the opposing 10-yard line in the return. And even after Pitt cashed in that turnover for only three points, Javon McIntyre’s fourth-down pass defense held the Fighting Irish scoreless despite driving to Pitt’s 1-yard line.

Advertise with us

And early in the third quarter, Biles leapt to make an athletic interception off Carr and returned it 10 yards for a touchdown to give Pitt some life at 28-9, only for Heintschel’s two-point pass to be picked off by Adon Shuler and returned 100 yards to make it a three-touchdown deficit once again.

One astounding statistic tells the story: Notre Dame started 6 of 11 drives at its own 40-yard line or better, and four of those six drives ended in points. And from that basket, the only two that did not yield points for the Fighting Irish were the two that started in Pitt territory.

“We definitely got dominated by field position,” Narduzzi said. “We can't do that to ourselves.”

In disappointingly similar fashion to its September losses at West Virginia and to Louisville, the Pitt offense was incapable of playing complementary football.

What to make of Mason?

There’s no getting around it — 15 for 31, 118 yards, an interception (plus one more on a two-point try that doesn't count in the box score) and zero touchdowns will never be enough against an opponent the caliber of which Pitt played this weekend.

Advertise with us

But Heintschel’s struggles — of which there were many — belong to the offense as a whole. It’s difficult to accurately judge Pitt’s young signal caller given how poorly the supporting cast played around him. The offensive line was not up to the task, allowing its quarterback to get hit nine times and suffer four sacks through less than four full quarters.

“Obviously they put a lot of pressure on our quarterback, so we didn't play good enough,” Narduzzi said.

Pass catchers were credited with only one drop in 38 targets, but the eye test says they should have been charged with more.

“You've got to make those big-time plays in the game,” Narduzzi said. “Our skill guys, they've done a great job all year, so I'm not going to complain. Big-time players make big-time plays in big-time games, and that's what we have to do.”

Heintschel deserves his share of the blame for this loss. He has yet to face a defense this good in front of a crowd this big. It was a pressure-packed moment that Heintschel wasn’t yet ready for. That doesn’t mean he never will be, but while he grows into his obvious talent, Pitt will need more from the players around him to beat like or better competition.

Advertise with us

Bonus takeaway: ACC race update

Pitt's disappointing loss didn't change the Panthers' hopes for a spot in the ACC championship game, but their path did become clearer after Virginia defeated Duke.

The Panthers (5-1 ACC) are one of four teams with one loss in conference play — Georgia Tech (6-1), Virginia (6-1) and SMU (5-1) are the others — and they'll need to win out plus get a little bit of help to end up as one of the last two standing. The Panthers can remove the Yellow Jackets from the quartet of one-loss teams with a win against Georgia Tech on Saturday in Atlanta. If they then defeat Miami on Nov. 29 at Acrisure Stadium, they'll finish 7-1 in ACC play.

But because they lose a three-way tiebreaker with Virginia and SMU, they'll need a Cavaliers or Mustangs loss down the stretch to get into the title game as a 7-1 team. At 7-1, Virginia and SMU would win the tiebreaker because of a better record against common opponents, with Pitt's 34-27 loss to Louisville in September the deciding factor.

SMU hosts Louisville and travels to California the next two weeks. Virginia has game one left, hosting Virginia Tech in two weeks.

In short: Two wins for Pitt plus one loss by Virginia or SMU gets it done.

Advertise with us

The ACC championship game is Dec. 6 at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, N.C.

Projection sites are giving the Panthers less than a 20% chance to get there, but stranger things have happened.

— Sports editor Daniel Mann contributed to this report.