Pitt head coach Pat Narduzzi has done his best to downplay the hype surrounding his team’s next contest. But he, along with anyone else paying attention, knows Saturday will be anything but a normal afternoon on the North Shore.
All eyes will be on Narduzzi’s No. 23-ranked Panthers this weekend as they play host to No. 9 Notre Dame. The matchup is so enticing that ESPN’s “College GameDay” will host its show live from the Steel City prior to the noon scheduled kickoff.
There is plenty of buzz surrounding the Pitt football program, which has won five straight since freshman phenom Mason Heintschel took over at quarterback. Still boasting only one loss in ACC play, the Panthers have a realistic path to the conference championship game, which of course grants the winner an automatic berth into this year’s playoff.
But before any of that can happen, the Panthers must first face the Fighting Irish, who enter Saturday on a seven-game win streak of their own. The showdown won’t help or hurt Pitt’s spot in the ACC standings, but those who suggest nothing is on the line Saturday afternoon are mistaken.
A quick glance through the history books can explain how a victory over Notre Dame could potentially elevate a program. And a living example will be in attendance this weekend, hoping to see the same results replicated.
Saturday marks the 50-year anniversary of perhaps the most significant individual performance in Pitt football history.
Read More
On Nov. 15, 1975, Tony Dorsett rushed for 303 yards and scored a pair of touchdowns to lead the Panthers to a 34-20 victory over the Irish. The effort brought national credibility to both Dorsett and Pitt and set the table for a 1976 campaign which produced the program's only Heisman Trophy and most recent national championship.
“You have to remember that there was no ESPN, no 24-hour sports channels, social media, etc.,” Dorsett explained during a recent email interview with the Post-Gazette. “You basically had a few games you could watch on Saturdays, and Notre Dame was on just about every week. I was named an All-American the previous year, so I had eyes on me, but the win put the entire program in the spotlight.”
The Post-Gazette caught up with Dorsett, along with a handful of individuals who were around for that cold afternoon in Oakland, to gain a better look at the performance that forever changed Pitt football:
Touchdown Tony Dorsett ⭐
— Pitt Football (@Pitt_FB) March 24, 2020
Enjoy these highlights of Dorsett torching Notre Dame in 1975.#H2P pic.twitter.com/qg9SYyMZTe
The build up
The story of Dorsett’s historic effort begins a few years prior. Following a 1-10 showing in 1972, Johnny Majors was the man Pitt’s athletic department selected to turn the program around. He arrived with plenty of new faces, bringing a group of 99 freshmen and junior college transfers into his first training camp.
Majors’ first year signified a tremendous improvement. The Panthers finished 6-5-1 and earned a bid to the Fiesta Bowl, their first bowl game since 1955. Their team was led by Dorsett, who in his first collegiate season rushed for 1,586 yards. Dorsett earned All-America honors, the first freshman to do so in 29 years.
“Nothing surprised me with Tony,” said former Pitt offensive lineman and coach Dave Wannstedt, who was a graduate assistant coach on Pitt’s 1975 team. “When I was a junior, I think our leading back was probably about a 400-yard rusher. Tony came in as a freshman and had his second-best college season, he ran for 1,586 yards. I did not block anybody any better than the year prior, when our lead back ran for 400 yards. So, my point is that it was all Tony.”
Pitt was even better in 1974, finishing 7-4 overall. Dorsett again earned All-America honors, and the Panthers’ expectations continued to elevate. Heading into 1975, their goal wasn’t just to compete, but to establish themselves as a legitimate part of the national conversation.
“You could look ahead and see that they were building something,” Pitt historian Sam Sciullo said.
The next step in the building process was for Pitt to show it could beat the best. It squandered its first chance to do so in the 1975 season via a 46-10 loss to No. 1 Oklahoma, a team that went on to win that year’s national title. But other opportunities awaited down the road. Slated to conclude their home schedule that season was a battle against No. 9 Notre Dame.
The Fighting Irish had long been a thorn in Pitt’s side. The Panthers hadn’t bested Notre Dame since 1963. From 1965 through 1973, the Irish won each matchup by at least 20 points.
“They were a statement football team,” said John Pelusi Sr., the starting center for 1975 Panthers. “If you could go out and beat them, then you had arrived.”
“If we were going to be a good team and take a step forward, we had to beat Notre Dame,” added Wannstedt.
Pitt entered that year’s contest against Notre Dame with perhaps some extra aggression. It was coming off a heartbreaking 17-14 road loss to West Virginia. Bill McKenzie kicked a game-winning 38-yard FG as time expired.
That aggression was channeled toward toppling an Irish squad they had nearly beat in South Bend the year prior. Notre Dame was no slouch of an opponent, especially on the defensive side. Headlined by consensus All-American Steve Niehaus, the Irish were allowing just 11 points per game.
On November 15, 1975, Pitt’s Tony Dorsett rushed for an amazing 303 yards and 3 TDs in those classic end zones as @Pitt_FB defeated Notre Dame 34-20 at Pitt Stadium. Exactly 50 years later these two teams will meet again in Pittsburgh in a massive game. #LetsGoPitt #H2P pic.twitter.com/OsUk5KnpO0
— Pittsburgh Hall of Fame and Sports Museum™ (@PittsburghHOF) November 9, 2025
“He was one of the largest human beings I’d ever seen,” Pelusi recalled. “The guy’s face was hanging out of his facemask. He was just enormous.”
Pitt, however, wasn’t intimidated.
As the week progressed, Pitt felt confident in its game plan. The Panthers aimed to overcome Notre Dame’s size with their speed, both up front and in the backfield.
“I don’t know if I was ever better prepared to do anything in my life than I was to play football at Pitt,” said Tom Brzoza, who started at right guard for the Panthers that season.
That week of practice was all business for Majors’ squad — until the final day.
Friday morning, Pitt’s coaching staff wanted to ensure the team would enter the next day loose and ready to play. To lighten the mood, defensive coordinator and assistant head coach Jackie Sherrill arrived dressed as the Notre Dame mascot, donning a leprechaun costume as the team warmed up.
Sherrill’s antics still provide a laugh to those who were a part of the 1975 Panthers. That silliness hit home because in the end, they knew they were ready. And they knew they had the right guy to lead their charge.
Game day
On paper, Notre Dame was the better team. But the Panthers had something the Irish didn’t.
They had Dorsett.
Entering that week, Dorsett, already a two-time All-American, had logged 1,116 yards on the ground at an average of 6.3 yards per carry. Notre Dame was more than familiar with his excellence, too.
As a freshman, Dorsett rushed for a record 209 yards against the Irish, an effort fueled by insult during his recruitment process.
“Tony certainly loved to play Notre Dame,” Sherrill said. “When we recruited Tony, there were a lot of people that claimed he was ‘too small,’ and legitimately so — he only weighed about 155 pounds soaking wet. But, you know, speed makes you a lot bigger and a lot stronger. That’s one thing that Tony had was speed.”
Notre Dame silenced Dorsett the next year, holding him to only 61 yards rushing along with forcing him to fumble near the end zone. That costly mistake motivated Dorsett for redemption in 1975.
November 15, 1975 was a perfect day for football. The 56,480 people in attendance at Pitt Stadium likely remember the sun shining bright despite the chilling temperatures. The skies were blue, the wind was minimal, and Dorsett was poised to deliver a show.
“Their opinion was that I was too small to be a big-time college running back,” Dorsett said. “They were looking at my size but not my heart or passion. I wanted to make them regret that decision, and I think I may have been successful.”
His big afternoon started just four plays into the contest, when he took an inside handoff from quarterback Matt Cavanaugh, broke a tackle at the line of scrimmage, bounced outside to his right and scurried down the sideline for a 57-yard rush that set up the Panthers’ first touchdown.
“I’ve never rode a motorcycle, but you watch guys push down that clutch. That's what he had,” said Rick Gradisek, Pitt’s equipment manager that season. “He had that extra gear.”
“I remember watching Tony take off,” Sherill added. “His hamstring looked like it exploded. I thought he blew it out. But his muscles were just that strong. He put on a show that day running the football.”
And Dorsett was just getting started.
On Pitt’s next possession, after falling behind 10-7, he put his team back ahead for good with a 71-yard touchdown rush. Cavanaugh started the play with a perfect option read, faking an inside handoff to fullback Elliott Walker before delivering a crisp pitch to his All-American tailback, who turned the corner, slipped a tackle and shot like a bullet along the Panthers’ sideline for his longest run of the afternoon.
“When you have Tony in the backfield, you block with a lot of confidence,” Brzoza said. “All he needed was a crack.”
Dorsett’s second touchdown of the game came in the second quarter. With just under four minutes left in the first half, Cavanaugh found Dorsett on a screen pass in the middle of the field. Dorsett caught the ball, turned up field and dashed 49-yards, untouched, into the end zone.
That score gave the Panthers a 24-13 advantage heading into the break. Dorsett celebrated by tossing the ball into the stands, resulting in a 15-yard penalty, perhaps his only mistake of the day. He had tallied 227 total yards of offense in the first half alone. By then, people began to realize something special — even for Dorsett’s high standards — was in the works.
“I think it was early in the second half that it began to dawn on me,” longtime Pitt football announcer Bill Hillgrove said. “Because at that point, Johnny Sauer is next to me, keeping track of his yardage. This was before stat monitors and everything else. I saw the numbers and just thought, ‘Wow!’”
“When he got up over that 250 mark, we started to have the conversation, both coaches and players,” Wannstedt recalled. “‘Is he gonna make 300? Can he really do this?’”
Those on the field, however, remained focused on the task at hand.
“I remember thinking, ‘We can’t let them come back,’” Brzoza said. “Our defense played great. But no matter how well we were doing, we felt we couldn’t score enough points. We wanted that win really bad.”
Despite Notre Dame giving everything it could to rally back into the contest, the Panthers grinded out the victory. Dorsett’s consistent production out of the backfield helped burn second after second off the clock.
In the game’s final minute, Dorsett gained 9 yards on a sweep to the left, bringing his rushing total to 303 — a number that surpassed both Pitt’s single-game rushing record and the highest total any player had compiled against the Irish. Both marks were previously held by Dorsett.
The Panthers finished the game with 505 yards of total offense, 374 of that coming from Dorsett, who also caught three passes for 71 yards. He scored twice, once on the ground and once through the air. He also set up Pitt’s other two touchdowns that day, a pair of short runs from Cavanaugh.
“Tony’s performance was the most outstanding I’ve ever seen in a game,” Majors said after the game. “He was superb. In fact, ‘superb’ is not an adequate adjective.”
“I’ve never seen a better performance than Dorsett’s,” Notre Dame coach Dan Devine added from the opposing locker room. “I may have seen as good, but I don’t know where.”
The performance remained Pitt’s highest single-game rushing total until 2022, when Israel Abanikanda tallied 320 yards against Virginia Tech. It still remains the highest single-game rushing total any player has compiled against Notre Dame.
The aftermath
Hillgrove’s clearest memory from Dorsett’s effort occurred after the game had ended. Notre Dame athletic director Edward Walter "Moose" Krause, was angrily exiting to the press box to join the team in the visitor’s locker room.
“I remember him turning to one of his staffers and saying, ‘We didn’t make any damn adjustments,’ loud enough for all of us to hear,” Hillgrove recalled. “My thought was, ‘How do you adjust to that?’”
And Hillgrove wasn’t the only one with that line of thinking.
“We tried to make normal adjustments,” Devine told reporters during his postgame availability, “but one guy kind of dominated the game, which made all the adjustments inadequate.”
As Notre Dame licked its wounds, still wondering what had just unfolded, the Panthers celebrated.
“It was a fun night in Oakland,” Brzoza said with a laugh. “I’ll just leave it at that.”
Pitt’s win over Notre Dame earned the program an invitation to the Sun Bowl. It went on to beat Kansas in that game, 33-19, for the first bowl victory since 1937. But the good times were just beginning for the Panthers.
“It was definitely a step to put us on the map and get people talking about us nationally,” Wannstedt said. “Notre Dame was always really good. If you could beat them, you were going to be in the conversation on a national stage. And that’s exactly what happened.”
Dorsett’s effort was the biggest story in the sports world the following day. He was known throughout college football before. But his performance made him a household name.
November 8, 1976
— Kevin Gallagher (@KevG163) November 8, 2025
The cover of Sports Illustrated
"Heading for the Heisman"#Pitt Panthers and future #Cowboys star running back Tony Dorsett pic.twitter.com/SeJ1UEdDmz
“It solidified what everybody was talking about,” Sherrill said. “They knew about this running back from Pittsburgh who set the freshman record for rushing. You had a lot of people that had been talking about Tony, but not a lot of people had seen him. … They learned what we already knew: that there was only one Tony Dorsett.”
Pitt opened the 1976 season ranked No. 9 in the country, an unimaginable achievement to many who watched the same school finish 1-10 less than four years prior. The year started with a 31-10 road victory over — you guessed it — the Fighting Irish.
Prior to the game, Notre Dame legend and 1956 Heisman Trophy winner Paul Hornung famously said he’d “jump out a press box window” if Dorsett rushed for over 200 yards. The Panthers’ star nearly made Hornung eat his words, reaching 181 yards on the ground before being pulled with eight minutes remaining. In the end, Dorsett rushed for 754 in his four career matchups against the team that once deemed him “too small” to wear its colors.
The rest, as they say, is history.
Pitt ran the table, finishing 12-0 to capture the program’s ninth national championship. After finishing fourth in Heisman voting in 1975, Dorsett won the award in a landslide in 1976. He concluded his collegiate career with 6,082 rushing yards, a record that remained untouched until it was surpassed by Rickey Williams (Texas) in 1998.
No University of Pittsburgh team has won a national championship since, nor has any Pitt football player won a Heisman Trophy. Those two honors remain perhaps the best team and individual achievements in the school’s rich athletic history.
And both were sparked by one big win over the Fighting Irish.
“I can't believe it has been 50 years,” Dorsett wrote. “That game is a cherished memory for me. I meet people all the time who still mention that game. I am a Western Pa. native, so to be able to bring the excitement and joy to the Pitt Panthers fans against a team that didn't believe in me was just icing on the cake.
“Forever, Hail to Pitt!”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.